Seattle, WA
Tasted Sunday, January 7, 2007 by Eric with 1,904 views
As is his wont, Roy Hersh decided to assemble a historic tasting of Madeira. So 15 lucky souls descended upon Kaspar's on a windy Seattle winter eve to sip Madeira.
Sercial
First we started with a lovely, almost bracing pair of Sercial. I don’t have a lot of Madeira experience, but these were most reminiscent of incredibly powerful Sherry, very tart, salt and showing a citric personality. They were both gorgeous wines and a great way to kick off the tasting.
Verdelho
Next we moved onto four different Verdelho's. In general, I found the Verdelho and Bual wines to represent the 'sweet spot' of the tasting for me. I very much enjoyed the Sercial we started with and Malmsey/Malvazia we had later. But these earlier wines struck a more vibrant, and for me more pleasurable, balance.
Bastardo
The second flight started off with a sole Bastardo. A rare, red-graped Madeira, vintage wines from this varietal were apparently only produced in 1870, 1875, 1876 an 1927.
Boal/Bual
Next we moved to an impressive quartet of Boal/Bual wines. For me these next four wines were probably the highlight of the tasting.
Terrantez
As with the last flight, we started off with a singleton, in this case a Terrantez.
Malvasia/Malmsey
Now we moved onto a quartet of Malmsey/Malvasia wines (The names are interchangeable, as Malmsey is just the term for the Malvasia varietal.) Many expected these wines to represent the highlight of the tasting, but 3 of 4 wines seemed to underperform, a bit of a letdown after such a spectacular start. Now mind you, these were all highly enjoyable but just not as ethereal as we hoped for. Or perhaps I was simply expressing more of a palate preference for the somewhat more dry Bual and Verdelho examples vs. the richer caramel of the Malvasia.
Moscatel
Finally we finished up with one example of Moscatel.
Conclusion
All in all, this was a rather remarkable tasting that is certainly going to lead to me chasing down a few special examples of Madeira. What is nice is that you can uncork a truly special bottle and enjoy it slowly for a year with no degradation. There is no other wine like that to be sure!
1862 D'Oliveiras Madeira Sercial Reserva
Portugal, Madeira
Slightly cloudy. A piquant nose with pickled capers and some VA. Wow, this is getting much more expressive and floral. Mmm, salt and limes, very dry. Lots of acid on the mouthwatering finish with lime and citrus dominating. This is very refreshing and intense, a true "laser" of a wine. There is a slightly bitter note of peanut skin on the finish. Of the two Sercials, this was my preferred wine, as I found it to be more consistent and harmonious.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Report Issue
1898 Barbeito Madeira Sercial
Portugal, Madeira
Gorgeous, shimmering gold in the glass. The nose is a little more dusty with some stink, sort of a brackish salt marsh thing. The palate shows honey moving to salt and with some nuts on the finish. This is a richer wine than the 1862 D'Oliveira Sercial and is very appealing. At the same time, this lacks the cut that makes the D'Oliveira so interesting.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Report Issue