Search Results - Save This Search

Wine Type Vintage Name Variety Locale Date Posted Score Helpful Comments Comment Date Community Score More...
White

1978 Domaine de la Romanée-Conti Montrachet

Montrachet Grand Cru Chardonnay more

7/1/2013 - The Gilded Sage wrote: NR

A wine of almost religious splendor. A proper tasting note can only be crafted in Latin:

Vinum pulchritudine praecellebat. Aurea et exquisita. Gustavi saepius ista, et nusquam erat attonitus tanto minus perfectum. De naribus, est redolens nox Aenean-comantem, et tamquam mollis aer texta est quod defert ut odorem. Est aetherea, intactilis omnibus rebus optimum in vita. Unius Provinciae olim noctes admonitus, cum de fenestra patefacta amet, sola scientia crevit furor momentum quod etiam finem, et in illo veterasce tempus est caro pueri. Cano, libet lamentari quisque recessit sorbere.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    5/20/2015 2:30:00 PM - Quidquid latine dictum sit, altum videtur, innit!

Red

NV Areni Winery Areni Areni of Yeghegnadzor

Vayots Dzor more

12/16/2014 - The Gilded Sage wrote: NR

I have listed this wine as non-vintage, since the precise year of its vinification remains unknown to me (predating, as it does, the dawn of written history), and because cellartracker has no function for the input of dates preceding the common era. Radiocarbon dating, however, suggests that the amphora—excavated from the Areni-1 winery in Armenia—dates from somewhere in the fourth millennium B.C.E.

This was double-decanted, at the suggestion of my manservant, Aloysius, to remove a light sediment, then enjoyed over the course of five or six hours. Some bricking was visible at the edges, befitting a wine whose production coincided with the commencement of the bronze age, but in all other respects it remained youthful and energetic.

The wine was served alongside a once-extinct species of Armenian Ibex, lately resurrected through cloning. Spit-roasted over a wood fire and then braised in its own blood and viscera, the meal proved an ideal accompaniment, accentuating the rich gaminess of the wine.

Ever scarce, the Areni-1 Proprietary Red is nonetheless worthy of one's best efforts at procurement. This particular vintage seems to be approaching its peak drinking window, and should provide enjoyment for at least another nine-hundred years.

Consistent with previous notes.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    5/20/2015 1:52:00 PM - Parker nailed this wine!

Red

2005 Le Vieux Donjon Châteauneuf-du-Pape

Red Rhone Blend more

5/15/2015 - StefanAkiko Likes this wine: 87 points

A solid Grenache wine with Rhône typicity.

Colour: dark red with slightly maturing brim.
Nose: non-descript shy Grenache aromas with herbal qualities. A very humble part of "La Garrigue."
Palate: with all the anticipation that comes from knowing what you will have and what so many others think... Our first impression was: total faceplant. But, this is a solid Grenache based wine. Not much more. And not showing much potential for the future either...

Terribly poor QPR.

One more btl, hoping and praying to Thor, Huitaca, Athena, Vishnu and the Flying Spaghetti-Monster for a complete makeover until 2021. Or, maybe we just got a poorer btl than you other guys...

Home dinner, wonderfully cooked WAGYU and giant green asparagus by wife (same wine score).

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    5/16/2015 1:22:00 AM - Flying spaghetti monster is the one true god. Everyone knows that. He is solely responsible for punishing stefan mainly because stefan is a very naughty boy.

Red

2013 Marcel Lapierre Morgon

Gamay more

4/30/2015 - stubbie999 Likes this wine: NR

Super tight right now, but everything you could want in a Morgon. Maybe not as good a vintage as '12 or '10, but no matter - still good. Floral, poised, elegant and waiting to unfurl. Don't stick these at the back of the cellar, but maybe wait a bit before opening the next one...

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    4/30/2015 2:36:00 PM - " Don't stick these at the back of the cellar, but maybe wait a bit before opening the next one... " - really good advice!

Red

2007 Chateau Musar

Bekaa Valley Red Blend more

5/31/2014 - pjaines Likes this wine: NR

Plumper and much sweeter than previous releases, this has a lot more up-front fruit certainly than the 05 and 04. Already drinkable but I think the fruit needs to back off a touch and the structure (of what there is) come to the fore to give it more balance. There is a concern that this veers towards the more fruit-bomb end of the Musar spectrum. For me this is worth a punt to stick in the cellar to see what happens.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    4/26/2015 9:05:00 AM - Stefan - I will take you at your word and buy some more. One can never have enough Musar (if only to freak out people who prefer International Bland Style Wine)

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    4/27/2015 12:40:00 AM - I think you'll find Mr Hochar is dead, Stefan. A shame. Would love to come to Sweden though. Does surstromming match with Musar?

Red

2007 Domaine Tollot-Beaut Beaune 1er Cru Clos du Roi

Pinot Noir more

4/17/2015 - pjaines Likes this wine: NR

The more I drink 2007 Burgs the more I like them - this is bang on point - light, clear, refined but with a firmness that sits well with the taut fruit. Firm cherry stone and minerals sit well on top of the tannins and structure. Good to go now.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    4/19/2015 2:51:00 AM - 07 is my go-to vintage at the moment as my 05s and 11s mature. I'm really enjoying the lightweight nature of most of the wines.

Red

2008 Château Figeac

St. Émilion Grand Cru Red Bordeaux Blend more

10/16/2014 - Wineguy76 wrote: 84 points

This bottle of the 2008 Figeac performed somewhat better than the first one I tasted but I remain underwhelmed - despite the overdone passion of some of the other reviewers on this site. Displaying a thick, deep ruby core, the wine has some promising fragrant aromas of cassis, chocolate and graphite. It is full bodied and pleases the palate with a soft and silky texture. However the tannic structure is alarmingly light and the flavours muted and hollow; and while there are some enjoyable notes of raspberry, burnt tar and caramel to speak of it clearly lacks the concentration, depth, precision and intensity I would expect from a wine of this stature. The fairly long finish does make up somewhat for the overall shortcomings of this disappointing Figeac. A good wine? Yes. A great wine? Surely not - and for similar value the vintage has far, far better to offer. Drink it over the next five years as it does not possess the structure or complexity to last beyond that.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    10/17/2014 1:09:00 AM - To be fair you marked it up 3 points from before!

    Mine are sitting in the cellar in France so I'll have to wait until I am back there before cracking one. I did have some 2005 Figeac the other night - now THAT is a wine that will take another 20 years to round - amazing depth.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    10/17/2014 1:48:00 AM - The feeling in the industry is that Figeac will be undergoing a bit of a style change with the new leadership team - which is a shame - I've always loved the wine for its a-typical make up. I guess more Gobs of Fruit and oak looks like the plan.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    10/17/2014 2:03:00 AM - Not had the 09 and 10 and I refuse to buy them because the prices are utterly utterly ridiculoius. They managed to alienate people who purchased the wine every year. I'm not buying at the new price level - hopefully they have seen the error of their ways and the 2011 and 2012 are more sensibly priced, but if they are chasing Grand Cru Classe A classicification then price is one of the parameters used to gain promotion so I'd expect another increase soon. A shame.

    I found the 2007 surprisingly good and woud drink well quite young.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    4/8/2015 12:44:00 AM - Well, I finally got to taste another bottle from my cellar and found the wine to be much deeper and broader than before. I actually found this to have the stuffing for some decent ageing, although not sure this is a 20 year wine.

Red

2013 Yvon Métras Beaujolais

Gamay more

3/20/2015 - the godfather wrote: NR

just a gorgeous nose but something very cherried on the palate. 24 hours of air does this much good.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    3/21/2015 2:28:00 PM - I'm looking forward to trying the "ordinary" (if you could ever use that word for Metras) Beaujolais - I find the Moulin-a-vent a Morgon simply wonderful....have a few stacked up in the cellar so might broach one soon.

White

2008 Domaine Vocoret et Fils Chablis 1er Cru Montée de Tonnerre

Chardonnay more

6/28/2013 - Waynescoting Likes this wine: 91 points

I'm not 100% sure I've correctly identified this wine because the label, an image of which I'll upload, looks different from one that another reviewer uploaded. Also, I'm an inexperienced taster.

I greatly enjoyed this wine that--based on earlier reviews--I'm drinking late. It was a pale yellow and relatively full-feeling compared to most whites I've had, dry but it didn't seem excessively so, buttery with some earthiness, even a tiny bit of spice perhaps. It's the best white-wine experience I've had in quite some time, and I thought I disliked Chardonnay! Any feedback from other tasters as to why this Chardonnay experience seemed so categorically superior would be appreciated. The answer may be, perhaps, that I've mostly been exposed in the past to American Chardonnays (and probably on the mid-to-low-end of the price scale).

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    10/28/2014 10:00:00 AM - Interesting note - you'll find that Chablis is much leaner and more mineral than a lot of the US Chardonnays, which feel very heavy and over oaked and buttery to the European palate.
    Good Chablis (in my opinion anyway) should have a very taut and lean mineral base - the Grand Cru chabis do have more depth of fruit but never that flabby, softer feel of some other Chardonnays. Good luck with discovering more - I love Chablis and think it is one of the great bargains when it comes to white wines.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    3/20/2015 8:43:00 AM - Yes, those soils and rocks are pretty special down there in Chablis - a great Chablis should really show that mineral spine.

Red

2005 Domaine Paul Autard Châteauneuf-du-Pape Cuvée La Cote Ronde

Red Rhone Blend more

3/7/2015 - Wine-Strategies wrote: NR

After the experience with the bottle I opened just 5 weeks ago, I really didn't see the point in taking up space unnecessarily with this final bottle. While it's my preference to put some age on wines in general, there are the exceptions - wines that show much better in their youth; this appears to be one of those exceptions. Held since release, this was charmless. Again. Well composed, technically, but absent the verve and nuance I'm always looking for. If you've got some, and you haven't checked (at all?) in a while, I recommend doing so. Medium-bodied, avg acidity, red fruited; no complexity. 14,5% abv (fully resolved). Drink now.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    3/8/2015 12:39:00 AM - Are you sure it is not just in a closed phase? I found these wines very age worthy....I had a 2000 recently and found it very decent....

Red

2007 Château La Commanderie de Mazeyres

Pomerol Red Bordeaux Blend more

10/27/2013 - pjaines wrote: NR

Pretty unmemorable at first, but I came back to this the next day after it had been left unforgotten in the kitchen like a ginger-stepchild......and it had turned into a reasonable passable Bordeaux. A touch of leafy elements in there (Cab Franc?) counterbalanced by decent enough black fruit. Nice, quaffable Bordeaux of a quality elevated slightly above the hoi-polloi.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    2/22/2015 12:21:00 PM - To be honest Stefan I really can't remember drinking this wine at all. Even when I see the label I come up blank.

Red

2010 Louis Jadot Corton-Pougets Domaine des Héritiers Louis Jadot

Corton Grand Cru Pinot Noir more

2/19/2015 - pjaines Likes this wine: NR

Like sneaking into some weird and wonderful sex club where strange and exotic things are just about to happen - the sap of anticipation rises - booom - then someone slams the door in your face. This has a tickle, a tease, a whiff of what is to come - all nuance and innuendo and then it shuts down and you can but just about imagine what excess lies ahead - a cornucopia of terroir and black fruit and minerals most likely. Oh sweet goddess of time please pass so one can kiss thine lips. Come quickly.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    2/19/2015 2:01:00 PM - Well, gin was last night.....tonight was Jadot Grand Cru and a stunning Benoit Droin Chablis Montee de Tonnerre 2012

Red

2010 Domaine Sylvain Pataille Marsannay Les Longeroies

Pinot Noir more

2/13/2015 - kingkanu Likes this wine: 89 points

medium light body with quite a dark tone to it. the nose has a bit of meat and smoke to it, the fruit isnt overly present on the nose. the palate is fairly bright with nice acidity, there's a fair bit going on but its a bit young and tight right now, the tannins are pretty fine and they coat the tongue, there's a good length of flavour, it seems to have all the parts, a bit more time will see if they all fall into place as well as i'd hope.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    2/13/2015 12:53:00 PM - I'm actually drinking this right now - had a bottle last night that was a bit off, but tonight it is all about gritty soil and terroir. Great value.

Red

2008 Produttori del Barbaresco Barbaresco

Nebbiolo more

1/9/2015 - Barolo Drunkard wrote: 94 points

Aromas of oak, tar, rasberries, strawberries, forrest floor, leather.
On the palate bright strawberries, and sour cherry, but in restrained manner. The fruit is almost like in a classy suit, talking Philosophy. It really is almost a clone of many 08 Barbarescos I´ve had recently. Restrained, austere, earthy, classy, delicious. Tannins are firm but polished. Earthy, dry and very savory. Salty aftertaste with nice rasberry, tobacco, and cocoa and ashy tannins. Old world at its best! All the elements of a classic Barbaresco, and the classical 08 vintage seems to highlight that even more. A hallmark of the vintage. I`m pretty convinced I would recognize this as an 08 Barbaresco in a blind tasting. A wine I would like to drink on a fishing trip, at a campfire, somewhere in Lapland, with self caught and grilled trout. And smoke a bowl of pipe after. Its very "manly" wine.
Great showing from the cooperative.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    1/19/2015 10:08:00 AM - Great tasting note - I found the 08 much more open and nuanced than I was expecting. I'll be sticking a load more in the cellar - this is such a good value wine.

Red

2013 Domaine Henri Gouges Nuits St. Georges

Pinot Noir more

1/15/2015 - pjaines wrote: NR

OW Loeb Burgundy 2013 En Primeur Tasting; 1/14/2015-1/15/2015 (London): Really stood out from the pack (not in a good way) with its mealy, rich, oaty palate - reductive as the previous taster has said - very ripe and plummy.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    1/17/2015 5:24:00 AM - I usually like Gouges but I guess compared to the rest they seemed quite plump and ripe. I'd like to taste again once it has been in bottle for a year or two.

Red

2011 Domaine Sylvain Pataille Marsannay les Grasses Têtes

Pinot Noir more

4/20/2014 - vagabond2009 Likes this wine: 90 points

Such dark, dense colour for a 2011. Opened out of curiousity based on OW Loeb's enthusiastic review. (they called Sylvain the Hero Of The Vintage or something like that). Really intense character but very much shut doors for now. Silky, ripe blue fruit character with not a peek of the pyrazine greeness that seems to have reared it's head in some 2011s. This requires a good rest in the rack for now.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    1/13/2015 4:46:00 AM - I'm looking forward to Loeb's tasting tomorrow in London - I find these Pataille Marsannays absolutely brilliant across the range - especially given the relatively modest price. Stick with 2011/12 or go for the 2013s? Hopefully they have his wines on tasting tomorrow.

Red

2004 Alter Ego de Palmer

Margaux Red Bordeaux Blend more

12/11/2014 - whybuyone Does not like this wine: 80 points

Ugh. Do not bother. If you own it, try to sell it. Even if it's for half of what you paid. Take the money and buy something you know you like. I've had several second labels (Echo from Lynch Bages comes to mind) and they never come anywhere close to the first labels. 2004 isn't considered a spectacular vintage but I've had '04 California wines which were far superior for a third of the price.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    12/12/2014 11:52:00 AM - I can see why you didn't like this - I think the 04 Bordeaux (especially the 2nd wines) are coming up way short. I quite liked this wine, to be honest, but in general I find 2nd wines a waste of money.

Red

2011 Château de Pennautier Cabardès l'Esprit de Pennautier

Red Blend more

12/7/2014 - pjaines wrote: NR

The standard Pennautier is one of those nice little secrets that always dish up a rustic, but balanced, Bordeaux experience. They've gone all double-bluff here with the Esprit which makes it sound like a second wine until you see the bottle which is enough to snap off a mans foot at the ankle if you dropped it. Coming it at a rather eye boggling 14.5% this looks like a wine that would have Fruit Bombers frothing themselves into a frenzy of expectation. The reality is a little more nuanced - yes, there is more oak, yes there is more body but there is still that Pennautier green, herbal tang and is well made. Is it worth the 60% markup from the standard wine? No, I prefer its more simple charms (which are, by the way, quite wonderful). This isnt that bad though - consider it like a good friend who has gone for a full plastic surgery make over and you say "well, it wasn't as bad as I thought it would be"

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    12/7/2014 12:30:00 PM - Glad you liked the note - I do love Pennautier's standard wine - lovely juice which is about £8 over here in Ye Olde Englande. I can see why Pennautier released this wine, but my guess is they just pumped more oak and glass at the decent grapes they already had.

White

2009 Clos Rougeard (Foucault) Brézé

Saumur Chenin Blanc more

3/4/2014 - JOsgood wrote: 94 points

In a word awesome. I can see why this wine is so sought after and hyped by the geeks. Deep nose with notes of petrol. Oily and coating on the palate. One for the cellar but delicious right now.

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    12/2/2014 3:06:00 PM - Geeks! Yup. It really is a geek wine.....but sooooo goooood.

Red

2004 Château Chasse-Spleen

Moulis en Médoc Red Bordeaux Blend more

11/24/2014 - Lars A wrote: flawed

Bought 12+1 some years ago. The one bottle was for testing purposes tonfind out if the wine could stand cellaring untill.my sons confirmation in 4 years time.
Totally corked wine made this assessment impossible so now I.must rely on notes here from CT.
So PLEASE help me if you can
...

  • Comment posted by pjaines:

    11/24/2014 12:44:00 PM - My fear is that the 2004s in general are not turning into very good wines - this one I had a couple of years back and it showed a rather scratchy palate. I like my wines reasonably austere but the 04s are generally lacking a bit of something for me right now. I'm hoping a few more years might do something, but I doubt sprinkling the wines with pixie dust will be one of them.

Loading wine details...
loading

×
×