Older nose, touch sherried. Sherry palate, wood, furniture wax, over the hill. Others enjoyed it.

Sweet strawberry nose, grenache-y. Interesting mix of sweet and tart strawberries, nice acidity, long tart finish. Thought this was a California rose of grenache.

Sweet plum nose, touch of leather, very nice. Fresh blackberries and plums. Light to medium bodied with nice medium acidity. Youthful, very little tannin. Finishes just a tad hot, otherwise really nice. (my 3rd, group's 4th)

Baked black cherries and dried flowers on the nose. Nice weight in the mouth, ripe blackberry fruit with a hint of herbs. Medium to full bodied, medium acidity, moderate tannins. Still youthful with the most structure of the flight. Should continue to improve. (my 2nd, group's 5th)

Delicate nose of raspberries and strawberries. Light bodied with medium acidity. Pretty and red fruited in the mouth with hints of earth and tea. An outlier in this flight, understated and lovely. (my 1st, group's 6th)

My pour had chunky sediment but it stayed at the bottom of my glass. Started a bit funky, with some horsey brett, but it wasn't offensive. Spicy in the mouth, slightly bretty with charcoal and an earthy finish. Moderate+ tannins, still needs time. (my 4th, group's 1st)

Sweet, kirsch nose. Sweet raspberry syrup and jam, a bit of heat and some baking spice on the finish. Overripe for my palate. Not my style but others liked it. (my 6th, group's 3rd)

No score b/c my pour had lots of fine sediment that didn't settle and made it difficult to evaluate. Dark raspberry nose, touch of spicy brett. Sweet black cherries, kirsch, chewy tannins. (my 7th, group's 2nd)

Sweet, acetone nose. Acetone palate, flawed. (my 8th, group's 8th)

Muddled, warm, baked black fruit. Round, black plum juice palate. Simple but not terrible. Others thought it was oxidized. (my 5th, group's 7th)