Professional reviews have copyrights and you can view them here for your personal use only as private content. To view pro reviews you must either subscribe to a pre-integrated publication or manually enter reviews. Learn more.Manage Subscriptions
2005 Kistler Chardonnay Dutton Ranch
- > California
- > Sonoma County
- > Russian River Valley
Community Tasting Notes 96
hsacks Likes this wine: (91 points)
January 17, 2015 - Deep gold color. Despite some obvious signs of oxidation, the wine still had excellent fruit and acidity and was delicious with my wke's spicy spot prawns.
PGB wrote: (80 points)
July 9, 2014 - This wine has not stood the test of time. Old, brown, and very unpleasant. So then I opened a bottle of the Hudson 04. Same result. And this is not the first time. Then I opened a Kistler "Kistler" vineyard. Still holding its own and mellowing nicely. For whatever reason the 04 and 05 Hudson, Vine Hill and Dutton have a problem. To be safe drink your Kistler Chardonnays in the first 7 years while they still taste great.
May 24, 2014 - solid shape for 9 year old CA chard...good acidity, length solid but secondary flavors were good not outstanding. I think this bottle has a life left... not sure it will get better but could add complexity.
sunalsorises wrote: (89 points)
March 16, 2014 - A bit off in the beginning. Cloudy. Got better with time but not as enjoyable as other 2005s.
lebo Does not like this wine: (80 points)
October 11, 2013 - Very disappointing. See my prior note. Time has not been kind to this wine. Nose had new world butterscotch / caramel popcorn immediately upon open, but that quickly faded to just an "aged wine" nose. Not in a complex or elegant way, but in a tired way. Palate really didn't have much flavor to it at all. My note from 3 years ago was "...tasted like water...". Well, now it tastes like old water. This was a wine to be consumed young. Live and learn. Trust YOUR palate!
Pro Reviews 1
Stephen Tanzer's International Wine Cellar
By Josh Raynolds
May/June 2008, Issue #138 (link)
(Kistler Vineyards Chardonnay Dutton Ranch Russian River Valley) Subscribe to see review text.
- Vintage 2005
- Type White
- Producer Kistler
- Varietal Chardonnay
- Designation n/a
- Vineyard Dutton Ranch
- Country USA
- Region California
- SubRegion Sonoma County
- Appellation Russian River Valley
- Pending Delivery 17 (1%)
- In Cellars 1471 (48%)
- Consumed 1578 (51%)