Professional reviews have copyrights and you can view them here for your personal use only as private content. To view pro reviews you must either subscribe to a pre-integrated publication or manually enter reviews. Learn more.Manage Subscriptions
2005 Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon Hillside Select
- > California
- > Napa Valley
- > Stags Leap District
Community Tasting Notes 89
jamie24 Likes this wine: (91 points)
September 19, 2014 - My first bottle of hillside select. Very ripe and fruit forward. Almost Shiraz like and verging on overdone. Blueberry and violets. Not my preferred style of cab sav but enjoyable and well made. Will hold off a few more years on remaining bottles in the hope it mellows.
thi nguyen Likes this wine: (94 points)
September 6, 2014 - Dry fruit after 3 hour decant .some tobacco leaf .green pepper .round tanning. complexity layer good long finish .
Loren Sonkin wrote: (99 points)
July 20, 2014 - Screagle, Kapcsandy, SHS, Abreu, Maybach, Donnhoff, etc., etc. (Downtown Cleveland): What a great winery. Every bottle flirts with perfection. Sometimes I think because it hits perfection 2 or 3 times a decade the wines scoring only in the high 90's don't get the respect they deserve. This was amazing. The WOTN for many. The nose has cassis, pencil lead, tea leaves and some vanilla. On the palate, lovely texture. seamless. Cassis, complex layers of earth and fruit, medium silky tannins. Long finish. This bottle had been slow oxed for 12 hours and I think that worked well. even then, it got better and better in the glass. Sadly, everyone took large pours, so there was no going back for seconds. This is a wine that deserves First Growth status.3 people found this helpful Comments (1)
Sundbyberg wrote: (91 points)
July 18, 2014 - Nice, dark, fruit and so on, but nothing that makes it stand out from the crowd of well done, quite sweet, high-end American redwines, loved by Parker. Lacks finesse and elegance and is fairly unstructured. To me, Mondavi reserve is the best buy among these type of wines, if considering value for money.
Opened 24 hours in advance followed by a 1-2 hour decant, which was necessary.
McKraftyWino Likes this wine: (93 points)
May 17, 2014 - on a night filled with 2005 cabs this was good but not the best (surprisingly since we all love Shafer Hillside Select!)
very tight. it was consumed later and not decanted so probably suffered in comparison to the earlier decanted 2005
still has decades of life left and hasn't really opened up yet.
Pro Reviews 1
Stephen Tanzer's International Wine Cellar
By Stephen Tanzer
May/June 2007, Issue #132 (link)
(Shafer Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Hillside Select Stags Leap District) Subscribe to see review text.
- Vintage 2005
- Type Red
- Producer Shafer
- Varietal Cabernet Sauvignon
- Designation Hillside Select
- Vineyard n/a
- Country USA
- Region California
- SubRegion Napa Valley
- Appellation Stags Leap District
- Pending Delivery 48 (1%)
- In Cellars 3727 (82%)
- Consumed 790 (17%)