Community Tasting Note

G_H wrote:

Sunday, January 5, 2014 - A BBR bottling, this was definitely past its prime and over the hill, followed it for about four hours, but that did not help, the acidity and barnyard notes just became stronger. This one is over when I add the other cellartracker notes to my own impression...

That brings me to a question: how do you rate wines that are neither flawed nor defective but clearly over the hill? Do you rate it low? (This was a mid-70's experience) or do you rate it as flawed, or just not at all?

Post a Comment / View G_H's profile
Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Report Issue (4,795 views)