etherscreen

User #12,048 signed up 1/31/2006 and last accessed 5/23/2015

Member since January 2006

This user's profile is not public.

  • 2010 MacDonald Cabernet Sauvignon

    There are so few data points on this wine, I believed this would be a worthy, although perhaps unexpected, contribution.

    I followed the winery's instructions, giving this a 24 hour double decant.

    The nose is a bit monolithic showing of dark fruits and oak elements of cocoa powder, spice, and graham cracker. There is a background herbal component as well. There is not, however, a sort of three dimensionalism that I associate with more complex wines.

    This walks the line with ripeness for me. I can only equate this to many '07 cali cabs showing a similar characteristic. It seems to fade over time, however. Full mouthfeel, just shy of syrupy. There is a touch of etoh. Is it elegant? Not really? Is it noble? Nope. Is there a defining characteristic other than being well made that makes this worthy of the price of admission? Sorry.

    Frankly, I'm at a loss here. The pedigree is obviously second to none. The enthusiasm from those with palates I deeply respect, I cannot explain. Let me be clear, that this is a flawless and very well constructed wine. Many folks will derive great pleasure from this. At the same time, it is not a distinctive wine, and it is one that would easily disappear in a sea of those similar to it.

    I anxiously await the thoughts of those who've also tried it.

    1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No / Comment

  • 2011 Antica Terra Pinot Noir Botanica

    Interesting showing for this bottle. At first sip this was interesting, yet after minutes, it recoiled into a shell shocked state. I came back about 30 min later and it had already blossomed.

    Complex nose of red fruits, tea, thyme, white flowers, and jasmine. Light in the mouth with a slightly sappy quality to the fruit. A crushed shell like minerality in the mouth. A wine that makes you think. Lacking some acid, but not flabby. I have no doubt that this will be fantastic in some years time, but worth a look now if you're unsure what AT is all about.

    While this was good, I much prefer the ceras as this point.

    Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Comment

  • 2010 Copain Pinot Noir Anderson Valley

    oh my has this changed...for the worse.

    boring nose of cherries and oak that is nearly indistinguishable from an $20 grocery store pinot. the acid in this wine has really fallen off in the past year. finish is clipped. this is not what copain is about.

    Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Comment

View all 498 Tasting Notes

Message Board Post Public Message

  • No messages posted.

×
×