Didn't really know what to expect with this wine, but when i found a sticky sediment in my cellar and traced it back to this bottle, I decided it was time to open and consume. The Plata didn't seem affected by the loss of containment. It's a heavy wine with a turgid personality that is a mouthful whether you like it or not. If you like that sort of thing, the Plata is a great example and worthy of praise. If your taste runs more toward subtlety than overt expression, like mine, you can still appreciate this in the same way a Pug owner appreciates a classic Great Dane: as a great example of Dog. I give it a 96 for what it is and an 88 for what I like in wine. Consensus 91.
Opened literally months ago, and came back to it at irregular intervals. It is as other tasters describe, pretty much; but I found it just a little much. Though it's got lively acidity, the raisin & caramel sweetness, and heck, possibly just the amplitude of flavor, made it a touch cloying/fatiguing for me - though I can completely understand that it'd translate to high-volume excitement to others. I'm in no hurry to open my other bottle.
I can't begin to say how disappointed I am. In myself. For some reason which defies explanation, I bought only one of this offering from Jon at Garagiste. As is our custom for a decade or so at NYE, we gather with our close friends for food and drink to ring in the new year. I have become the supplier of the evening's dessert wine by some quirk of habit. I search for an interesting and unique bottle all year long, from Tawny to Tokaji. This PX blew everyone away. Raisins, caramel, coffee on the nose and palate. Thick and viscous, luscious and rich, beauty in a glass. Paired with slightly-sweet Guinness chocolate cake. It was, in a word, perfection.
Professional reviews have copyrights and you can view them here for your personal use only as private content. To view pro reviews you must either subscribe to a pre-integrated publication or manually enter reviews below. Learn more.