Bordeaux WIMPS (La Tromplette, Chiswick): Aromatic, savoury, red fruit, cedar, spice. Decent depth on the palate, spicy red fruit, fine, almost resolved tannin, very good length finish. Very good indeed ***1\2
After slow oxing for a couple hours, the nose had developed what seemed to be some mild TCA underneath an otherwise aromatic nose of black fruit and earth tones. The palate, however, was in a great place, with lots of tertiary flavors of leather, pepper and herbs complementing the fairly dense fruit.
Blind Dinner at Mark's (Chicago, IL): Served blind. Really funky nose. I think there's some mild TCA going on here, though the palate doesn't seem to show it at all. Really barnyardy. Cabernet-based for sure, from the green pepper tones. Very earthy as well, I called this as a Bordeaux from the mid 80s. Very austere, with some flavours of leather and tobacco as well. Drying up, drink these sooner rather than later.
Professional reviews have copyrights and you can view them here for your personal use only as private content. To view pro reviews you must either subscribe to a pre-integrated publication or manually enter reviews below. Learn more.
(Talbot) The second flight led off with the 1986 Talbot. There were lots of green beans and olives in the nose, which was a bit waxy and spiny, though also clean. Some tickling crushed red fruits rounded out the nose, which also had a little bathwater edge to it. The palate was much more classic; it had sweet, tasty and nutty fruit and a spicy palate that had mineral, earth and game flavors. Sweet cassis, nut and caramel flavors were also there. It was thick in the mouth but balanced, classic and delicious despite a bit of awkwardness to its aromatics (93).
(Chateau Talbot St Julien) Surprisingly a tawny rim - this is a relatively youthful wine. The nose has classic rich ink and liquorice. Smooth palate, good tannins, acidity good, well balanced, nice fruit. Smoky notes give some complexity. Finishes smoothly. Good length.
NOTE: Some content is property of JancisRobinson.com and RJonWine.com and Vintage Tastings and Winedoctor.