Who Likes This Wine(8)

  1. BordeauxBoy


    66 Tasting Notes

  2. Nanda


    3,170 Tasting Notes

  3. Eric Guido

    Eric Guido

    3,150 Tasting Notes


Food Pairing Tags

Add My Food Pairing Tags

Community Tasting Notes (64) Avg Score: 91.3 points

  • No visible age showing. Popped and poured and this one was very strange from the start, kind of bitter and really lacking any fruit flavor initially. After about an hour some fruit began to emerge and filled out the palate a bit, but still was lacking fruit or interest overall. I'd say this was still possibly improving at the end of the bottle (2hr) but the overall impression left me wondering whether I should have popped it right off the truck and enjoyed it for its great fruit profile when young? I still have a vertical of 06-08 so maybe a side by side with a decant is in order...

    Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Comment

  • PnP at home after attending wine dinner with sweetish, mediocre wines. Perfect antidote. Opaque. Dense, earthy mouthfeel. Started with plum and blackberry, with a hint of cherry/strawberry, plus middle eastern spices. Finish was shortish, but intense. Dry. Earthy. Not a hint of fruit jam. As it opened, the flavors swirled and separated, with the red fruit stepping up, and the finish lengthened. VacUVined and refrigerated the rest for a party 2 days from now. Stay tuned. NOTE: this bottle was stored for two years in a shipping case in a closet, and not cellared properly, so it might have matured a little quicker.

    Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Comment

  • Was in a celebratory mood so pulled a wine that I thought would have some gravitas. Have enjoyed the '06 vintage from Carlisle over time, but this drank surprisingly young. Intense, black fruit and structure. Only started to unwind after a hour or two of air. Much bigger, but also better wine than the '05 version. Will hold my remaining '06 for at least a two more years. Once softened with air, started getting some blood sausage, a hint of garrique, and some base iron qualities. But the grip of the fruit still dominates today.

    Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Comment

  • Have been cellaring well since I received from Carlisle. Popped and started pouring. This bottle is great. Great concentrated dark fruit with some real tarry dirt and a little white pepper on the nose and pallet. Almost northern Rhone early on. I am really glad I decided to wait on this bottle because at 9 years old, it was really good. A little tartness after open about 4 hours so I'm not sure this will get any better.

    Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Comment

  • Robust black fruit, spice and camphor nose. Palate is still richly fruited but the wine has shed its fat and sheer concentration. It's a big but silky and mellow wine. In a good spot.

    Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Comment

View all 64 Community Tasting Notes

What Do You Think? Add a Tasting Note

Professional reviews have copyrights and you can view them here for your personal use only as private content. To view pro reviews you must either subscribe to a pre-integrated publication or manually enter reviews below. Learn more.


  • By Josh Raynolds
    May/June 2008, IWC Issue #138, (See more on Vinous...)

    (Carlisle Winery Syrah Cardiac Hill Bennett Valley) Subscribe to see review text.

NOTE: Some content is property of Vinous.

Add a Pro Review Add Your Own Reviews: