The Plumed Horse Restaurant, Saratoga, California
Tasted Wednesday, April 14, 2010 by rjonwine@gmail.com with 845 views
![]()
David Niederauer kept the tradition going this year of a tax time, largely blindtasting bash at Saratoga's The Plumed Horse Restaurant. It's a great way to take our minds off the bite of having to pay those darned taxes, and it's been a very fun and tasty event with wine buddies for three years running now. The first year David organized this event, he had a hobo theme running through the meal, having collaborated with Chef Peter Armellino on dishes that David was able to describe, fancifully, with Depression era inspired names on our special menu, like "Government Cheese" and "Varmint Stew." That was such a memorable and clever stunt that we continue to refer to this as the "Hobo Dinner," even though Peter comes up with new creations for the dinner each year, and there's no longer a "hobo" theme to the dishes.
David organized us into teams and flights for this event, assigning two people to come up with a white flight, three teams of two people each to do Pinot/Burgundy flights, and one team of two to provide sweet wines. David himself provided what turned out to be a flight of Diamond Creek Cabs, as well as a '90 Yquem for the foie gras dumplings (he covered up the year on the bottle and had us guess, and almost all of us were guessing a lot older than '90 because the dark orange color of the wine and the relative accessibility on the palate suggested something a lot older than '90).
We started with a Champagne flight that had been volunteered by one of the attendees, and our first Champagne, the exquisite '79 Henriot Baron Philippe de Rothschild Reserve, turned out to be my WOTN. My other favorites of the evening were the '90 d'Yquem (the most tasty and relatively ready to drink 750 ml bottle of that wine I've ever had), an '88 René Engel Echezeaux, a '93 Diamond Creek Gravelly Meadow, and a 1942 Château d'Arche Sauternes. It did seem like we had a touch more than our share of TCA-afflicted wines on this evening--perhaps that was the IRS exacting yet another penalty on us at this time of year.![]()
![]()
The '79 Rothschild Reserve was an absolutely beautiful, detailed and elegant Champagne. What a fabulous way to start! It's the first I've ever tried of this particular Henriot bottling, and I will now be seeking them out. The '81 Comtes de Champagne seemed quite mature by comparison, but was also quite tasty.
We did not pick these out as Chablis right away. A few people were even guessing that one or two of these were California Chardonnay. A couple of them did seem particularly shut down, as is so often true with Grand Cru level Chablis for several years following release. I would love to revisit the Raveneau, in particular, in another three or four years. The Dauvissat was TCA-affected (a bottled I had on release was stunning), otherwise it would probably have been the WOTF.![]()
Zuckerman's asparagus, slow cooked egg, house cured applewood smoked bacon![]()
Jill and I picked a Vosne-Romanee theme, and tried to come up with a couple of ringers that would be "Vosne-Romanee-like," but the gang weren't buying it. Everyone easily picked out the California ringer, which I thought was showing very well for a 13-year-old Russian River Pinot. After a few guesses like "Haitian Pinot" or "Third World Pinot" for the Spatburgunder, Jayaram properly guessed it was German. I think it's one of the best German Spatburgunders I've ever tasted, but I don't think there were a lot of Spatburgunder fans in our crowd. The sous vide halibut course with this flight had fabulous texture, and was the dish of the night for most of the group.![]()
Wild Alaskan halibut, with Spring green garlic and black trumpet mushroom ragout![]()
Mark and George went with a Grand Cru, mature, Cotes de Nuits theme for this flight. We were guessing '85 and '88 (it helps that we know some of the wines Mark collects), and a couple of us did guess Bonnes Mares. The '88 Vogüé Bonnes Mares did not show nearly as well as an excellent bottle we had at the end of last year for J.D.'s birthday. ![]()
Roasted squab, with fava beans, confit squab on quinoa![]()
Jayaram and J.D. likewise did a mature, Grand Cru flight, with one ringer, featuring two '90 bottlings. This was my first time sampling all four of these wines, so that was a treat. Mount Eden Pinots often age beautifully, but this '78 was not showing well. The '88 Engel Echezeaux was my WOTF.![]()
Mmmm, slider![]()
The '84 Diamond Creek Lake can be a spectacular wine -- I had an amazing bottle of it toward the end of last year, and David himself had brought a bottle that was very good to last year's Hobo Dinner. This one, unfortunately was corked. That opened the field for the '93 Gravelly Meadow to be WOTF. I didn't know that Diamond Creek had bottled a Gravelly Meadow/Lake Blend, so our '91 was of interest for that.![]()
Prime filet of beef & beef daube, with crispy sweet bread mirepois and bone marrow croquette on whole grain mustard![]()
Mischa and Craig, our sweet wine collectors and experts (besides David, whose nickname is Mr. Yquem), collaborated on this flight. The '52 Climens was much darker than the '42. Both were good, but I found more complexity, depth and length on the '42. The maitre d' claimed we'd never guess the flavor of the foam on the strawberry tapioca palate cleanser, but J.R., a terrific chef himself, quickly and accurately guessed "horchata." Our final dessert was creative, quite tasty and light.![]()
strawberry tapioca with horchata foam palate cleanser![]()
sous vide pineapple and coconut dacquoise with hot buttered rum![]()
1979 Henriot Champagne P. de Rothschild Reserve 96 Points
France, Champagne
Light golden yellow color; nice yeasty, delicate lemon, mineral, vanilla, nutmeg nose; tasty, yeasty, finely detailed, tart citrus, mineral, delicate and elegant, layered palate with definition and lift; medium-plus finish 96+ pts. (50% Pinot Noir, 50% Chardonnay)
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
1981 Taittinger Champagne Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs Brut 93 Points
France, Champagne
Light medium gold color; mature Champagne, honey, maple, mulled orange nose; tasty, honeyed, tart citrus, tart orange, apple palate with good acidity; long finish 93+ pts.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No