Ah Orh Seafood, Bukit Merah
Tasted Wednesday, November 3, 2010 by Paul S with 699 views
I asked for a serious wine dinner this week, and Euming pulled this together. Boy, was this every a serious one. Great wines all round. Unusual line-up of whites too, with a sherry and two sweets. I had a great time, with Alex, Fiona, Euming, Charles, Kelvin and Joyce all making for a wonderful dinner. We ended up finishing the remainder outside the restaurant as they pulled the shutters down!
A good bottle, but it was straddling the no-mans-land between between the reticence of an adolescent Burg and the developed openness of adulthood. Indeed, it was all bit tight at first, with secondary scents of of soy, earth and umami on the nose being accompanied by some black tea and a little spice and wood but little in the way of fruit on the nose. All very savoury. With time though, some dried dark cherries, plums, prunes and lifted flower notes, almost chamomile-like, started emerging. Most of us guessed a top Volnay 1er Cru. The palate had lots of live acidity, almost tingly, making me think it might be a 1996, along with fresh dark cherries, tangerine orange and kumquat notes, along with a meaty undertone, a little woodiness and some earthy mineral, all coated with a layer of fine tannins. It had a nice longish finish full of fresh dark fruit and hanging spice notes. Again, it took a little time to coax out some riper blueberry flavours. I liked the depth on the wine, and I thought it had quite powerful concentration. Nice, but just a bit on the tough, woody side at the moment - this certainly is not as giving as some of the 2001s I have had recently. The secondary flavours are just about emerging too, and I think another 3-5 years would really do this bottle a world of good.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
This was a seriously good wine. 45% each of Cab Sauv and Merlot, with the rest being made up of Cab Franc, we all unanimously guessed it as a Right-Bank Bordeaux. Really pleasant nose. Earth, meat, plums, iron, bloody meat, all very Bordeaux, and then came an inexplicable whiff of sweet Japanese cucumbers and eucalyptus. This should have been the tell-tale sign pointing to Australia. The palate told another story though. Fresh, lively, with tomato-ish acidty, cool fruited cherries, strawberries, little flowers, some savoury undercurrants, very nice! Super fine tannins made for a gorgeous structure, and just perfect balance lent the wine a wonderful elegance and breed. Really refined, really elegant and at peak. We were debating whether it was a 1998 or 2000, and whether it was Pomerol of St. Emilion. A real surprise, and a real treat.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
Really solid stuff. Beautiful, classic lines on this one, everyone picked out its Tuscan Sangiovese roots within a few sniffs. Still young, so that it seemed like a good-looking 16 year-old, rather than a fully matured beauty, but it had certainly already started to open up and there was just so much to enjoy. Initial prune scents on the nose were accompanied with earth, plums, some red meat, beef broth and sprinkles of Italian herbs along with a minerally note. Palate was ripe, a nod to the vintage there, and absolutely delicious, with crushed cherries and berries, earth, red meat, mineral and spice. Super-integrated, I thought, one flavour just melded onto another, with little pinpricks of Italian herbs floating around the whole wine like a halo. Beautiful balance and structure too. You hardly noticed the acidity, but it certainly played a nice counterpoint to the ripe fruit notes, and although the tannins were still grippy, they were so fine and well-integrated that the whole package came across very elegantly, almost plush. The wine had a fittingly long finish as well, showing some dark chocolate notes, thyme and mint. Deep and complex, this is a wine to be savoured slowly with good friends. No harm done drinking it now with a couple of hours in a decanter, but I would really keep this for another couple of years - it well deserves patience, and will certainly reward it.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
Absolutely wonderful. This matched a 1982 Leoville Barton blow for blow. Just drinking ridiculously well at the moment. Tons of tobacco on the nose, with cigar scents wafting out of the glass alongside wet leaf and cassis. A wonderful left-bank bouquet. It was on the palate where this really took off though. Silky smooth, it had just the most luscious ripe cassis notes, carried on juicy, succulent acidity and wreathed with smoky cigar notes, and a mid-palate anchored by some stewed meat flavours. It was just laugh-out-loud joy juice. Really yummy stuff. Finish was really great too. Long, smoky, spicey, with cigar, earth and some tar. I was quite sure it was a 1996 Leftie, and, on reflection, it certainly was very clearly a Graves, yet I somehow guessed Pauillac on the night. Nevertheless, a wonderful wine at a wonderful place in its development.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
Best red of the night for a few meteoric moments, before it started a long, slowish retreat into its shell. No one was in doubt that this was a 1982 Left-bank, with quite a few guessing St Julien. Nose was lovely - deep cassis notes were married to earthy scents, savoury meat, red capsicums, and just little bits of herb, spice, black tea and tobacco notes. Wonderfully rich and balanced palate, this had rich cassis tones, more earthy notes and hints of mushrooms, all really full and sumptious, and clad in a robe of velvet tannins that gently coated the mouth. Quite masculine in the way it was structured, but not as austere as some of the Leoville Bartons I have had. Wonderfully fresh on the finish too, with some red cherries emerging alongside flowers and coffee / toffee notes. Quite pitch perfect some 30 minutes of air. It felt a bit rounder, deeper and more elegant. An hour or so later though, the fruit receded little by little, and the tannins came out a bit more. Amazingly, it was still drinking well one night on, as a somewhat dimmed reflection of the wonderful wine it was shortly after it was first poured.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
A real treat, but not for everybody I think. I personally thought it was great, maybe not as world-beating as some of the other posters on CT have rated it, but a really, really excellent dessert wine nonetheless. Nose was okay. Raisins, dark chocolate, spice, nectar, some Italian herbs and a little smoky, cigarette ash and burnt mahogany scent that lingered around rather distractingly. The palate was quite incredible though, I have never quite had a wine like this. It was rich, concentrated, and had tons of depth, with brown sugary sweetness and yummy flavours of chocolate, rum and raisins, prunes, peppermint and coffee - somewhat a cross between a good vintage port and liquified raisins. However, there was absolutely no heat or overt stickiness. Instead, it was fresh, bright, elegant, almost clean. Finish still had some bite, with fine, but firm and slightly chewy tannins at the back-end as the wine faded away with stewed oolong tea flavours and a long, smoky tail, reminiscent of a pull on a first rate cigar. Profound depth and lots of complexity I thought, yet the wine wears it so lightly and deceptively. However, any wine that not only stands up to Orh Nee (the sweet Teochew Yam Paste), but actually overwhelms it, must pack a whole lot of power under the hood. I have no idea how these wines age, but this seemed good to go.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
© 2003-26 CellarTracker! LLC. All rights reserved. "CellarTracker!" is a trademark of CellarTracker! LLC. No part of this website may be used, reproduced or distributed without the prior written permission of CellarTracker! LLC.


NV Equipo Navazos La Bota de Manzanilla 22 "Navazos" 94 Points
Spain, Andalucía, Manzanilla de Sanlúcar de Barrameda
Not quite as amazing as the first bottle, which had been opened for half a day before I got to it. Still darn solid though. Incredible nose. Earth, mineral, clam shells, saline sea spray, soy bean, varnished wood and yellow fruit hints all wrapped up in a slightly caramelly, slightly oxidative Cognac-like package. Very nice, a pleasure just to smell. The palate had that just absolutely incredible balance that I remembered from the last bottle. Fresh, lithe, lively, almost bright, so that this is deceptively light and lemony on the attack. But boy, it had profound depth, with absolutely mouthfilling flavours of figs, seashells, Chinese pears and a strong seam of mineral just opening up and zooming into a gripping finish that just kept unfolding and unfolding and unfolding in savoury layers of preserved kumquats, figs, mineral and little pinpricks of spice. A whole rush of flavours there. With a bit of time, some umami was layered throughout the mouth. Wonderful with spicy clams too, with the acidity cutting through the spice, and the clams just opening the wine up to bring out almost sweet pear fruit. Gorgeous, just somehow missing a bit of that stunning profound depth I remembered on the night. K messaged me a day and a half later to say that the remainder of the bottle had opened up to the same mind-blowing proportions as the first bottle. I certainly know what to do the next time I open one of these - give it lots of time and air.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
1990 Domaine des Baumard Quarts de Chaume Grand Cru 95 Points
France, Loire Valley, Anjou-Saumur, Quarts de Chaume Grand Cru
A superb wine. This stood toe to toe with the amazing Sherry that preceded it. Golden-yellow in colour, with a distinctive nose of wafting orange peel smells, some fresh wooly socks, and maturing secondary tones of mushrooms, dried mangoes, wolfberries and red dates along with rich chrysanthemum tea and white flower scents. With time, some earthy mineral scents start emerging. Really nice - this could only be a top-end Loire. We were wondering whether it was a Huet Vouvray, before settling on a Quarts de Chaume. The palate was deceptively young though, with most of us guessing mid-90s. It had a wonderful balance. Off-dry, creamily textured, with some sweetness and a little caramel creme note on the attack, but it was also absolutely singing with perfectly integrated acidity that just kept the wine lithe and focused throughout. Wonderfully deep, delicious flavours too - lemon cream at the fore, and then peach, nectarine and dried lychees, moving into a super-long honeyed finish layered with serious mineral notes. Beautiful. A very complex, very complete wine. Great to drink now, but I can only imagine at getting better and better as the years go by. Given the balance and the sugars, this could be well nigh indestructible.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2004 Reichsrat Von Buhl Forster Ungeheuer Riesling Auslese 94 Points
Germany, Pfalz
The third of a trio of just superb whites. From a 375ml - this was far, far better than the last bottle I had a couple of years ago. It was really good. While the last bottle was a bit sugary and primary, this had began to shed some of the sweet impressions and take on secondary flavours. It probably helped that it was beautifully paired with fried prawn rolls (haey chor) and sweet sauce. A lot of botrytis here for a 2004. Nose had very nice honey, mushrooms, kerosene and floating flower scents, osmanthus I thought, all haunted by a woody vanilla and caramel tone. On the second pour, a wonderful slatey minerality showed up. It also had a gorgeous balance on the palate as only a German Riesling can have. Deep, rich, yet oh so fresh. Almost bright, with candied lemons and peach galore, along with more honey and white flowers, all perfectly integrated, with a little dessicated coconut at the end. Brilliantly put together wine. I tend to find Von Buhl's Ausleses a little sweet for me at times, but this bottle wore the cool 2004 vintage tones really well. Less power maybe, but the relatively higher acid and less aggressive sugars lent a cut and balance that I do not usually associate with this house. Served blind, I thought this might be a Nahe rather than a Pfalz. Very nice indeed.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No