First Growth Night 2011

PRIMA
Tasted Friday, May 6, 2011 by soyhead with 931 views

Introduction

Thanks to Duane for organizing it, and laying down some very clear and straightford rules - only official first growths : Lafite, Latour, Marguax, Haut Brion (all declared 1855), Mouton (declared 1973), Groth (declared 2010), and Coonawara Estate Terra Rossa (declared 2011). No Petrus, Ausone, or Cheval Bullshit, etc... I think rule number two was something along the lines of the organizer and anyone else on the politburo reserve the right to bring whatever they want whist you bring a first growth.

In attendance were Jeff, Doug, Brian, Bob, Errol, Duane, Mario, and Steve. We convened with the notable absence of John, which was not cool - WTF?

We toasted to friends and fine wine, and with a huge and momentous week in terms of world events behind us, we all toasted President Obama as well for finally and successfully tracking down and nabbing his birth certificate.

Below are my humbled opinions of the wines that follow. Scores are of course arbitrary; and i tend to come in on the low side, dont let that fool anyone. There were some superb wines poured, thanks to everyone for their generosity.

So let's start with the wines:

Flight 1 (1 Note)

1. After opening and decanting all the bottles , Sid, the sommelier, commented that he was worried only about this bottle, the 1970 Margaux, and that the cork has essentially disintegrated; others worried about the quality of a Ginestet era Margaux that has not found favor with the emporer of wine, but were we reassured by Jeff who has had this wine 'at least six times' that there is nothing to fear.

  • 1970 Château Margaux 93 Points

    France, Bordeaux, Médoc, Margaux

    nose - Musky. Hay & decaying leaves. honey (per Duane). vaguely smells like underarm, but you know, in a good sort of way. Muted funk. A nose to remember. Vaguely pheremonel.
    mouth - fruit punchy red flavors, very soft and mellow. tannins still present but barely, almost like a weak iced tea. good acidity, and surprising verve for a wine older than me. a delight to taste, i liked it much more than i anticipated i would. but this wine could be a letdown if you approach it with the wrong expectations.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 2 (1 Note)

2. I believe the story behind Steve's wine (86 Haut Brion) is that he was planning on bringing the 2000 Lafite, and when Jeff found out he essentially had a heart attack and told him not to be silly, instead sell the bottle with the dough buy himself a new excavator, or something. Now mind you I would have really loved to try the 2000 Lafite, but the replacement bottle turned out to be quite fine as well. So the 2000 Lafite survives another first growth event, for now ;-).

  • 1986 Château Haut-Brion 95 Points

    France, Bordeaux, Graves, Pessac-Léognan

    My third time having this wine, and ooh baby was it singing tonight. Nose of dirt, manure, and rose. Mouth - gorgeous round red fruit and notes of tobacco; very expansive on the midpalate, the wine is in a generous and giving space at the moment. Nice acidity to boot. Flat out delicious. My WOTN.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 3 (1 Note)

3. The next wine (98 Haut Brion) was brought by me, having been procured from Duane. Thus I was spared him harping on it.

  • 1998 Château Haut-Brion 91 Points

    France, Bordeaux, Graves, Pessac-Léognan

    nose - cherry, dirt, burnt orange
    mouth - polished, good red fruit flavors but overall rather wound up esp in comparison to the '86 Haut Brion. bitter cherry midpalate. Just turned a teenager but has some maturing to do.

    Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

Flight 4 (1 Note)

4. Brian's wine (96 Mouton) was originally meant for first growth night last year, and since he decided to attend this year, he brought it.

  • 1996 Château Mouton Rothschild 91 Points

    France, Bordeaux, Médoc, Pauillac

    nose - a wicked nose of fermenting cranberry, mushroom, Asian spices, and tea. Duane and Brian picked out Bing cherry. This was fun to sit around and smell. In the mouth i found the cranberry and cherry flavors somewhat tight. I couldnt get a good read on it, strikes me as being shut down. Either that or I was shutting down. Probably just needs more bottle age.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 5 (1 Note)

5. Bob's wine was the '98 Latour. I have not had many bottles of Latour in my day - getting to taste this was a huge treat.

  • 1998 Château Latour Grand Vin 90 Points

    France, Bordeaux, Médoc, Pauillac

    nose - mushroom, dried flowers
    mouth - bitter fruit, tobacco, still quite tannic. i think this is very young.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 6 (1 Note)

6. The first of two blinded wines courtesy of the good doctor was the yang to counterbalance the ying (see next). I think it was guessed to be New World by all, but only Bob called it not being from California. I especially like how it arrived in a carafe pulled out of a box (predecanted). This was the bottle we all were worried about (rightfully so).

  • 1998 Parker Coonawarra Estate Terra Rossa First Growth 85 Points

    Australia, South Australia, Limestone Coast, Coonawarra

    Tasted blind at first growth night, and despite the name, it was the ugly duckling. Nose of spearment, mint, and cedar (per Brian). Mouth - sweet in comparison to the '1855 classified' other first growths. Very caramelly. Clearly overoaked. Though not bad, lacking the complexity or depth of a fine wine. Parker scored this 95-97 points? What was he smoking? Perhaps it originates from the early Australia hullabaloo which has clearly blown over. Of note, it appears that I have had this bottle before commenting 'drinking fine but nothing to write home about'.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 7 (1 Note)

7. The ying. Whoa Nelly. This was another honor to be served. The generosity of the good doctor must be noted, and no this does not excuse you for the next five years and justify your shenanigans. Proof that in fact people do still drink Lafite.

  • 1990 Château Lafite Rothschild 93 Points

    France, Bordeaux, Médoc, Pauillac

    Tasted blind. Earthy nose. In the mouth earth meets fruit, showing slight bitter orange secondary flavors, has nice fine grained tannins, with a good broad finish. A quality wine.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 8 (1 Note)

8. Doug's bottle (2002 Hundred Acre) was a late addition acquired from Brian who acquired it from Errol. Talk about impeccable provenance.
You might think the appearance of this bottle violates the rules of the event, however it was cleared with the bossman first (remember rule #2).

  • 2002 Hundred Acre Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon Kayli Morgan 92 Points

    USA, California, Napa Valley

    This my third time having this wine, and for some time now i had considered it the finest red wine i have ever had. Oddly enough (or perhaps not) it didnt really show well interjected into a sea of Bordeaux first growths. Nose - cinnamon, clove, chocolate fudge. Mouth - huge extract, fudge predominates, strong concentrated cassis liqueur, almost fatigues the palate. Perhaps more chocolate in the palate than fruit. What it seemed to lack was freshness. In spite of its massive body, its probably overoaked. Pair with itself, or fudge.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 9 (1 Note)

9. And Mario's d'Yquem, that last bolus of ethanol to push you into metabolic acidosis, but fear not, he can fix that.

  • 1999 Château d'Yquem 93 Points

    France, Bordeaux, Sauternais, Sauternes

    nose - dried apricot
    mouth - mouthcoating, viscous, and delicious. honeysuckle and honey. Someone chimed in, what year is the 'd'yquem', to which bob replied 'what does it matter they all taste the same'. which made me reflect a little bit and realize that the sweetness so dumbfounds me that i should probably recuse myself from rating sauternes in general, or at least try a bunch of them side by side and learn myself a little something first

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Closing

Nice time had by all. Sorry no pictures this year. All the French first growths made a presence - a flush of sorts. Till we meet again.

The great Oz has spoken.

×
×