Virginia Wines from 2011 Wine Bloggers Conference
Omni Hotel, Charlottesville; Monticello; and Pollak and Veritas Tasting Rooms, Virginia
Tasted Friday, July 22, 2011 - Sunday, July 24, 2011 by rjonwine@gmail.com with 1,075 views
Introduction
Virginia hosted this year's Wine Bloggers Conference, and took full advantage of their sponsorship and support of the conference to expose assembled bloggers to the state's wines. During the course of meet-the-sponsor tastings, "live blogging" tastings, a major event at Monticello (outdoors in 101 degree heat and high humidity), a Saturday night Virginia-focused dinner, and my own visit to a couple of wineries that intrigued me after the conference, I managed to taste 117 Virginia wines from 46 producers during the course of the conference's long weekend. This was a significant increase over the mere five wines from the state I'd managed to sample before (all of which, I believe, were thanks to a few friends who brought back VA wines from visits to the state, as Virginia wines are noticeably absent from wine store shelves throughout my home state of California). I don't presume to have become any kind of expert on Virginia wines as a result of this quick immersion, but I do come away with a few working hypotheses, as well as an appreciation of the seriousness of the winemaking going on here at a number of producers despite the very challenging climate conditions they have to contend with. I'll share those hypotheses in this report, along with information on the producers whose wines most impressed me during this visit. I'll also hazard a suggestion or two for further marketing of the state's wines.
First that climate: As we learned through first-hand experience during this conference, it can get darned hot and muggy during a Virginia summer. This intense heat and humidity, especially when it comes toward the end of veraison and at harvest, can cause the sugar-ripeness of the grapes to accelerate way ahead of the progress of physiological ripeness. The result tends to be green tannins and a lack of acidity. I learned that it is standard amongst the state's winemakers to acidify the wines, which basically takes care of the latter problem, as long as the acidification is done carefully and doesn't result in further imbalance in the wine. The green tannins are hard to overcome, however, unless the grapes ultimately get a chance to reach full physiological ripeness. The humidity and high rain levels also encourage the growth of fungal diseases, especially downy mildew, powdery mildew, black rot, phomopsis cane and leaf spot, and botrytis gray mold. Nonetheless, Virginia winemakers are persevering, and in many cases succeeding, through careful variety, clone and site selection; intensive canopy management (which can help counter the accelerated sugar ripening); and spraying to control fungal infections.
Another way that many producers have sought to overcome the challenges to growing and making fine wine in Virginia has been to import experienced talent from elsewhere: e.g., Italy, France, South Africa and California. This was how Thomas Jefferson originally tried to get vinifera grapes to grow in Virginia when he planted vines at Monticello in 1807 with help from Italian viticulturist Filippo Mazzei. The aforementioned fungal diseases, however, prevented Jefferson from realizing his dream of making wine from those grapes. Italy’s Zonin family finally had success, however, 170 years later, when they imported Gabriele Rausse, pictured below, to help them grow grapes for their Barboursville Vineyards, the state’s first commercial vinifera winery. Gabriele's efforts resulted in Barboursville's first vintage in 1979. Barboursville’s current winemaker is the gregarious Luca Paschina, also from Italy. Afton Mountain Vineyards’s winemaker Lucien Dimani is from Cahors, where both his parents were winemakers. He’s also worked in Bordeaux and New Zealand. Matthieu Finot, a winemaker from the Rhone, is winemaker for King Family and consulting winemaker at both Ankida Ridge and Stinson Vineyards. Stephen Barnard, winemaker at Keswick Vineyards, was assistant winemaker at Groot Constantia and Flagstone wineries in South Africa. Simone Bergese, winemaker at Potomac Point, is from Alba, and started his winemaking career at Produttori del Barbaresco. Bill Swain, originally from California and one-time assistant winemaker at Charles Krug, is winemaker for Ingleside Vineyards. And Mike Panczak, winemaker at White Hall Vineyards, got his first experience at Qupe and then Foxen in California’s Santa Maria Valley. 
Veritas owner Andrew Hodson and daughter and winemaker Emily at a "speed blogging" session
With that 1979 vintage from Barboursville being a success, other wine producers got into the act in the 1980s and '90s. Reportedly there are now 193 wineries operating in Virginia, and there are even wineries successfully producing wines in southern Virginia, which was originally thought to be the last place in the state where that would be possible. As of 2010, per U.S. Department of the Treasury Alcohol and Tobacco Tax Trade Bureau statistics, Virginia was producing 976,052 total gallons of wine, which amounts to .144% of all the still wine made in the U.S. For comparison, in 2010 California produced 606,448,660 gallons, or 89.5% of the country’s still wine; New York was a distant second in wine production with 3.73% of the country’s output; Washington State was third with 2.92%; and Oregon fourth at .724%. I’ve seen some marketing materials—at WBC11, shall we say, and repeated on a few blogs--indicating that Virginia is now the country’s fifth largest producer. Unfortunately, that’s pure bullshit. Virginia actually ranked 13th in bulk wine production and 15th in bottled wine in 2010, per U.S. government statistics. In bulk wine, where they ranked 13th, they trailed, after the big four, Kentucky, Florida, New Jersey, North Carolina, Missouri, Ohio, Texas and Indiana. But in terms of quality, I wouldn’t be at all surprised if Virginia wines aren’t significantly ahead of those of some of the states that are bigger producers, like Florida, Kentucky, Ohio and Missouri.
There appears to be a lot of experimentation and innovation going on in Virginia, which is a good thing. I tried sparkling wines from unusual varieties (e.g., Merlot and Viognier), some intriguing blends (e.g., Tannat, Cabernet Sauvignon and Petit Verdot) and even some fortified, late harvest Viognier. The latter, from Pollak Vineyards, was actually pretty darned good. What I tasted that particularly stood out for its quality, however, were whites made from Viognier and Chardonnay, and reds from Bordeaux varietals. There were some quite decent Cabernet Francs, Cabernet Sauvignons, Merlots and Bordeaux blends that could give most Bordeaux superieur and the like a good run for their money. And as I’m a fan of Petit Verdot when it gets fully ripe, I was quite excited about some varietal bottlings of Petit Verdot, and other wines where the grape made up a substantial component of the blend. And most of the Bordeaux varietal bottlings I tried had good balancing acidity. This was due, in presumably all cases, to acidification, but the acidification was well handled and made for generally well balanced wines.
Given the insane prices of Bordeaux wines these days, made even worse by the increasingly unfavorable exchange rate, I began to wonder how a “Buy America” campaign focused on Virginia’s Bordeaux varietals might fare. Most of the Virginia Bordeaux varietals that I was impressed with were quite fairly priced, so I think there’s some potential to sell U.S.-based lovers of Bordeaux on made-in-America versions of Bordeaux blends that are available for about the same price as a lot of iffy, and often very herbaceous, Bordeaux superieurs. I think that kind of campaign stands more of a chance in gaining market share outside of the state than pushing Virginia’s state grape, Viognier. Many of the Virginia Viogniers I tried were quite decent—aromatic and balanced—while others were more on the fruity and very ripe side. I don’t think the demand for these wines is anywhere near as strong, however, as the demand for reliable, food-friendly, well balanced red wines. The little Viognier bubble that existed toward the beginning of the last decade hasn’t gotten all that much bigger, as best I can tell. I, for one, don’t buy much domestic Viognier as it is, and doubt I would go all the way to Virginia to supplement what little need I have for domestic Viognier. If I want aromatic, white and food friendly, I’m much more likely to reach for still-bargain-priced German Rieslings. I’m just sayin’. But if the state’s Petit Verdots and some of the other, better Bordeaux varietal blends were available in California at reasonable prices, I’d likely pick some up.
So recognizing that my tastings at WBC11 were just a mere quick snapshot of what’s going on in the state, and that the conditions under which I tasted some of these (i.e., at the big Monticello do) were “less than ideal,” (okay, so Monticello ranks as “the worst conditions ever”), what did I think were the best of the 117 wines I tasted in the Old Dominion? The wines I rated 89 points or more came from the following producers:
Annefield Vineyards
Aspen Dale Winery
Barboursville Vineyards
Barrel Oak Winery
Blenheim Vineyards
Breaux Vineyards
Fabbioli Cellars
Gabriele Rausse
Jefferson Vineyards
Keswick Vineyards
King Family
Paradise Springs
Pippin Hill
Pollak Vineyards
Rockbridge Vineyard
Veritas Vineyard
White Hall Vineyards
Best overall for me (again, from a very limited snapshot), with multiple wines rated 89 points or more, were Blenheim, Breaux, Jefferson, Keswick, Pollak, Veritas and White Hall. I note from my reading on the wines of Virginia that Kluge Estate and Piedmont Vineyards are thought by some to be among Virginia’s best, but neither of these wineries participated in any of the WBC proceedings.
My very top wines of the weekend, the 14 that I rated 90 points or higher (i.e., nearly 12% of what I tasted) were:
2008 Barrel Oak Winery Petit Verdot Reserve – 90 points
2010 Blenheim Vineyards Viognier – 90 points
2007 Breaux Vineyards Meritage – 90 points
2009 Keswick Vineyards Merlot – 90 points
2007 Keswick Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon – 90 points
2010 King Family Vineyards Viognier – 90+ points
2010 Paradise Springs Chardonnay – 90 points
2010 Pollak Vineyards Viognier – 90+ points
2010 Pollak Vineyards Pinot Gris – 91 points
2009 Pollak Vineyards Petit Verdot – 91 points
2009 Pollak Vineyards Mille Fleurs Late Harvest Viognier Monticello – 91+ points
2010 Pollak Vineyards Mille Fleurs Late Harvest Viognier Monticello – 91-93 points
2008 Rockbridge Vineyard V d'Or – 91+ points
2010 White Hall Vineyards Viognier – 90 points
For my detailed tasting notes, and a little more info on producers that most impressed me, see below:
Flight 1 - Afton Mountain (2 Notes)
Flight 2 - Ankida Ridge (2 Notes)
Flight 3 - Annefield (2 Notes)
Flight 4 - Aspen Dale (2 Notes)
Flight 5 - Barboursville (6 Notes)
This is the winery responsible for showing that vinifera varieties could actually be made into wine in Virginia, and they haven't rested on that laurel. I was particularly impressed by the Nebbiolo Reserve, and the other wines we tasted were well made, if not as exciting as some others I tried during the weekend. The property on which the winery is situated was once owned by James Barbour, a former governor of Virginia, for whom Thomas Jefferson designed the mansion containing the famous Octagon room, for which the winery's signature Bordeaux blend wine is named. 
Winemaker Luca Paschina pictured right
Flight 6 - Barrel Oak (2 Notes)
This winery is a relatively new entrant on the scene, with vines planted only in 2006, and the winery has been opened for visitors since 2008. The Petit Verdot was among the best I tasted all weekend, however. The owners are Sharon and Brian Roeder, and they've planted 22 acres to vinifera as well as American and French hybrids. The varieties planted are Seyval Blanc, Vidal Blanc, Petit Manseng, Viognier, Chardonnay, Merlot, Petit Verdot, Traminette and Chambourcin. The winemakers are Sharon Roeder and Rick Tagg.
Flight 7 - Barren Ridge (2 Notes)
Flight 8 - Blenheim (2 Notes)
I was impressed by both of these wines that we tasted at Monticello (and I like the wine label graphics as well, which are based on the Pythagoras tree fractal). The winery was founded in 2000 by owner Dave Matthews, and has two vineyard sites growing five European varieties: Chardonnay, Viognier, Cabernet Franc, Cabernet Sauvignon and Petit Verdot. Winemaker Kirsty Harmon apprenticed with Gabriele Rausse. 
Winemaker Kirsty Harmon
Flight 9 - Boxwood (3 Notes)
Flight 10 - Breaux (4 Notes)
This producer was started in 1995 by Paul and Alexis Breaux when they purchased a three-acre vineyard that had been planted in 1985. They now have over 100 acres planted to 18 different grape varieties. The new winemaker is David Pagan Castaño, an import from Yecla, Spain, where his family has made wine for three generations. The wines were good overall, but I particularly liked the Meritage and the Nebbiolo. 
Flight 11 - Byrd Cellars (2 Notes)
Flight 12 - Cardinal Point (2 Notes)
Flight 13 - Catoctin Creek (2 Notes)
Flight 14 - Chatham (2 Notes)
Flight 15 - Chrysalis (2 Notes)
Flight 16 - Cooper (2 Notes)
Flight 17 - 8 Chains North (2 Notes)
Flight 18 - Fabbioli Cellars (2 Notes)
Flight 19 - Flying Fox (2 Notes)
Flight 20 - Gabriele Rausse (2 Notes)
Gabriele Rausse, responsible for Barboursville's successful vinifera vintage in 1979, pictured right
Flight 21 - Gadino Cellars (2 Notes)
Flight 22 - Glass House (2 Notes)
Flight 23 - Gray Ghost (1 Note)
Flight 24 - Horton (1 Note)
Flight 25 - Ingleside (1 Note)
Flight 26 - Jefferson (4 Notes)
This producer occupies the land that Thomas Jefferson arranged for his wine consultant, Filipo Mazzei, to buy, near Monticello. They claim that it was first planted to vinifera varieties in 1774. Andy Reagan is the winemaker. From what I tasted, this seems to be a very consistent producer. The Petit Verdot Reserve sells for only about $20.
Flight 27 - Keswick (3 Notes)
This, for me, was one of the most impressive producers I got to try during the whole event. Al and Cindy Schornberg planted a vineyard on part of the original 1727 Nicholas Meriwether Crown Grant, and produced their first wines in 2002. Al had previously been a high-tech entrepreneur in Michigan, and the Schornbergs have invested a tremendous amount in acreage and equipment in an effort to produce high level wines. Stephen Bernard, pictured below, has been winemaker and general manager since 2006. He started out at one of South Africa's oldest wineries, Groot Constantia. Both the Merlot and Cabernet were among the best versions of those varieties I sampled during my visit.
Flight 28 - Kilaurwen (1 Note)
Flight 29 - King Family (2 Notes)
This was the source of one of the weekend's best Viogniers. David and Ellen King, originally from Texas, are the owners, and their children and the childrens' spouses are also very involved with the business. The winemaker, as mentioned above, is Frenchman Matthieu Finot, who has previously worked in the Rhone Valley, Bordeaux, Burgundy, Provence, the Jura, Italy and South Africa.
Flight 30 - Lovingston (2 Notes)
Flight 31 - Michael Shaps (2 Notes)
Flight 32 - Château Morrisette (2 Notes)
Flight 33 - Mountfair (2 Notes)
Flight 34 - Naked Mountain (1 Note)
Flight 35 - Paradise Springs (2 Notes)
Flight 36 - Pippin Hill (2 Notes)
Flight 37 - Pollak (10 Notes)
This was another of the most impressive producers across the board that I encountered during my visit. The Viognier got my attention as one of the two best wines of the night at the Saturday dinner. We happened to be seated at the same table as two of the Pollak staff, including tasting room manager Nick Dovel. Since Nick was going to be in the tasting room the next day, Fred Swan and I invited ourselves to come for a visit after the wine bloggers conference was over to sample more of the Pollak wines. I had been particularly intrigued when Nick mentioned at dinner that they use a variety of different commercial yeasts in fermenting the wines, as they've found different yeasts bring out different characteristics and/or flavors in the wine, and that blending batches fermented with different yeasts can add to the finished wine's complexity.
Since I'm already aware that yeasts are responsible for a large percentage of the flavor compounds in wine, and am hugely tired of the wine world's current fetish for "indigenous" or "ambient" yeasts (which just means that whatever yeasts have become dominant in the winemaking facility environment take over the fermentation, regardless of whether they're the ones that might have the most interesting impact on the ultimate wine), I was jumping at the chance to sample the result of fermenting the same variety from the same vineyard with different commercial yeasts. Nick obliged us the following day by not only tasting us on all the current releases, including the excellent 2010 Pinot Gris and 2009 Petit Verdot, but also letting us compare a barrel sample of 2010 Merlot from their Smuggler vineyard fermented with D254 yeast alongside a barrel sample fermented with BM4x4 yeast. Both had good structure and firm tannins, especially the D254 sample, but there was a very appealing roasted fruit quality and meatiness to the BM4x4 sample. He also let us try the very unusual fortified late harvest Viognier that the winery has been making since the '09 vintage. It's called Mille Fleurs, and they make it with Viognier grapes that have "dimpled," indicating that they've already lost 10% or so of their water content. They ferment them to 5% alcohol, and then fortify with brandy distilled from their own Chardonnay grapes to 18% alcohol. They then age the wine in barrel for two years. The '09 had a wonderful silky texture, and nose and palate reminiscent of fine pear brandy. We also tried a barrel sample of the 2010 version, which has the potential for being even more complex.
Pollak owners Margot and David Pollak, who live in Ohio, purchased the farm that has become Pollak Vineyards in 2001, after looking for a suitable location for a new winery venture nationwide for some time. David Pollak had been a founding partner of Bouchaine Vineyards in Carneros back in the '70s, eventually selling out to the DuPont family in the mid-1980s. When the couple decided to re-enter the wine business, they were impressed by what was happening in Virginia (where the price of fine potential vineyard land was also substantially less than in California). They purchased 100 acres at a high elevation in a "wind gap," where the breeze is fairly constant throughout the growing season, helping to keep the grapes dry and lessening the chances of rot. Starting in 2003, they have planted 27 acres to vines, relying on experienced Virginia consultants Chris Hill and Michael Shaps. Viticulturist Chris Hill dictated the "ballerina" trellis system, specially designed for Viognier in Virginia's growing conditions, used on the first 10 acres planted. The varieties planted, all French vinifera, include Chardonnay, Viognier, Pinot Gris, Cabernet Franc, Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Petit Verdot and Petit Manseng. The winemaker is Jake Busching. They produced a field blend Meritage in 2005, but the first real commercial vintage was 2007. The lovely tasting room, with a view of the vineyards and a small lake, was opened in 2008. I look forward to checking back on this producer in the coming years, as I think they have the potential for creating really elegant and complex wines that should be standouts for the state.
Flight 38 - Potomac Point (2 Notes)
Flight 39 - Prince Michel (2 Notes)
Flight 40 - Rockbridge (1 Note)
Flight 41 - Stinson (2 Notes)
Flight 42 - Tarara (4 Notes)
Flight 43 - Veritas (14 Notes)
We asked Nick at Pollak which one other winery we should visit in the neighborhood, which was all we had time for before my flight back to San Francisco. Nick turned us on to Veritas. This seemed like a real destination tasting room, as it was quite crowded with visitors when we arrived. It felt even more crowded when a brief thunderstorm started, and more people entered looking for cover. The quality of the wines was, on the whole, quite good. I particularly like the non-vintage white blend White Star, as well as the sparkling wine they make from white grapes, Scintilla. British-born neurologist Andrew Hodson is the owner, with his wife Patricia, and Andrew and his daughter Emily are the winemakers. They started operations in 2002.
Flight 44 - West Wind Farm (2 Notes)
Flight 45 - White Hall (2 Notes)
Owners Tony and Edie Champ established White Hall in in 1992 with six acres of Chardonnay, Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot and Cabernet Franc. They have since added Pinot Gris, Gewürztraminer, Muscat, Touriga Nacional, Viognier, Petit Verdot and Petit Manseng, for a total of 45 planted acres. The winemaker is Mike Panczak, from California's Santa Maria Valley. Both the Viognier and Petit Verdot were quite good.
2008 Afton Mountain Vineyards Tête de Cuvée Brut 88 Points
USA, Virginia, Central Virginia, Monticello
(7/22/2011)
Light lemon yellow color with medium-sized bubbles; chalk, tart green apple nose; tasty, chalk, tart green apple, mineral palate; medium finish (50% Pinot Noir, 50% Chardonnay)
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2009 Afton Mountain Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Reserve 86 Points
USA, Virginia
(7/23/2011)
Dark purple red violet color; very tart berry, pencil lead nose; tart berry, pencil lead, graphite, tart currant palate; medium-plus finish 86+ points
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No