Strictly Rhythm, London
Tasted Friday, April 13, 2012 by cooberp with 745 views
A group of 11 Hocharophiles rendezvoused at the office of a cool record label to share 15 Lebanese libations. Served with an excellent shepherd's pie and carrots. I only took notes on the reds.
This was an extremely educational evening. Musar is a distinctive and wonderful wine. It can exhibit every flaw in the book: we had two corked bottles, most showed some VA, and a handful had some brett lurking in the background. Sometimes that's a good thing as part of a package; sometimes it most definitely is not. It resembles Burgundy (Vosne I suppose?) in its consistent cherry/currant red fruit, cinnamon/brown sugar/baking spice/soy sauce aromas, high acid, and low tannin. But it's very full-bodied in its youth, and retains that volume for at least 30 years (the '66 had turned weightless, but the '77, '82, and '83 still had heft). In that sense, it's more like Sangiovese that's aged long enough for its tannin to resolve. Once it reaches middle age, it takes on a brandyish air I strongly associate with Rioja. Indeed, if I were to taste it blind, my best guess would probably be a fine mature Rioja Crianza or very lightly oaked Reserva.
I generally think of myself as preferring older wines, but surprisingly, I think Musar may be an exception. As an early adolescent (the 1999 at this tasting, or the 2002 I have now bought two cases of), it fires on all cylinders: its signature complexity is already visible, but it's layered on top of extremely generous fruit impeccably balanced by invigorating acidity. As you'd expect, as it moves into maturity, the fruit fades and the body lightens while the secondary notes become more prominent. But I don't find myself convinced that the tradeoff is worth it. The really old vintages may be fascinating lab experiments, but I'll order a 1999 or 2002 with my meal, thank you very much.
This is great news for my wallet, as Musar has an extremely steep price-age curve, especially in the UK. Up to about 15 years from harvest, the grand vin can be had for a song: $24 a bottle in bond, which comes to $32 after duty and VAT. It's also widely available in half-bottles, which is the optimal volume for this single drinker. Then, as you move towards 20 years and out, the price skyrockets, moving well north of $100 in a hurry, and reaching double or triple that for sought-after old vintages. (Traditional Piedmont seems to show a similar pattern, though it's more expensive across the board). If the pattern holds, then buying caseloads of '99 Musar and sitting on it might prove a fine investment.
1990 Chateau Musar Blanc
Lebanon, Bekaa Valley
No notes taken
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
1991 Chateau Musar Blanc
Lebanon, Bekaa Valley
No notes taken
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
1999 Chateau Musar Blanc
Lebanon, Bekaa Valley
No notes taken
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2001 Chateau Musar Blanc
Lebanon, Bekaa Valley
No notes taken
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No