Home of Mike and Sandra O.
Tasted Friday, June 1, 2012 - Saturday, June 2, 2012 by Nutty08 with 825 views
This was a challenging tasting. All wines were double blind, frequently with an unhelpful clue. The two wines I brought were known to me and I could use as a reference.
(6/1/2012)
#1 – Big rich nose of black currants, cassis with well placed cedar spice. The palate was wide open, ripe napa cab fruit flavors and a lengthy finish with just the right amount of cedar spice from the oak. This was well sized, accessible, with anything well balanced, polished and positioned. I wish more Napa cabs were like this. I guessed ’04 Napa cab from Calistoga—specifically with Larkmeade in mind. Not a bad guess but it went downhill from there very quickly.
Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
(6/1/2012)
#2 – Very interesting nose of mint, meat, exotic spices with a floral like quality. Some leather on the palate, dried red fruits and fine still prominent tannins. Lengthy finish with spice, leather and a hint of earth. Still l seemed a little closed but opened up wonderfully through the evening showing more cab franc character. I had a hard time choosing b/t a ’94 left bank and ’95 right bank and after the identity was revealed I saw why. With a little clue I guessed ’95 La Conseillante. Elegant, structured, and “four-square”. 93-94
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
(6/1/2012)
Big rich briary and purple fruit nose with new oak spices. Palate was fat and juicy, with tons of concentrated purple fruit, big chunky tannins, and round fruity mouthfeel. Lengthy berry and fruit filled finish. Fruit was a little more “purple” than Zin, without the character of syrah, and the tannins made me think PS. (I also recognized the Turley bottle which helped). Well balanced without any heat and given the round fruit I thought this was a few years older, 04-’05. Give this some time.
Post a Comment / 2 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
(6/1/2012)
#4 – Man I bombed this one. Brownish color with some bricking and light coloring. Tinny/metallic, light floral nose. Palate was thin with slightly mature sweet fruit and fine tannins. Moderate finish with some forest floor. Later in the evening when I knew the region I thought this showed some herbal greenness, more prominent acidity and seemed a little younger and more expressive-- but still didn’t seem like it would have a great future. I thought it was a ’91 or ’92 left bank—totally shocked it was an 8yo Grand Cru. 87-89
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
(6/1/2012)
#5 – Rich vanilla nose with a more red fruit profile than The Maiden. Polsihed palate, tannins became a little less fine and more chunky with air. Round ripe fruits and low acidity made me think this was a bit older. Nice pleasant cedar, vanilla, and sweet cassis on the finish. Guessed 04 Mondavi Reserve. After knowing the identity and spending more time with it, this was less impressive but still good, and my initial blind impression was that this was excellent. 91-93
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
(6/1/2012)
#6 – I got a bright citrus orange peel note on the nose initially, that later was more tart cherry and licorice. Bright, quite acidic palate, with clean pure cherry flavors and fine barely perceptible tannins. Lengthy stone driven finish. Got to follow a glass of this later in the evening, has great structure and should gain complexity and accessibility with time. The citrus note pushed me to call this an ’08 Beaujolais (gamay). Hold.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
(6/1/2012)
Clue helped identify this one. High-toned, floral nose with some leather and spice—very subtle. Tannic youthful palate with dried fruits, leafy herbs and a sweet sandal wood finish. I’m starting to like Barolo, though I thought this was older given it’s rather accessible palate. Balanced, poised, subtle complexity. Really nice. 93
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
(6/1/2012)
#9 – Meaty earth character with tart cherry palate, with touch of leather and game on the finish. A very odd Chianti, thought it was much older, maybe around ’04.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
(6/1/2012)
#8 – This was a slightly cold sample. Dark fruit nose with some vanilla. Fine acidity on the palate, slightly thin with some bed berry fruit. Some oak on the finish. I couldn’t even venture a guess it was so non-distinctive to me. Maybe too cold? Forgot to retaste.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
(6/1/2012)
Showed much better than my recent experience. Ripe clean cherry palate, with fine acidity and tannins that carries through on the finish. Cab-like structure with red berry profile fits in what I typically refer to as a Super Tuscan. Nicely put together wine, though not terribly complex. Less overt toasty oak character than my bottle a few weeks ago (I did not recognize it).
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
(6/1/2012)
#11 – Really missed this one. High toned red fruit nose with licorice coming out only after I knew what it was. Acidic palate, but ripe round red fruit, hint of spice, and prominent polished tannins that are slightly bitter on the finish. I guessed Priorat of all things. I got a clean, ripe pinot profile only after I knew what it was. ‘09’s are delicious and would be hard not to enjoy now.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
(6/1/2012)
Opened and poured in the glass, sat a couple hrs before tasting. Nose was rather close for the most part, with hint of oak/barrel funk, saline, and cassis. Currants come through on the palate, very polished, concentrated, with fine tannins. Fresh has a definite freshness along with a lush density, though overall mouthfeel is medium in body and plush. Lengthy finish with vanilla, saline, chocolate, and black currants. Clearly has some oak to integrate, with polished tannins and good concentration and poise. Will revisit tomorrow, but not as expressive or enjoyable now as hoped, revisit in 5-10yrs.
Day 2,blind to the group. slightly more accessible, with a rather dark fruit character and showing a little flint and saline. Very difficult to nail down as a Paulliac. '09 left banks have been rather closed to me.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
(6/2/2012)
#14 – This was known to me and showed the character I associate with Chile. Meaty, minty nose with currants and leather. Palate was rather soft, but still has some tannin, more currants than cassis, plenty of eucalyptus and leather. Moderate lengthy finish of espresso, toast, mint, earth. Seemed a little muddled and lacking focus. Typical of Chilean cabs for me and rather unimpressive at the price point.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
(6/1/2012)
Non-blind. Surprised this is Chardonnay. Big ripe nose of botrytis, apricot and tropical fruit. Palate is massive, thick, coating the mouth but lacking acidity and the needed energy and verve that comes along with it. Finish is long but tiring. Cloying. Couldn’t finish the glass. Disappointing given the hype and expectation.
Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
Another incredible evening. Great food, fun and friends. Double blind is very hard and humbling. Clearly people who can pick out these wines blind are highly skilled and experienced, and I do not envy our MW-candidate member that has to do this under pressure. Some conclusions:
1) Double Blind is hard
2) I clearly know nothing of burgundy
3) The Mainden is good but hard to justify the price. Harlan must be fantastic (never had)
4) I still don’t care for Chilean cabs
5) Barolo is very interesting, need to try more
© 2003-26 CellarTracker! LLC. All rights reserved. "CellarTracker!" is a trademark of CellarTracker! LLC. No part of this website may be used, reproduced or distributed without the prior written permission of CellarTracker! LLC.

2009 Peter Michael Chardonnay Cuvée Indigene 88 Points
USA, California, Sonoma County, Knights Valley
(6/1/2012)
This was pretty cold when I tasted and non-blind. Nose was a littly shy showing a waxy character and ripe golden fruit. Palate was massively concentrated for a chard, plenty of tropical fruit and soft mouthcoating feel but heavy and viscous. Finish was long lasting, buttery. Big and blowsy, hard to imagine drinking something like this with food as there seems to be little acidity. Not my style.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No