Dinner at Swa Garden

Swa Garden, MacPherson Road, Singapore
Tasted Saturday, July 6, 2013 by Paul S with 627 views

Introduction

We gathered the gang in one of my old haunts for a quick and delicious Teochew meal paired with (as usual) blind, BYO wines. Some really interesting stuff this time round, but I must say, it was the great food that really stole the show.

Flight 1 - WHITE (3 Notes)

  • NV Villa Sandi Prosecco di Valdobbiadene Superiore di Cartizze Vigna La Rivetta 91 Points

    Italy, Veneto, Prosecco di Valdobbiadene Superiore di Cartizze

    I really enjoyed this - a world away from simple, cocktail party fizz, it must be one of the very best Proseccos I have had. It had a really pretty nose, clearly not Champagne, but very attractive with lots of floral notes floating around a base of apples and artichoke aromas, some yeast and mineral, and a nice litf of fennel-like spice. It was the palate that really surprised though - there was serious quality here - clean, fresh, with a fine mousse running through delicious flavours of apple flesh and whte peach, with more floral highlights at the side, this was really nice. There seemed to be the lightest touch of residucal sugar here, but it was a lot more serious than your run-of-the-mill Prosecco, showing a round fleshiness and depth and some complexity too, especially towards the finish, where the fruit and flowers were met with a cool bit of minerality and a nice spicy, cumin and fennel twist. Really nice stuff, lovely pairing with both our oyster omelette and caryfish dishes, and great value as well - I would buy this again in a heartbeat.

    Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • 2010 Montalto Vineyards Chardonnay Estate 92 Points

    Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Mornington Peninsula

    Wow - I was very impressed by this. Kelvin had carted this back from NZ after serendipitously stopping over at the winery to use the restroom and being blown away by their wines. Served blind, tt was one of the best new world Chardonnays I have had in sometime. And this was all the more remarkable given that the wine we drank was actually from a bottle that had been opened 6 days before, with part of it being double-decanted into a half-bottle and brought for this dinner. It had a lovely nose, with cream and butter, some toasty oak shades, than expressive but controlled aromas of sweetly spiced apples, sweet pears and some tiny floral, tropical hints, all underlined by flinty minerality. Very nice. The palate was very round, very full, with fleshy apples and pears, almost pineapples at the edges, then a lift of citrus lemons at the edge. Yet such was the lovely balance and poise, the juicy tension on the wine that most of the table guessed it was a Burgundy rather than a new world. Some savoury white meat and mineral notes past the midpalate certainly helped to bolster that impression as well. It was only at the long finish, where a little ripe sweetness crept in and there was a tiny shade of popcorny oak, that I changed my guess to new world instead, but a very good one indeed. Solid stuff.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2007 Tement Sauvignon Blanc Grosse Lage STK Ried Zieregg 92 Points

    Austria, Styria, Südsteiermark

    This was good, even very good, but I have not had this for some time and coming back to it after three years, it left me rather less impressed than in the last time round. Served blind, I must say I still really liked it, but I was not blown away, and neither was most of the table. It may well be that we did not give it enough time to open up. The nose though, was very nice even on first pour - tons of lychee, some grass and ripe gooseberries, green pears, green mangoes, a bacldrop of earth and mineral notes some gingko nuts. Very complex and nicely attractive. Guesses were all over the place with this one - Alsace Pinot Gris, Loire Chenin Blanc etc - it was only the faint whiff of cats pee that emerged with time that made me call it an SB. The palate, while very good indeed, was not quite as expressive as the nose. It was round, fleshy and deep, very full on the palate, with a slightly oily texture that once again brought to mind Didier Dageuneau's wine, showing rather neutral white fruited flavours of melons and pears at first though. Only with some time and when the wine warmed up after extended time in the ice-bucket did more nuanced flavours of gingko nuts, lemons and sweet gooseberries emerge, along with a nice stream of spice and a little undercurrant of slatey mineral moving into a long finish. Some complexity at the last. All in all, I thought this was a really good, nice pairing with Teochew food too, but it seemed a shadow of its former self, always seeming as though there was a lot more to unlock in its depth. I think we either rushed through this a bit too quickly or that it needs a few more years in the bottle, or, as is most likely, both. This is a wine I would like to try again around 2015-2016.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 2 - RED (2 Notes)

  • 1995 Giacomo Conterno Dolcetto d'Alba Cascina Francia 90 Points

    Italy, Piedmont, Alba, Dolcetto d'Alba

    A pretty nice wine; tiring fast, but what remained was rather pleasant. I liked the nose, with its earthy forest floor aromas and layer of herb and spice, and then sweet notes of dried cherries and strawberrries in the background and a little some dried flower note. Very advanced, with just a tinge of soy at the sides, and a strangely confected muffin-like note, but that aside, rather attractive. The palate was still very fresh, but it was clearly starting to thin out. Still though, it retained a pleasant veneer of dark cherries and sour cranberries - a very clean, clear expression - on nice backbone of fine tannins and very bright acid. On the finish, some mineral and wood spice peeked out. Rather simple a wine nearing its 18th year, but very pleasant, and just about enough left in its tank to go very nicely with a Teochew braised goose dish - it is quite remarkable that a humble Dolcetto should have hang on this well for this long; time to drink up though!

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 1997 Domaine Laborbe-Juillot Givry 1er Cru Clos Marceaux 92 Points

    France, Burgundy, Côte Chalonnaise, Givry 1er Cru

    This was another surprise - it is not everyday that a good 18 year-old Dolcetto is followed by an even better 15 year-old Givry, both punching way above their weight class. There was a really nice nose here, with earthy forest floor, dark cherries, some cooked meat aromas and a bit of spice - on the masculine side of Burgundy, but still clearly a Burg. The palate was round, fleshy and very nicely developed, with tannins having softened into a fine velvety feel and juicy acidity enlivening the wine's mouthfilling notes of dried cherries, bramble and some foresty shades. There was something in the mouthfeel on the wine, it was so soft and approachable, that I had little hesitation calling it a 1997 when blind. However, unlike quite a few 1997s even from good Côte d'Or producers, this still had a semblance of structure to it. There was a certain rusticity in the way it was set out, with herby menthol and mint notes at the finish, so that the table was split on whether it was a Côte Chalonnaise or Côte d'Or - but one thing we all agreed upon, this was at peak, and absolutely delicious.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 3 - SWEET (1 Note)

  • 2009 Wagner-Stempel Siefersheimer Heerkretz Riesling Spätlese 91 Points

    Germany, Rheinhessen

    As has been the case with almost every Wagner-Stempel wine I have had, this was far sweeter than its Pradikat level would give one to expect. Served blind, the guesses were all Auslese or even Auslese GKA. That aside, it was actually a pretty good wine. It had a big fruited Rheinhessen nose, showing peach and apricot aromas slathered with honey and laced with some spice and chalky mineral notes. Much the same on the palate - sweet, honeyed flavours of apricots and nectarines, ripe red apples, all thankfully buoyed by lots of lovely juicy acidity and brighter, almost limey citrus notes on the midpalate. It finished with a some slatey mineral that gave a nice relief. A very powerful, in-your-face expression for sure, still very primary and really too sweet for Spat. But for all that, it was clearly a decently good wine, and one that should show nicely say in 10 years or so. On the night, a bit too much on its own, but a great foil for an equally sweet yam paste (Orh Ni) dessert.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

×
×