Luciana's, Dana Point, CA
Tasted Sunday, May 4, 2014 by brigcampbell with 617 views
First, thanks to Mike for supporting this effort and providing a few of the wines and carving out the time to let us badger him. I know he doesn't do many of these types of events so it's greatly appreciated by everybody in attendance. FMIII did another amazing job of organizing the clan for dinner at Luciana's in Dana Point. Below is a picture of the private cellar room where we hid for the evening, very nice atmosphere and terrific food. I typically don't provide commentary on the food but I scratched out a few observations. 
A few of the special guests. 
Very simple yet perfectly paired salad with the white flight. I think the lemon vinaigrette beautifully complemented the acid of the wines. 
Brown butter sauce, you could pour that over gravel and it'd be tasty. The squash had a real freshness to it and it wasn't over cooked into mush. Had a bit of pumpkin flavors too, I like pumpkin. 
Wow, this was nice. Had the consistency of pork and the roasted garlic and rosemary... Says it all. 
This was very good. I thought it was short ribs, that's a good thing. 
The grilled polenta with loads of butter, very decadent. The sausage was nice and lacked any of the gristle or fat you find in cheaper sausage. 
There's raspberry flavored cheese filling layered with the chocolate. Great consistency and strong berry flavor. Held up to the petite sirah. 
Here's a great piece of nostalgia, Frank brought the very first mailing list flyer he every received way back in 2002. In those days Mike folded, stuffed, and addressed every envelope himself. Ah, the glamour and romance of being a winemaker! The good news is it all seems to be working out for Carlisle. 
2011 Carlisle Compagni Portis
USA, California, Sonoma County, Sonoma Valley
Light straw color. Aromas of perfume, petrol, and yellow fruit. Medium weight, light spice, pear on the attack, high acid mid palate. Finishes with lots of lemon rind and just a ton of complexity. Reminds me of a Chenin.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2012 Carlisle Compagni Portis
USA, California, Sonoma County, Sonoma Valley
Light straw color. Nose is tight compared to the '11 with a whiff of yellow pear. Flavors of lemon rind, musk, and medium plus acidity. Good complexity.
16 months on lees, no oak, and no malo.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No