Home (Noe st)
Tasted Wednesday, December 23, 2015 by RajivAyyangar with 227 views
A face-off of Turkheim granite Grand Cru Pinot Gris. Same year (2012), same producer (Boxler) and two different Turkheim Granite vineyards:
Brand - steep south-easterly amphitheater (natural "cirque").
Sommerberg - steep southern-exposed vineyard. Wiptal is the special parcel Boxler sources from. It has a reputation for more structured wines, and that comes through here, with an added jolt of florality.
A wonderful pairing. Both epitomize the style of lusciousness balanced by mostly mineral energy, rather than acidity.
2012 Albert Boxler Pinot Gris Brand 92 Points
France, Alsace, Alsace Grand Cru
Medium-gold. Luscious, tightly-knit nose of underripe white peach, peach pit, crushed stones, subdued and well-knit tropical fruits (specifically custard-apple / sitaphal). Relatively clean (no oxidation or botrytis) if flamboyant style, estery (generic floral tones, faint hints of ripe banana). Ever so slightly reductive (rubbery sulfur tones) but it blew off quickly.
The aromas are well-knit together. A balance between savory and ripe.
In the mouth, this tingles with a mineral energy and vibrantly elevated acidity (medium plus). There's a fair bit of residual sugar, maybe 15-20g/L, but the sweetness is well-lit by the acid and mineral energy, as well as offset by a perfectly modest does of phenolic bitterness. Alcohol is slightly elevated (13.5%) but again, well-integrated.
Stylistically, this is classic Pinot Gris, on the cleaner side for Alsace, with compelling varietal aromatics.
The Brand Grand Cru vineyard is one of the most well-known Turkheim granite vineyards. A steep natural amphitheater with excellent exposure. Why is this relevant? I'm not sure. Maybe there's something to be said about the vintage with the particular "precocity" of this vineyard but it's beyond me.
2012 was warm and good for PG, Pinot Noir, Gewurz - not as much Riesling. This definitely shows the warm character with the expansive, ripe fruit, and elevated alcohol plus sugars.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2012 Albert Boxler Pinot Gris Sommerberg Wibtal 92 Points
France, Alsace, Alsace Grand Cru
Medium plus gold. Well-knit nose of peach pit, custard-apple (sitaphal) that differs from the Brand by a stab of floral tones - white flower petals.
Slightly more structured in the mouth than the Brand, with a more pronounced bitterness and more notable acid (solidly medium plus) and mineral energy, leaves the tongue in a tingle. Residual sugar seems slightly lower, maybe in the 15 g/L range. Alcohol is comparable (also 13.5%).
I think I slightly prefer this to the GC Brand, but really they are two perfectly valid expressions of GC Pinot Gris. Again, this is quite clean, with no noticeable botrytis and even a faint hint of reduction. I would bet this ages a bit longer given the structure.
From a sub-parcel "Wiptal" within the Sommerberg Grand Cru (granitic soil, near Turkheim). Similar to Brand, it has great exposure.
2012 was warm and good for PG, Pinot Noir, Gewurz - not as much Riesling. This definitely shows the warm character with the expansive, ripe fruit, and elevated alcohol plus sugars.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No