Yan, National Gallery, Singapore
Tasted Tuesday, December 15, 2015 by Paul S with 558 views
This was a quartet of birthday celebrations - Chad, Gina, Alex and William. We had two tables this time, so almost every wine was served blind in magnums. Interesting exercise - the pair of Potel's at the end aside, the wines seemed fresher and more vibrant than one would expect from a 750ml. Happy Birthday all!
In an odd German Riesling magnum format, this bottle looked a bit like a baseball bat in its length and dimensions. The wine itself was a bit on the simple side, but it was otherwise pleasing enough. The nose showed telltale petroleum notes alongside sweeter aromas of apple flesh and then some lemon zest and a nice dose of chalky minerality. The palate came across very juicy and lemony at first, but then opened up into apples and a hint of white peach on the midpalate, with a little flesh peeking out from its bright acid frame. I found this to be very elegant and light on its feet; perhaps a touch simple, but good with food. It does need a more few years in the bottle though.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
A lovely new world Chardonnay, quite at peak now. This had a beautifully perfumed nose – flowers and sweet cream, beeswax and honey, with ripe lemons and sweeter stone fruit aromas, all rounded off with a touch of salted caramel and toasty oak. I was actually quite surprised that a lot of people guessed that this was a Grand Cru Burgundy with a sunny nose like that, but I could just about see why when we got to the elegant balance and integration on the palate – qualities that more often than not escape warmer new world Chardonnays. There was a really nice yumminess to this, with creamy flavors of sweet peach and apricots and nectarines shaded with just a touch of toasted corn and coconut oak notes. There was lovely weight, but also equally lovely balance throughout, with the acid and fruit all beautifully integrated from the attack to the long finish with its dash of spice. I thought the oak treatment was obvious, but otherwise, this was very delicious in a very upfront, summery way. In magnum, this was at peak and really enjoyable now – a great example of what a Californian Chardonnay can be.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
We have all become fans of Francois Bertheau’s wines in the past few years, so it was a bit of a treat to try his father’s handiwork – especially since the Bonnes Mares is probably the best wine in the family’s stable. This was the only wine on the night that came in two separate 750ml bottles rather than in a magnum format, but pours from either bottle still felt really alive for an almost 35 year-old Burgundy from a middling vintage. It had a beautiful nose, with perfumy wafts of dried flowers and orange peel floating about mature aromas of dried cherries and blueberries, then sour plums and earth – a lot of people actually guessed Chambolle with a pretty bouquet like that. The palate was a lovely mix of the soft and the firm. Fine tannins had already mellowed into a creamy mouthfeel, but there was also some muscle left, with a nice strength showing in the wine’s flavours of cherry and blueberry seasoned with a flush of dried flowers and spice. Actually, very strong for 1981 I thought, with a nice succulence on the midpalate and decent acidity keeping the wine on its feet nicely. There was just a touch of austerity showing in the long finish, and this was nowhere as silkily elegant as the recent Francois Bertheau examples. However, all that apart, it was really pleasurable and full of charm – a wine that I enjoyed tremendously. Probably time to drink up.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
Wow. This village wine was a canvas for showing off the joys of a mature Burgundy from a great vintage, well-stored (in a magnum no less), and drank just as it hit its peak. 50% of the wine came from young vines Musigny I am told, as these were the days before Vogue declassified the Moose into a Chambolle 1er Cru, and the quality certainly showed. It had a wonderful nose that just wafted out of the glass with meltingly sweet aromas of cherries and berries, spice and herb, with a lovely floral perfume of dried rose petals weaving in and out of the fruit. Beautiful. The palate was classic 1985, marrying sappy depth and sweet sunny flesh to a great freshness and purity, so that there was a lovely fresh-fruited crunch to its sweet flavours of cherries and red berries, again perfumed with a nice floral character. This really was a perfect gem of a Chambolle-Musigny, with a jewel-like clarity and elegance to it. From magnum, it was at peak and drinking wonderful well too. Of course it did not quite have the weight of a great Grand Cru, but at 30 years of age, this was probably one of the best Burgundy villages that I have ever had.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
A real charmer of a CDP and (from a magnum) at a perfect place for drinking now. It started out with a wonderful nose, with meaty, earthy tones - roast beef I thought – shading a core of black cherries and sweet plums seasoned with warm, fragrant spices and fresh herb. There were some bretty, gym sock hints at the sides, but these added interest rather than distracted from what was otherwise a lovely bouquet. The brettiness came out again on the palate, but again not in large enough doses to distract from the wine’s better qualities. Here, fine-boned, ever-so-slightly powdery tannins and gentle acidity framed pure, expressive flavours of cassis, blackberries on the attack and midpalate, and then a lovely earthy minerality as the wine glided into a succulent finish. Neither the most powerful nor the most complex, but this was a real charmer, perfectly balanced and nicely elegant, showing all of the dialed-back presence and classic styling that I always enjoy in Vieux Telegraphe wines. A great drink, especially in the context of the weaker vintage.
Post a Comment / 3 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
A pretty good wine, drinking quite nicely out of a magnum. As always, this was quite impossible to pick out when blind, but it all made perfect sense when unveiled. There was a whiff of Musar’s typical melange of earthy funk, meat and tobacco on the nose, along with complex notes of cherries and wild berries, capsicums, and something faintly floral – dried rose petals maybe. That funk carried across to the palate as, where there was a trace of smelliness I could best describe as wet goat fur drifting its way around an otherwise lovely, bright mouthful of cherries and berries on the attack and midpalate, and then notes of wild herb, menthol and a unusual hint of gingko nut around the finish, all this laced with soft, powdery tannins. Overall, not fantastic, but this was a nice wine, drinking well too.
Post a Comment / 2 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
A really delicious matured Bordeaux. Not the strongest Claret by any means, but in a magnum format, it was drinking at what seems like peak. This was classic Pauillac. It smelt like a gentleman’s club on the nose, with deep leather and tobacco aromas swirling around a lighter core of sweet cassis, earth and capsicum notes. Very nice. The palate was completely resolved and almost seemed to melt in the mouth, with soft, barely there tannins and perfectly integrated acidity dripping through lovely, pure notes of cassis and capsicum, earth and mineral, with just a twist of black tea at the finish. This was utterly delicious, especially when paired with a lamb dish. It did lack some oomph, coming across rather light-weight, but boy was it at a sweet spot and drinking marvelously well. I half suspect that normal 750ml bottles would be slightly past it, but in a magnum, it was at a perfect place.
Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
First of a pair of rather disappointing Potel bottles. I have had a couple of bottles of this particular wine in the past. One really nice one in 2012 followed a very disappointing example in 2013. Unfortunately, this bottle was more akin to the later than the former. It was not a bad wine by any means, but again fell way short of what one would expect from a good RSV. I must say that it did have a beautiful nose, with whiffs of black cherries and the very darkest berries tossed together with some funky earth and meat, and a twist of licorice. Nice, but not quite RSV – this came across more like a very extracted Pommard or, dare I say, even a Chateauneuf-du-Pape with that bouquet. No one got it right blind. The palate shared some of the character of the nose. Far from the elegance and silk one would expect from the vineyard, we instead got lots of power and richness in the wine’s expression of dark cherries and blackberries. On the attack and midpalate at least, this certainly had impressive depth, even for a Grand Cru, and a nice bit of freshness as well. I just thought it felt rather clunky and lacking in charm, with a certain monolithic stubbornness that sometimes afflicts Potel’s wines. The finish conspired to thin out a little too, with the fruit fading behind a cloak of spice and herb Altogether, a decently good drink but, even in a magnum format, this is a wine that seems to be quickly losing its vitality and charm.
Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
Good but boring. If at all possible, this semmed to be quite a mechanical, paint-by-numbers Burgundy. It had a nice nose, with a touch of funky forest floor alongside dark cherries and plums and a hint of spice and rubber. The palate showed a good bit of fresh, juicy acidity running through a muscular, broad-shouldered mouthful of cherries edged with earth and spice and a touch of orange peel towards the finish. All in all, well-made and quite classily shaped, with just a touch of drying tannins throwing the overall feel off by a bit. However, the wine seemed to lack passion and interest and, like the Romanee St Vivant before it, came across quite monolithic. In fact, it was similar enough to the previous wine for us to guess that this was another 2001 Potel Grand Cru en magnum, albeit from an indeterminate village in the Cote de Nuits. Altogether, good, but not great
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
© 2003-26 CellarTracker! LLC. All rights reserved. "CellarTracker!" is a trademark of CellarTracker! LLC. No part of this website may be used, reproduced or distributed without the prior written permission of CellarTracker! LLC.

2004 Gaston Chiquet Champagne Grand Cru Blanc de Blancs d'Aÿ 92 Points
France, Champagne, Champagne Grand Cru
I have had the 2004 Chiquet Special Club several times and loved each bottle. This was just a step behind I would say, but still really nice. It had a lovely nose, with fresh cream and white flowers and a soft sweetness, like the aroma of spun-sugar (I thought Chinese Dragon-Beard candy) and then a hint of white bread. A very pretty bouquet. The palate echoed the nose quite well. It was nicely elegant, with a gentle mousse framing soft, round, fleshy white-fruited flavours, and then a little stream of minerality peeking out at the finish. There was a nice, gentle presence and demenour to the wine. Unlike some other 2004s, it was fresh, but not threateningly so, with a beautifully integrated balance that, wed to its creamy textured roundness, made it so easy to drink. I think Champagne always tastes better out of a magnum, and this really just slipped down the throat. It was not the most powerful, but boy was it charming. Approachable and very enjoyable now, I do not think that this will be the most long-lived of 2004s, but it should continue to give lots of pleasure over the short to medium term.
Post a Comment / 2 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
NV Bérêche et Fils Champagne Brut Réserve 90 Points
France, Champagne
A fun Champagne, I liked this from magnum quite a bit more than the bottle I tried at EMP a few years back. 1/3 Chardonnay, 1/3 Pinot Noir and 1/3 Pinot Meunier, the bottle was marked Non-Vintage, but had some useful information on the back-label, including the fact that the base year for the wine was 2012, and that it was disgorged in Feb 2015. A bit reductive at first, it opened up into a very effervescent nose with time, showing lots of bright scents - fresh herb and mint, lime zest and green apples. Attractive. The palate was really fresh and lively too. There was clearly quite a bit of power and intensity on the wine, but what stood out more was its bright acidity and a really bubbly mousse that streamed out alongside a pure crunch of green apples and fresh cucumbers. Past those super-fresh flavours, a little dosage showed up with lightly sweet apple cider notes spreading past the midpalate and into the finish. Altogether a very decent NV and a fun drink even if, in a magnum format at least, it was way too young. This will be interesting to try it again in 4-5 years.
Post a Comment / 3 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No