Some history - the winemaker is Gideon Beinstock, former winemaker at Rennaissance, the Sierra Foothills legendary winery, and literal “cult wine” until the unfortunate regime change around 2006.
With a little chill on it, this truly resembled a Cru Beaujolais: -Red fruit -I’d guess there’s a little whole cluster or carbonic maceration -tannins are medium minus - so a bit high for Fleurie, but this could be a Morgon or Moulin-A-Vent.
There are a few reasons this isn’t Cru Beaujolais: There’s a dirtiness to the earth (manure-ish) that you wouldn’t normally find in CB. There's also bitterness to the tannins. Acid is just medium (I’d expect medium plus from CB). Alcohol is a touch elevated - I’ve guessed 13.5%, but it’s actually only 13%.
(No score - this is the same bottle I’ve been Coravining, and my evaluation hasn’t really changed, but I do feel more appreciative of this rustic, earthy, fruity wine).
Clean style (no botrytis) with a complexity to the fruit - shades of ripe peach, pineapple, cantaloupe, and radish - all well-contained, well-knit, and restrained. This is so nice! Score: Around 9.
We may have done this an injustice by not opening it in advance. It responded well to the last-minute, splashy decant, but the aromas seemed to tire too much. I can’t help thinking if we’d Audouzed this in the morning, it would have resembled the last bottle I had more.
Out of the bottle, reductive burnt rubber, overt Brett, and a distinct oxidative/nutty sherry note. In the mouth it appears medium-plus in body, with just slightly elevated acidity, and a pronounced bitterness.
~1 hr: It’s put on more flesh - warm translucent cooked apple. Slight balsamic notes (VA, but well-integrated). Brett is integrating a bit more, manifesting as savory complexity and less overt dog fur. There’s still some rubbery reduction but it’s calming down. Quite bitter still.
~2 hrs: Now it’s starting to sing. Wax, mushrooms. Yellow apple and brown pear, but with extreme purity. The bitterness is mostly replaced by a bright, nervoux, medium-plus acidity (I didn’t think this could happen, but it seems to be happening). The Brett is gone (blown off or integrated) and manifests as a slight savory complexity to the fruit. There’s a noble sweetness to this - fudgy apple, caramelized mushroom, slight dried mango. Burnt toast with apple butter, near a camp fire (the reduction, perhaps turning into interesting smoky/mineral notes?)
Just as the structure seemed to resemble my memory (elevated acid, no significant bitterness), the wine seemed to tire a bit (it had been in a very high-surface-area decanter, and we’d agitated it a fair amount. I’ll always wonder: Was this just a bad, reductive bottle, with strange bitterness, or could this have been different if we’d Audouzed it for several hours?
Score: Despite the awkwardness (perhaps our fault), this was profound, complex, and incredibly persistent. 9-9.5
2011 Domaine André Bonhomme Viré-Clessé
France, Burgundy, Mâconnais, Viré-Clessé
A solid, relatively neutral chard with a slight ripe lime character. Has a bit of body (13.5%) had been opened for a while so I won't rate it.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2014 Clos Saron Carignan The Pleasant Peasant
USA, California
Some history - the winemaker is Gideon Beinstock, former winemaker at Rennaissance, the Sierra Foothills legendary winery, and literal “cult wine” until the unfortunate regime change around 2006.
With a little chill on it, this truly resembled a Cru Beaujolais:
-Red fruit
-I’d guess there’s a little whole cluster or carbonic maceration
-tannins are medium minus - so a bit high for Fleurie, but this could be a Morgon or Moulin-A-Vent.
There are a few reasons this isn’t Cru Beaujolais:
There’s a dirtiness to the earth (manure-ish) that you wouldn’t normally find in CB.
There's also bitterness to the tannins. Acid is just medium (I’d expect medium plus from CB). Alcohol is a touch elevated - I’ve guessed 13.5%, but it’s actually only 13%.
(No score - this is the same bottle I’ve been Coravining, and my evaluation hasn’t really changed, but I do feel more appreciative of this rustic, earthy, fruity wine).
Post a Comment / 2 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
2013 Weingut Willi Bründlmayer Grüner Veltliner Alte Reben Kamptal Reserve 91 Points
Austria, Niederösterreich, Kamptal
Clean style (no botrytis) with a complexity to the fruit - shades of ripe peach, pineapple, cantaloupe, and radish - all well-contained, well-knit, and restrained. This is so nice!
Score: Around 9.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
1999 Chateau Musar Blanc Flawed
Lebanon, Bekaa Valley
We may have done this an injustice by not opening it in advance. It responded well to the last-minute, splashy decant, but the aromas seemed to tire too much. I can’t help thinking if we’d Audouzed this in the morning, it would have resembled the last bottle I had more.
Out of the bottle, reductive burnt rubber, overt Brett, and a distinct oxidative/nutty sherry note. In the mouth it appears medium-plus in body, with just slightly elevated acidity, and a pronounced bitterness.
~1 hr: It’s put on more flesh - warm translucent cooked apple. Slight balsamic notes (VA, but well-integrated). Brett is integrating a bit more, manifesting as savory complexity and less overt dog fur. There’s still some rubbery reduction but it’s calming down. Quite bitter still.
~2 hrs: Now it’s starting to sing. Wax, mushrooms. Yellow apple and brown pear, but with extreme purity. The bitterness is mostly replaced by a bright, nervoux, medium-plus acidity (I didn’t think this could happen, but it seems to be happening). The Brett is gone (blown off or integrated) and manifests as a slight savory complexity to the fruit. There’s a noble sweetness to this - fudgy apple, caramelized mushroom, slight dried mango. Burnt toast with apple butter, near a camp fire (the reduction, perhaps turning into interesting smoky/mineral notes?)
Just as the structure seemed to resemble my memory (elevated acid, no significant bitterness), the wine seemed to tire a bit (it had been in a very high-surface-area decanter, and we’d agitated it a fair amount. I’ll always wonder: Was this just a bad, reductive bottle, with strange bitterness, or could this have been different if we’d Audouzed it for several hours?
Score: Despite the awkwardness (perhaps our fault), this was profound, complex, and incredibly persistent. 9-9.5
Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No