Deductive Practice with an MS

Mosu, SF
Tasted Tuesday, March 1, 2016 by RajivAyyangar with 344 views

Introduction

full notes: https://www.evernote.com/l/ABYZnBsT97ZOs7bN7r6oeXTwodzLjNQrd_Q

Tim and I tasted with Kevin Reilly, MS. The format was incredibly helpful:

First, I went through a full grid on White 1, making a conclusion. Tim tasted along and weighed in.
called: 2014 Alsace AOP Riesling. Tim concurred.
actual: 2012 Trocken Riesling, Mosel

Next, Tim went through a full grid on Red 1, making a conclusion. I tasted along and weighed in.
Tim: Barbaresco
me: 2013 Zinfandel, Sonoma County
actual: 2013 Zinfandel, Sonoma County

Then, I did the sensory only for Red 2, and Tim did the conclusions
Tim: Rioja (and confirmed after tasting)
Me: Brunello
actual: 2005 Rioja Gran Reserva
--> Oak was the most important thing on this wine. If you're going between Rioja and Brunello, and it would be a Rioja Gran Reserva... it's probably a Rioja.

Finally, Tim did the sensory on White 2, and I did the conclusion.
Me (after Tim's sensory): Pinot Grigio
Me (after tasting): 2013 Federspiel Gruner
actual: 2013 Federspiel Gruner

Flight 1 (4 Notes)

  • 2012 Karthäuserhof Riesling Ruwer Trocken 88 Points

    Germany, Mosel Saar Ruwer

    Super mineral, ripe fruit, lime and floral aromas etched in stone and a fairly distinct TDN/Petrol. Not super aromatic though.

    -----------
    (blind)
    Visual

    - Clear, day-bright
    - Moderate gold, reflections of straw
    - no gas or sediment
    - moderate viscosity

    Nose

    - clean
    - medium minus intensity
    - underripe stone fruit
    - underripe white peach
    - underripe nectarine
    - not getting much out of this
    - generic white flowers
    - no herbaceousness
    - no signs of oak - will confirm on the palate
    - low complexity
    - nose has a little lime
    - a little saffron - botrytis

    Palate

    - Mostly dry - 3-4g RS
    - medium body
    - moderate alcohol 12% (close - 11.5%)
    - medium plus acid (amend to high acid)
    - no phenolic bitterness or tannins
    - beach ball, shower curtain, petrol
    - strong impression of stony minerality
    - no signs of oak
    - no signs of development - youthful
    - balanced in an acid-driven way
    - moderate plus finish

    Initial

    - balance, moderate alcohol, high acid —> Old World, cool climate
    - petrol —> Riesling
    - slight botrytis and moderate alcohol and relative dryness would take me away from the Mosel —> Alsace
    - German Riesling would be cleaner, more RS, less alcohol
    - Australia: clean and no RS (and higher alcohol)
    - Austrian Riesling - not sure how to separate from Alsace

    Final

    - Alsace AOP Riesling 2014
    - actual: Mosel Riesling Trocken (you'd tell this from Alsace because it's a bit cleaner, aromatics a bit more refined).

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2013 Weingut Knoll Grüner Veltliner Federspiel Loibner 88 Points

    Austria, Niederösterreich, Wachau

    A good example - clearly I think so since I nailed it as a 2013 Federspiel blind :)
    The melon aromas were really nice, and the acid was well-balanced.
    -----------
    (blind)
    Tim initially did a grid that made it seem firmly in the Pinot Grigio camp.
    My notes upon tasting:
    - color is a bit deep for pinot grigio - moderate lemon with hints of gold
    - nose has a fair bit of creamy peach and melon
    - structure: I think it’s around 13% alcohol - a bit higher than Tim. (actually 12%)
    - vegetal - sweet radish
    - gruner, federspiel. I said 13% alcohol, but it doesn’t have the ripeness to be Smaragd.
    - —> Federspiel or equivalent from Kremstal or Kamptal, 2013

    Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • 2013 Seghesio Family Vineyards Zinfandel Sonoma County 86 Points

    USA, California, Sonoma County

    Classic Sonoma Zin. Pretty solid.
    --------
    (blind)
    Dry medium plus acid
    -Slight RS
    -medium minus tannins
    -High alcohol
    -15% (close, 14.8%)
    -M- Ruby. Pink rim.
    -red fruit and slightly raisinated fruit
    - Cranberry and grapey blackberry dark plum. Raisination.
    -some new oak - 10-20% new or 2nd use barrels
    Zinfandel.
    Could be:
    CA Merlot - I’d expect more oak and cassis/dark fruit. Less of a range of fruit.
    OZ Shiraz - no black pepper, savory notes
    OZ Grenache - not sure how to discount this. Maybe more red fruits? Lower acid.
    (forgot to consider Amarone because of the raisination but it would have higher alcohol and be darker in color)
    —> Zinfandel, recent vintage. 2013.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2005 Bodegas Valdemar Rioja Conde de Valdemar Gran Reserva 88 Points

    Spain, La Rioja, La Rioja Alta, Rioja

    This is pretty delicious - great integration of oak over time, with ripe red fruit as well.

    ----
    (blind)
    Visual

    - clear, bright
    - med- ruby, red rim
    - no gas or sediment
    - med+ viscosity

    Nose

    - clean, shows oxidation, significant development
    - dried red fruit - dried cranberry, dried raspberry
    - dried flowers
    - leather
    - wet leaves, dried leaves
    - savory umami quality - development
    - a little fresh ham - savory development
    - a little spice here - not sure where it’s coming from
    - signs of neutral oak on the nose - will confirm on the palate

    Palate

    - dry
    - medium plus bodied
    - high alcohol - 14.5% (actually 13.5%)
    - medium plus acid
    - medium plus tannins (amended to high)
    - signs of oak on the palate - it’s spent some time in oak, not 100% new
    - savory baking spices, a little clove, rounded sweetness to the wine
    - red fruits - dried
    - dried roses
    - lots of earth - sweet tobacco, dried leaves
    - stemmy herbaceous quality - not necessarily stem inclusion
    - dark liquorice note
    - balanced - acid balances the alcohol
    - moderate plus complexity
    Retasting:
    - moderate plus finish
    - retasting: medium plus tannin
    - spent a lot of time in oak, maybe not new oak.
    - Going between Brunello and Rioja Gran Reserva [you shouldn’t go between GR and Brunello!] - the oak is really important here.
    - I called it Brunello. I think this isn’t a good call.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

×
×