Amoroso Room, Bellevue Wine Storage
Tasted Tuesday, September 20, 2016 by skifree with 461 views
Somehow our group convinced F22Nickell that a Merlot blend tasting should be our theme for September, despite his dislike (?!!) of the grape. He was certainly a good sport about the event, as he agreed to organize the tasting for us all (though he forgot his wine that he declared, so perhaps there was some internal conflict). Eleven of us got together at the Amoroso Room in Bellevue on a beautiful September evening; these are events that most of us look forward to each month.
We started with our usual potpourri of white and red wines before our tasting event, with appetizers and then a potluck dinner to share. Tutta Bella pizza, pasta fagioli soup, salad, dolmades, pork chow mein, a variety of good cheeses with bread and crackers, and olives are what I remember of the dinner fare.
As usual, I sampled only a few of the pre-function wines, and did not take pictures nor detailed notes on the wines. My favorite was a 2015 white Vin de Savoie, though I also tried a Pinot Gris, a Riesling (oxidized), and a Tuscan blend that was decanted and was very satisfactory to accompany the assortment of foods on my plate.
We had nine wines for the tasting, with a 2010 Uriah Spring Valley replacing the forgotten Force Majeure Collaboration Series IV (not well, as it turned out). As usual, we had declared which wines we were bringing in advance, but the wines were bagged and lettered so we did not know which wine was which in our glass while tasting. We do not spit the wines (not practical due to space limitations), but taste enough to decide about a wine and then pour the rest out.
I have to admit I am a particular fan of Merlot, and have lots of St. Emilion and Pomerol in my cellar, as well as a number of Washington Merlot's that I like (Woodward Canyon, Long Shadows Pedestal, Leonetti). I declared a St. Emilion that was more Merlot than Cab Franc, but the later declarations were 100 % Merlot. As I said, F22 is a very good sport.
I was surprised by my low scores overall at the tasting, not sure why my numerical scores were so "grumpy". Perhaps I spent too much time reading Purple Pages reviews last week. Typically I like both "classic" and "new world" wines, though in this case I scored the younger, bigger wines lower.
After the tasting we moved on to dessert, with the choice being a raspberry cheesecake or a "chocolate explosion" cake. I chose the latter; very tasty.
We had 3 dessert wines to choose from:
1) 2002 Doisy Daene Barsac. I love Doisy Daene, but this was not my favorite; it lacked the complexity I expect from them. I am realizing 2002 is not a favorite sticky vintage for me.
2) 2009 La Tour Blanche. Still very light in color; enjoyable and well made but didn't knock my socks off (perhaps palate fatigue?).
3) 2009 Taylor Fladgate Port (I think I got this right). I didn't know what to make of this; seemed quite dry against the cake so I didn't know exactly what to make of this. My limited experience with Port tied my tongue, I think.
This was another great night, hope everyone enjoyed as much as I did.
Funny that I met Stephan von Neipperg in Vancouver in January while tasting the 2013 Bordeaux vintage, and that his 2001 wine then scores so highly in our blind tasting in September. Wish I had more of his wine in my cellar!
2010 Château Barde-Haut 87 Points
France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Saint-Émilion Grand Cru
Dark garnet in the glass. Menthol, chocolate on the nose. Body feels "big". Chocolate, baking spice, and plum in the mouth - comes across as a big wine with lots of tannins. Guessed (correctly) that this was young and needed time. Tasted single blind at CT SEA merlot blend and merlot tasting. My 7th, group's fifth at tasting, range was third through eighth among 11 tasters. I likely scored this too low as it was not decanted.
Read 1 Comment / Post a Comment / 2 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
1998 Château Beauregard 91 Points
France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Pomerol
Medium garnet in the glass. Leather, tobacco, and blackberry on the nose; seemed unmistakably Bordeaux. Tobacco, black tea, and black fruit in the mouth. Long finish, tannins still noticeable. Thought (incorrectly) that this was young, so way off on that point My second, group's second at CT SEA merlot blend and merlot tasting. Another kudo for '98 Pomerol.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2010 Freemark Abbey Merlot Napa Valley 88 Points
USA, California, Napa Valley
Medium garnet in the glass. Sweet fruit, menthol, alcohol on the nose. Quite juicy, with acidity in the background. Sweet generic fruit in the mouth, but then a bit harsh and alcoholic on the finish. My sixth of 9, group's sixth with a range of votes between 4th and 7th. Did not pick this out as the Cali in the line-up.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2011 Château Moulin Saint-Georges 88 Points
France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Saint-Émilion Grand Cru
Medium garnet in the glass. Sweet, ripe fruit on the nose. Quite acidic on the attack, but with flavors of fruit, tobacco mixed in. Quite a long finish, with lots of tobacco and earth. Overall impression for me was that this was quite primary. Tasted single blind at CT SEA merlot blend and merlot tasting. My fifth of nine, group's third just a tad behind the second place wine. Given its youth, this wine should have a solid future ahead.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2010 Northstar Merlot Premier 89 Points
USA, Washington, Columbia Valley
Medium garnet in the glass. Sweet fruit and flower on the nose. Seemed quite chalky in the mouth, with lots of spice and chocolate - a big wine. Had a long finish, but it felt a bit harsh - seemed very new world. Tasted single blind at CT SEA merlot and merlot blend tasting. My fourth of 9, group's 7th of nine with a range of scores from third through 8th.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2009 Kimmel Vineyards Merlot Flawed
USA, California, North Coast, Mendocino
Tasted single blind at CT SEA merlot and merlot blend tasting. Most of the table thought this wine was flawed, it was on the edge but not as noticeable as some I have had. The wine was flat and acidic for me in the mouth and on the finish. After some debate, we included it in the scoring as it was NOT the last place wine for some people. My ninth of 9, group's 8th of 9.
Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
2001 Château Canon-la-Gaffelière 93 Points
France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Saint-Émilion Grand Cru
Brought to Merlot blend and Merlot tasting with CT Seattle group. Tasted single blind. My number one, group's number one with 20 points total. 7 of 11 rated this #1, lowest was 5th of 9. Medium garnet in the glass. Most complex nose of the night; dominant "fruit rouge", tobacco, flower, yum. Lighter body. More fruit rouge in the mouth, good acids, some white pepper. Fruit and white pepper linger through the finish.
Scored this blind the same as when I savored with food from my cellar; perhaps my palate is not as "burned to a crisp" as I was afraid of!
Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
2006 Concha y Toro Merlot Marqués de Casa Concha 89 Points
Chile, Maule Valley
Dark garnet in the glass. Nice dusty note on the nose, but then the alcohol is noticeable. Big wine, hard to pick out all the fruits on the palate. Kind of a short finish, definitely a big bruiser of a wine. Tasted single blind at CT SEA merlot and merlot blend tasting. My third (tied in score with 4th place wine) of nine, group's 4th of nine.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2010 Spring Valley Vineyard Uriah 84 Points
USA, Washington, Columbia Valley, Walla Walla Valley
Dark garnet in the glass. Alcohol, bramble, and chocolate on the nose. Quite acidic in the mouth, with simple generic fruit blend dominating. Then the acids dominate the finish. Overall impression was of a simple wine. Tasted single blind at CT SEA merlot and merlot blend tasting. My eighth of nine, group's ninth of nine by a lot (it lost to a flawed wine!). The person who brought this was vocally adamant that they hated the wine, and were quite surprised to see it was the wine they brought upon reveal.
Read 3 Comments / Post a Comment / 3 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No