Tasted Friday, November 17, 2017 by HowardNZ with 536 views
Mark St Clair thought it would be interesting to collect all of the Les Saint Georges from a vintage for a horizontal tasting. The only grower's wine he was not able to acquire from 2011 was Domaine Zibetti's. The negociant Lucien Le Moine also produces a cuvée.
The tasting was the opportunity to think about several issues. Is the 1er Les Saint Georges climat appropriate for elevation to Grand Cru status, as some like Thibault Liger-Belair have argued? To what extent were there there pyrazine or green issues we could see in this fair cross-section of 2011s, a vintage where some have reported these issues? Finally, of course, given the same climat and vintage, how important to the wine quality was the viticulture and winemaking?
All wines served single blind.
Unsurprisingly, given the same climat and vintage, the human component was seen to be extremely important. Tasters occasionally commented on what they saw as Les Saint Georges terroir markers but, overall, winegrower and maker influence seemed the most dominant factor in quality.
To varying degrees we all saw some green elements in some of the wines. This seemed, to me any way, to be an issue of phenolic underripeness, rather than of an extreme pyrazine taint.
In this lineup, only the Liger-Belair and the Faiveley wines seemed to be of Grand Cru quality. That is perhaps however an unfair conclusion due to the moderate quality of the vintage and the fact, as Mike said, producers were not making the wines as Grand Crus (perhaps, the top two aside). Mark's view was though 'Regardless of vintage a Grand Cru should stand out'.
Thanks to Mark for organising this tasting.
2011 Domaine Henri Gouges Nuits-Saint-Georges 1er Cru Les Vaucrains
France, Burgundy, Côte de Nuits, Nuits-Saint-Georges 1er Cru
Cherry colour with touches of ocre at the rim. A bouquet of strawberries, raspberries, red cherries and orange rind. On palate, fully ripe, with fruit sweetness on entry. Pure red cherry fruit, backed by persistent, firm minerality. Not a hint of green. Below medium weight but with good balance and sufficient concentration and structure. Looking back, I preferred this wine to Gouges Les Saint Georges.
Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No