SommSelect Blind Six - March 2018

Shady Acres. Houston, TX
Tasted Saturday, March 31, 2018 - Sunday, April 1, 2018 by Heynetty with 588 views

Introduction

Been wanting to try these for a long time and finally my first consignment has arrived. Very excited to give these a whirl. Coravined the bottles from each flight and tasted over two days.

Flight 1 - The White Wines (3 Notes)

  • 2016 Scarbolo Friuli Grave Pinot Grigio 89 Points

    Italy, Friuli-Venezia Giulia, Friuli Grave

    (3/31/2018)

    Tasted Blind

    A: medium lemon with copper highlights. High viscosity (quite appealing actually)
    N: Medium (+) intensity, Youthful.
    Melon, orange peel, pineapple, lemon and FLORAL (JTH spotted that before I did). Florals definitely honeysuckle. At the bottom of the glass it smelled like a Pub floor 2 hours before closing i.e yeast and stale beer (got that after IC prompting).
    P: Aromas confirmed with addition of phenolic bitterness and is that wax (?).
    Dry, medium (+) acid (3 secs till drip), medium alcohol, medium (+) body, medium (+) intensity and medium finish.
    C: BLIC? Well balanced. The fruit and acid is lovely here. Tick for intensity and complexity. This is a Very Good Quality wine. Drink now.

    MY GUESS:
    I guessed it was a PG from the color and the fact there was no rose or lychee meant this was not a gewürztraminer that can also have the copper hues.
    Thought it was New World because I MISSED THE WET ROCKS but thought cool climate. I put it down as an Oregon PG or a novelty from further North which was silly now that i think about it as there was no sign of an oak barrel. The body here comes from time on the lees and battonage.

    MISTAKES:
    After reading Cauble's notes, i realized that i had missed a few things:
    Ian's Viscosity: medium (+) .... I had high viscosity
    Ian's Acid: medium .... I had medium (+) acidity
    Ian smelled: wet rocks, peanut shell and stale beer .... I didn't get the stale beer until re examining after the reveal.

    STALE BEER and PEANUT SHELLS are big markers for Pinot Grigio.

    Ian noted more apple and salt than i got but Jeff pointed the salt out early and then i got it on the palate. Find it tough getting salt on the nose.

    PRACTICE: Ripe Pinot Grigios can be easily mistaken for Albariño and less ripe examples as Grüner Veltliner as all typically have some bitterness or spiciness in common. Must try 2x PG against 2x Albarino against 2x Grüner .

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2016 Domaine Agnes et Didier Dauvissat Petit Chablis

    France, Burgundy, Chablis, Petit Chablis

    (3/31/2018)

    Tasted Blind

    A: Pale lemon GREEN [IC says medium color intensity]
    N: Florals. White flowers Lemon, grapefruit, lime, yellow apple, wet stone. Pretty neutral. Medium intensity and youthful.
    P: Dry, high acid [IC says medium (+)], medium alcohol, medium body, medium (+) intensity and medium finish [IC says medium (+)]. I am adding Wet stone and salt to the confirmed aromas.
    C: Guessed this was Old world, cool climate owing to acid and alcohol, thought the grape was actually muscadet as it was salty and cool climate and full of citrus.
    The salt was very apparent on the palate but i didn't realize what i thought was salt, was actually crushed oyster shell. The retronasal breathing really helped that chalky oyster shell to show up. NEED TO WORK ON THAT.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2016 Weingut Bauerl Grüner Veltliner Smaragd Stein am Rain

    Austria, Niederösterreich, Wachau

    (3/31/2018)

    I hope i put this under the right name. Should have Federspiel in the title

    SCREWCAP CORAVIN ACCESSED (by the way, the closure doesn't work so well after 5 days. The florals/white pepper disappeared on day 5)

    Tasted Blind

    A: Pale lemon green [IC says medium (+) color]
    N: First off there was ripe banana and pear drops but that smell passed about 15 minutes after pouring. Got herbs, celery, wet stones, lots and lots of white pepper. [IC had additional honey,radish, cucumber, wet rock] Medium intensity and youthful.
    P: My aromas were confirmed. Dry, medium acid [IC says medium (+)], medium alcohol, medium body, medium (+) intensity and medium (-) finish [IC says medium ].
    C: This young fresh wine is for drinking now and not laying down. BLIC? balance and intensity get ticks. Good Quality wine.

    MY GUESSES:
    Gruner Veltliner because of all that white pepper.
    Normally i would say Old World and cool climate without a doubt here but i failed to truly believe that it was. the acidity was strangely low (i was prob just dehydrated). Once i guessed it was gruner though, it was going to be from Austria and so wrote that down. Guessed Wachau as Kamptal and Kremstal would have a little more body.

    MISTAKES:
    I should rehydrate between wines. That correct acidity would have helped.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 2 - The Red Wines (3 Notes)

  • 2016 Domaine des Terres Dorées (Jean-Paul Brun) Morgon

    France, Burgundy, Beaujolais, Morgon

    (4/1/2018)

    Tasted Blind

    A: pale ruby
    N: Cherry, raspberry, vanilla, blackcurrant, blackcurrant leaf, something mineral in here.....graphite?, earth and some leather. Medium (+) intensity and developing.
    P: Dry, high acid [IC says medium (+)], medium (-) tannin, medium alcohol, medium (+) intensity and medium finish [IC says medium (+)].
    There is a real greenness here which i assume is green bell pepper.
    C:

    MY GUESSES:
    Its Old World with all that earth. Its not fruit driven.
    I think its cool climate with the acidity.
    Varietals - Likely Cab Franc from the loire. The pyrazine thing and graphite lead me here. As did the color intensity but the tannin seems a touch lower than i might expect.
    Age: Looks young. Ruby with a pink tint near the edge. I reckon its a 2016.

    Final Guess: 2016 Cab Franc from Chinon

    MISTAKES:
    So i can't tell the difference between green bell pepper aspect (seen in CBs) and green stemmy/herbal notes (seen in some Beaujolais).

    PRACTICE:
    Northern Rhone Syrahs (particularly young Crozes-Hermitage), Beaujolais Crus and Chinon are often confused. Try tasting these side by side

    Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • 2012 Azienda Agricola Guido Padeletti Brunello di Montalcino 89 Points

    Italy, Tuscany, Montalcino, Brunello di Montalcino

    (4/1/2018)

    Tasted Blind

    A: Pale garnet. High viscosity
    N: Medium intensity. Developing
    Tart cherry, orange peel, leather, tobacco, herbs and JTH got black tea [IC adds crushed clay, dried roses, fennel, mushrooms]
    P: Dry, medium (+) acid, medium (+) tannin, medium getting on to medium (+) body, medium (+) intensity, medium finish [IC says LONG].
    Aromas confirmed.
    C: This is built to last. I would drink now or hold 5+ years. Ticks for everything on the BLIC scale.

    MY GUESSES:
    Thought Old World, Cool climate and Italy.
    Varietal - either Pinot Nero or a Sangiovese or Nebbiolo.
    Age - 2013

    2013 Sangiovese - Brunello Montalcino

    MISTAKES:
    I TOTALLY guessed this one. I need to get better with recognizing different vintages. In addition, this could have been nebbiolo or pinot nero for me. I couldn't get any clear VA though i thought i had a whiff at the end of the glass which would have ruled out PN. Had i picked up the MUSHROOMS that IC got, it would have pushed me in the correct direction with less chance and more design.
    Try Pnot Nero, Nebbiolo and Brunelli side by side non blind.

    Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • 2016 Tyler Pinot Noir Santa Barbara County

    USA, California, Central Coast, Santa Barbara County

    (4/1/2018)

    Tasted Blind

    A: Pale ruby
    N: cherry, cranberry, strawberry, herbs, vanilla, baking spice, leather ? not leather , earth,but got a little floral note. Medium intensity [IC says high] and developing.
    P: Dry, medium (+) acid, medium (-) tannin [IC says medium], medium alcohol and medium intensity and finish [IC has medium (+) finish].
    C: This one is very young and so i would keep it for another 5 years or drink now. It has earthy undertones but good fresh fruit on top with a structure to extend its life significantly.

    MY GUESSES:
    Old World
    Cool to Moderate Climate
    Sangiovese, PN, Cab Franc, Nebbiolo
    2016

    In the end i thought 2016 Sangiovese or PN from Italy. Agh! WAY OUT

    PRACTICE:
    Try this atypical PN from California and compare to the Oregon and New Zealand styles which are its closes relatives. Add an Italian PN and Sangiovese from North Italy just to mix things up a bit.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Closing

Ian Cauble's notes are superb. I have paid vertiginous sums of cash for classes that didn't give me notes like this. Its definitely CMS leaning but still of great use to WSET students.

This first Blind Six round has whipped my assets. The reds were a disaster for me. Lots more practice on the cards, chaps!

×
×