UGC Bordeaux Tasting (2015 Vintage)

San Francisco
Tasted Thursday, January 25, 2018 by John Dunlap with 304 views

Introduction

With a high-level of anticipation, I finally got to tasted the 2015 Bordeaux as part of the January 25, 2018, Union des Grands Crus de Bordeaux tasting, here in San Francisco. It was an exciting tasting, but such events are also a lot of work - especially if you have only one glass to taste from and can’t sit down and compare wines over a long stretch of time. I guess that’s one (of many) differences between an amateur and an expert. I also wish some Chateaux such as Pontet Canet (yes, they once poured at UGC events), l’ Evangile, Feytet Clinet, Meyney, and others had participated.

OK, to generalize, many of the chateaux representatives pouring likened 2015 to 2009 and 2016 to 2010, with many giving an unofficial slight nod to 2016 over 2015. Yet, unless you are a millennial with forty years ahead of you, I don’t think it matters too much other than to say, that the 2015s can probably be consume at a slightly earlier age than the 2016s. Of course, this is conjecture on my part based on this evening’s conversations and having not yet tasted 2016 vintage.

For me, 2015 was clearly a Merlot year with Left Bank wines prevailing – especially the wines of Pomerol. Some mentioned that the best value were found in the St. Julien region and that maybe true, but I tended to return to the Right Bank because the wines were more intriguing and so rich.

But before I dive into the wines that interested me the most, let me say that Smith-Haut Lafitte (Blanc) was simply phenomenal and stands out above all other dry white wines and probably all the reds produced in 2015; it’s is one of the best wines of the entire evening: really beautiful. Very much worth seeking out, if you like white Bordeaux and have the discretionary funds to purchase the entire spectrum of wines.

As for the red Bordeaux, there were a number of good reds, of which, Chateau Rouget seemed most appealing with one of the best price points offered ($54.99/bottle). Others, that stand out include, Gazin, and Grand-Puy Ducasse. Also liked Chateau Beauregard. Was not “wowed” by Chateau Clinet, which was probably the wine I most wanted to taste that evening. My notes are limited to just a few chateaux.

Flight 1 (4 Notes)

  • 2015 Château Smith Haut Lafitte Blanc 96 Points

    France, Bordeaux, Graves, Pessac-Léognan

    Smith-Haut-Laffite (blanc) – Tons of guava-like flavors dominate with outstanding elements of honeysuckle, pomelo, gooseberry, citrus, and vanilla. The assemblage is 90 Percent Sauvignon Blanc, five percent each Sauvignon Gris and Semillon. The SHL's profile and approachability stood above all other dry whites tasted mostly to the lovely guava flavors, which the other 2015 blancs did not possess. I believe this wine’s profile was aged 50 percent in new barrels with light or “soft” toast. All other whites tasted that evening were dominated by a much more acidic grapefruit profile, which is wonderful, but not as unique. Not sure if the guava flavor element has a half-life to it and whether it will recede with time, thus revealing more “typical” citrus and grass elements, but who knows – it’s all good and will be fun to follow over the years.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2015 Domaine de Chevalier Blanc 95 Points

    France, Bordeaux, Graves, Pessac-Léognan

    Domaine de Chevalier (blanc) - A lovely wine and above all other whites tasted this evening - except for the Smith-Haut-Laffite blanc. An ensemble of 70 percent Sauvignon Blanc and 30 percent Semillon. The DdC has a more typical profile dominated by grapefruit flavors on the nose and palate. Detected a lovely lime element and just touch of clove – the latter of which - I am not sure where it comes from. Maybe the barrels used or perhaps the Semillon varietal? Sometimes I detect a bit of forest flavors in this producer, but not this time. Still, very complex and is one of the best dry whites tried this evening.

    Read 2 Comments / Post a Comment / 4 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • 2015 Château Clinet 90 Points

    France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Pomerol

    Clinet – Full disclosure - I did purchase some 2015 as futures, so I was hoping the wine would be amazing; yet, for some reason, the 2015 Clinet was not firing on all cylinders that evening. Maybe it was the specific bottles poured from the local distributor or the wine was still in travel shock; who knows? Nevertheless, the 2015 Client did not live up what was hoped for. That said, I am not giving up, as I think the wine will improve. Overall, I noted elements of red fruits and some chocolate/cherry flavors. Seemed closed and a bit musty. Hard to understand. Ninety percent Merlot, nine percent Cabernet Sauvignon, and one percent Cabernet Franc.

    I was perplexed by this wine, so I wanted to see if there were discrepancies in tasting scores that could conceivably be tied to who imports the wines or if the wines did not have enough time to rest after clearing customs. I looked at other scores on CT, which I try not to do before I write up my notes, to see if there was a correlation between scores and location.

    I had to make some assumptions on location of tasting based on the dates notes were posted. Listed below are the locations and dates of the UGC tastings plus the corresponding average wine score. All sample sizes are noted in parentheses.

    Washington DC 1/18/18 - 93 (1)
    Montréal 1/20/18 - 99 (1)
    New York City 1/22/18 - 97 (1)
    San Francisco 1/25/18 - 92 (2, not including my own score in the sample)
    Los Angeles 1/26/18 - 92 (2)
    Amsterdam 2/6/18 - 93 (3)

    Sure, the sample size is too small, so the overall analysis is inconclusive; however, the highest scores were from the east coast (NY and Montréal) and the most consistent scores were those from Amsterdam. Again, not sure this analysis means anything. Yet, I wonder if the 2015 Clinet tasted this January, in San Francisco, did not have ample time to rest or whether there is an issue with the transportation to the west coast. Maybe the chateau and/or importer can comment on my concerns? My hope is that the wine improves with time.

    Read 1 Comment / Post a Comment / 6 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • 2015 Château Rouget 92 Points

    France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Pomerol

    Rouget – a lovely wine that I can’t recall tasting before. Comprised of 85 percent Merlot and 15 percent Cabernet Franc. Twenty percent new oak employed in 2015. Broad, dark, fruits prevail with a nice sweet-fruit finish. Tannins are fine and also broad throughout the palate. Some iron like favors too. Classic in a rich Bordeaux manner. The vines are around 40 years old, which may account for part of the wine's deep flavor profile. Very nice and a good value.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

×
×