St Claudes, Oxford Street, Sydney
Tasted Thursday, August 16, 2018 by chatters with 235 views
Every year I blow a ridiculous sum of money on a preposterous Burgundy tasting…this qualifies as that tasting for 2018.
<shrugs>
That struck match/bacon fat/sulphur note was a common theme for me across this bracket.
with the exception of the 12, which was a bit too flat/lifeless, these were all good but not exceptional wines…I wouldn't be forking out $1000-1500 AUD for them, let's put it like that…
I thought the Fremiets was nice but a reasonable comment is that this is very young bracket...
The underlying spirit in this wine was a bit course for me.
First the tasting in general...There was a fair amount of 'How big is my dick'ing going on (my favourite quote of the night "I don't drink village wine but this is rather nice") which is most prevalent, in my experience, with Burgundy though I'm sure everyone has similar stories...
Now the wine…Hmm, yeah, okay…it's nice, very nice in some cases, but it's more of "savour the price of it" for me - I just didn't see the price justification for a lot of these wines which also begs the question...why am I spending silly money on tasting Burgundy when I can trawl the auction sites for Burgundy that is at an almost justifiable cost...
2010 Vilmart & Cie Champagne Premier Cru Coeur de Cuvée
France, Champagne, Champagne Premier Cru
More bread yeast and biscuit than brioche, soft lemon curd. Very citric on the palate; plenty of lemon with a little lemon pit, a little chalky minerality, mousse is exceedingly fine textured. Still quite primary despite 8 years under the belt. Would I pay 260 AUD for it? No thank you.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No