Jay 'splains Wine - Barbaresco Class

Kline Household
Tasted Saturday, March 23, 2019 by thesternowl with 170 views

Introduction

Part of a new series of educational tastings that my wife and friends wanted me to start. The name is a bit droll but whatever...it's all in good fun. The format is casual. They pick what they want to learn more about i.e. regions, varietal, etc. and I make the selections. We usually make a meal together and then we'll work through the wines. Tonight, the class was Barbaresco and all four wines came from my cellar.

Flight 1 - Barbaresco Class (4 Notes)

Four friends; Four Barbaresco crus; Four producers; Three separate vintages.

  • 2010 De Forville Barbaresco Black Label Loreto 92 Points

    Italy, Piedmont, Langhe, Barbaresco

    Popped and poured; noticeably darker than the two 2014's. Initially, this was cherries, damp forest floor, some mushroom and a little funk. After a couple of hours, this became really interesting. It gained some weight and added sun-dried tomatoes and a smokey, burned toast thing. In fact, I thought it had a rather remarkable Spaghetti-O's and Meatballs smell and I was alright with that. I realize that sounds crazy but once I mentioned it, that's what everyone else smelled too. LOL! The finish was long and savory. The tannins are still firm but well integrated. The 2010 "Loreto" delivered until the very last sip, nearly five hours after opening. This was a fantastic showing. Drink or Hold until 2025.

    Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • 2014 Cascina Roccalini Barbaresco Roccalini 91 Points

    Italy, Piedmont, Langhe, Barbaresco

    My first experience with Cascina Roccalini was last year with the 2013 vintage and I was hugely impressed so I was very excited to try the 2014 version. Popped and poured; initially bright ruby in the glass but became noticeably darker, turning to garnet after about fifteen minutes. The nose on the 2014 Roccalini was opulent; far and away the freshest and most interesting of the group in the first couple of hours with beautiful, ripe cherries, bruised red delicious apples, tar, baking spices and roses. So much pleasure! After about hour three, the roses gave way for Easter Lilies...which I can't ever recall in a red wine before. However, around hour five, the Roccalini started to fall apart and the finish became watery and thin which is exactly what happened to the 2014 "Sori Paitin"; further reinforcing my feeling that the 2014's will be a vintage to enjoy while they are younger and preferably within the first couple hours of being open. Drink now or before 2022.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2014 Paitin di Pasquero-Elia Barbaresco Serraboella Sorì Paitin 90 Points

    Italy, Piedmont, Langhe, Barbaresco

    Popped and poured. Like the Roccalini, this initially poured a bright ruby red which became a darker, almost garnet color with about 15 minutes of air. The 2014 Sori Paitin was distinctive with tar, roses, crushed rocks and, with a couple of hours in the glass, a bit of brown butter which was really interesting. However, around hour three, the finish became watery and thin...similar to what happened to the 2014 Roccalini but more so. I suspect this will be a recurring theme for the 2014 vintage in Barbaresco so my advice would be to drink these on the pop and pour and within the time-frame of a typical meal (a couple hours or so). Drink now or before 2022.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2009 Produttori del Barbaresco Barbaresco Riserva Montestefano 94 Points

    Italy, Piedmont, Langhe, Barbaresco

    Originally, I only planned to pour the De Forville, the Roccalini and the Paitin but it just didn't seem right to host a Barbaresco class and not have a Produttori in the mix. So, I pulled this from the cellar as a bonus. Boy, am I glad I did. On the pop and pour, this had a striking burnt rubber smell; like from a pencil eraser. This blew off after a few minutes however and became sensational with the most perfect expression of Montmorency cherries, tar, and crushed rock. The 2009 Produttori "Montestefano" is so balanced and yet incredibly powerful. It also remains powerfully tannic. The finish is remarkably long; lasting well over two minutes. This is still very primary and would benefit for continued cellar time. Wow...I love this wine. This will drink well for decades to come. Bottle No. 12202. Bravo!

    Post a Comment / 5 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

Closing

Two things stood out to me:

1. 2014 is definitely a vintage for early drinking.
2. Produttori Riserva's really are unbelievable value.

While all four wines were very good to great, the two 2014's showed their best within the first couple hours of being open and started to fall apart around hour three beginning with the Sori Paitin and the Roccalini followed suit about an hour later. The finish became thin and hollow...almost watery...like it had been diluted. In contrast, the De Forville "Loreto" and Produttori "Montestefano" delivered strong until the last sip, particularly the Produttori which was magnificent even into the next day.

×
×