Home (Noe st)
Tasted Monday, April 8, 2019 by RajivAyyangar with 230 views
Chardonnay, 2016, Paso, good quality - $50
Peter - 3 - called Southern Rhone white
Rajiv - 5
Krystian - 3
Roussanne, Grenache Blanc, Picpoul, 2016
Peter - 3 - overestiated terpenes and missed alcohol
Rajiv - 4 - missed alcohol
Krystian - 3
2017 Rangeland Sauvignon Blanc
Peter - 3 - missed the orange creamsicle for oaked pyrazines
Rajiv - 3 - missed the orange creamsicle for oaked pyrazines
Krystian - 5 - sauvignon blanc.
Chenin Blanc, 2017 Thacher
Peter - 2 - overestimated alcohol - Roussane blend
Rajiv - 2 - overestimated alcohol - Roussane blend
Krystian - 2 - overestimated alcohol - Sauv Blanc
2015 Tablas Creek, 49% Mourvedre. 14.5%
Peter - 4 - Zin
Rajiv - 3 - I should have had Zin on my laterals.
Krystian - 4 - Zin
2015 Syrah, sinor la vallee ($45).
Peter - 5
Rajiv - 5
Krystian - 5
2017 Thacher Cinsault, ~$40
Peter - 2 - overestimated alcohol by 1.5%
Rajiv - 2 - overestimated alcohol by 1.5%
Krystian - 3 - got the profile, but didn't have a guess
2016 Mistletoe 40% cab, 30% syrah, 20% petite sirah, 10% Merlot.
Peter - 4 - GSM is a good call
Rajiv - 4 - Syrah is probably the closest
Krystian - 4 - GSM is a good call
Cabernet, 2015, $40
Peter - 2 - too low on alcohol and thought he tasted violet and blueberry
Rajiv - 5 - nailed.
Krystian - 4 - syrah
2015 Sinor-LaVallee Chardonnay White Label Bassi Vineyard 87 Points
USA, California, Central Coast, San Luis Obispo County
(blind)
Pale straw color. Dry.
Ripe yellow apples, hint of struck match reduction, hint of freshly-sanded wood - new French oak.
On the palate, dry (maybe 2-3g RS), 14% alcohol (actually 14.2%), medium plus acid, no bitterness. 30% new French oak (actually 5% new!).
Called: Chardonnay, 2016, Paso, good quality - $50
Actual: Chardonnay, 2015, SLO county (sinor la vallee) - $40
I enjoyed the integration here.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2016 Tablas Creek Esprit Blanc de Tablas 88 Points
USA, California, Central Coast, Paso Robles Adelaida District
(blind)
Medium yellow color. Dry.
Relatively neutral nose. Hint of underripe peach pith (terpenes).
Bone dry, 14% alcohol (actually 13%), high viscosity, diminished acid, medium plus phenolic bitterness. Very slight impression of used oak - maybe 10% new.
Based on the neutral aromatics, elevated viscosity, diminished acid, and high bitterness, I think this is:
Called: Marsanne-Roussane blend, 2016, Paso, good quality - $40.
Actual: Roussanne, Grenache Blanc, Picpoul, 2016, $45 (Tablas Creek 2016 Esprit)
Analysis: Stylistically nailed this. I think this is really good quality for the style. Though I wish it had a bit more nuttiness and midpalate weight (maybe age will bring it).
Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
2017 Rangeland Wines Sauvignon Blanc 78 Points
USA, California, Central Coast, Paso Robles
(blind)
Pale yellow color.
Relatively neutral nose, with oily peach notes.
Dry, 14% alcohol (12.9%), screaming high acid, no bitterness. Neutral barrel aging - possible lees stirring.
Based on the screaming acid, this seems not to fit chardonnay or even Roussanne.
Called: 2016 Chenin Blanc, neutral barrels.
Actual: 2017 Rangeland Sauvignon Blanc
$30
Aged for 4 months in 30% once used french oak, 70% Stainless steel.
Analysis: In hindsight, there is a sort of key lime pie, orange creamsicle note (oak plus pyrazines) but it's really subdued.
The acid really sticks out in this, and the overall neutrality of the aromatics doesn't really support the intense structure. It almost seems acidified - the acid sticks out like there was a tartaric addition.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2017 Thacher Winery Chenin Blanc Own-Rooted Shell Creek Vineyards 86 Points
USA, California, Central Coast, Paso Robles
(blind)
Pale straw color. Super mushroomy, savory nose, with slight dirty peach, and significant button mushrooms. On the palate, dry, 14% alcohol (actually 12.5%), elevated acid, medium phenolic bitterness, medium plus almond and slight underripe nectarine finish. Neutral barrels (<10% new).
Based on the overall neutrality, this is a rhone white.
Laterals:
- Marsanne-Roussane blend (e.g. N. Rhone)
- Roussanne-dominant blend
- Grenache-blanc-dominant blend (e.g. S. Rhone)
Final call based on the slightly elevated acid and lesser viscosity:
Called: Roussanne blend with marsanne, 2016, good quality $35.
Actual: Chenin Blanc, 2017 Thacher
Analysis: This is a bit more bitter than I'd expect from a chenin. That said, my alcohol call is way off.
12.5%
3.6 pH
5g TA
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2011 Tablas Creek Esprit de Tablas Flawed
USA, California, Central Coast, Paso Robles
(blind)
Medium minus dull ruby color.
Nose: This is cooked - browned apple core all the way.
FLAW.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2015 Tablas Creek Esprit de Tablas 89 Points
USA, California, Central Coast, Paso Robles Adelaida District
Medium minus ruby color.
Nose: Super ripe red cherry, just a hint of possible reduction (rubber).
3-4g RS, 14.7% alcohol (14.5%), medium acid, medium minus tannins, hint of phenolic bitterness. No overt new oak - maybe neutral barrels.
Given the crazy ripeness and red-fruitedness, combined with the high-alcohol structure, I think this is probably a grenache or grenache-dominant blend.
Laterals:
- Grenache
- GSM
The hesitation here is the slight reduction, which is uncharacteristic of grenache. I'll chalk this up to clean winemaking and youth.
Called: 2016 Grenache, Paso, $30, good quality.
On re-tasting, I should have had Zin on my laterals - the elevated acid, the slight tannic grip, the slight presence of cranberry fruit.
Actual: 2015 Tablas Creek, 49% Mourvedre. 14.5%
Analysis: Zin might have been a better call given the elevated acid and more prominent millerandage than I'd expect on a Grenache. I like this - it's really fresh and aromatic.
Post a Comment / 4 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
2015 Sinor-LaVallee Syrah White Label Bassi Vineyard 86 Points
USA, California, Central Coast, San Luis Obispo County
(blind)
Medium plus ruby color. Slight reduction (plastic), slight earthiness, slight smoked ham.
Dry, feels 14.7% alcohol (allegedly 13.5%), high acid, medium tannins (slightly papery). Strong blackberry and smoked ham finish. Impression of slight new oak - 20% new French (actually 100% used).
Given the aggressive acid, dark color, and smoked meat, my laterals are:
- Syrah
- Zin - wouldn't be this meaty, or dark-fruited, or high in acid.
- GSM blend - would have lower acid.
Called: 2016 Syrah, good quality, $50.
Actual: 2015 Syrah, sinor la vallee ($45).
Analysis: seems about right. Overall the quality is good but it's a bit hot.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2017 Thacher Winery Cinsault Glenrose Vineyard 89 Points
USA, California, Central Coast, Paso Robles Adelaida District
(blind)
Pale rose-colored red. Extremely aromatic nose with white pepper, confected cherry, slight sweet banana. Very appetizing.
On the palate, slight RS (3-4g), 13.8% alcohol (actually 11.5%), elevated acid, medium minus phenolic bitterness, low-plus tannins.
This is a blush wine or extremely light red, reminiscent of the Arnot-roberts Trousseau. It tastes like it was made in a fresh style, with semi-carbonic fermentation, stainless steel (actually 500l neutral oak). The pepper suggests a variety with rotundone, maybe Syrah or Gamay.
Laterals:
- Trousseau
- Valdiguie
- Gamay
- Pinot - would be darker
- Syrah or Zin in a semi-carbonic style.
Called: 2017 Gamay, Paso, $30.
Actual: 2017 Thacher Cinsault, ~$40
Actually 11.5% alcohol!
3.74 pH
5.2g/L
Analysis: This is cool - it's a nice picnic wine, though maybe a bit pricey at $40. I think I mostly nailed the style but totally missed the alcohol.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2016 Rangeland Wines Mistletoe Blend 87 Points
USA, California, Central Coast, Paso Robles
(blind)
Deep purple.
Slight reduction, slight floral terpenes, slight cured meat.
Maybe 2-3g RS, 14.8% alcohol (15% alcohol), elevated acid (possibly acidified), medium tannins, impression of cedar and dried cinnamon on the finish - 50% new French oak.
Given the oak and the elevated acid, and meaty fruit with blackberry midpalate notes, this seems pretty solidly in Syrah territory.
Called: 2015 Syrah, Paso, $40.
Actual: 2016 Mistletoe 40% cab, 30% syrah, 20% petite sirah, 10% Merlot.
Analysis: I'm pretty close here - it's a bizarre mix. $32 - good value! Excellent depth.
Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
2015 Rangeland Wines Cabernet Sauvignon 88 Points
USA, California, Central Coast, Paso Robles Adelaida District
(blind)
Medium plus ruby color.
Pronounced intensity, with explosive ripe red and black cherry.
Maybe 2-3g RS, 15% alcohol (14.9% alcohol), elevated acid, high tannins.
Feels like there's some syrah but it's mostly grenache.
Possibly cab? 100% new French oak.
Based on the color and the structure, and fruit character, I think this is:
Called: Cabernet blend, 2015, $60
Actual: Cabernet, 2015, $40
Pretty good value! Great depth and length.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No