Small Tasting of Nieces' Favorites

Tasted Saturday, June 20, 2020 by I'd Rather Be Drinking Wine with 122 views

Introduction

This was a small tasting with my nieces of their favorite wines, joined by the rest of their family members. The group was 6 people and the wines featured were the favorites of my nieces (except for the Carter, which threw in for something different, but I knew would be in their wheelhouse). As expected, no agreement on WOTN, and in fact, each wine got at least one vote for WOTN. One person in the group did not vote, and I did not tally votes for top 3. If I had to pick a group's WOTN, it would be the 2011 Cobos, because it received 2 votes for number 1, while the others received 1 vote each. Was a very good tasting featuring some exceptional wines! Of course, a real treat sharing wine with my nieces!

Flight 1 - Nieces' Favorites! (3 Notes)

  • 2012 Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon Special Selection 95 Points

    USA, California, Napa Valley

    A wine tasting at my nieces house to compare their favorite wines. The line-up was as follows:

    - 2011 Viña Cobos Malbec Cobos Marchiori Vineyard Block C2
    - 2012 Caymus Special Selection
    - 2016 Carter Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon Fortuna Vineyard
    - 2016 Quintessa

    This The wines were prepared as follows:

    2011 Cobos - PnP
    2012 Caymus SS - PnP
    2016 Carter - Half the bottle was gone from using a Corvin twice earlier (going back 2 weeks) and PnP today
    2016 Quintessa - Uncorked the bottle and slo-O'd for 6 hours - reinserted cork for transportation and poured when arrived.

    All wines poured at once and drank over the course of 2 hours.

    A great line-up! Not surprisingly, everyone had their favorites, and each of the wines in the line-up was someone's WOTN. I did not tally points, so I cannot say which wine was the group's number 1. For me, my WOTN was the 2011 Cobos, followed by the 2012 Caymus SS, then the Carter and 4th was the Quintessa. For me, only one point separated the WOTN from the Quintessa, and I also believe with more time, any of these wines could be number 1. Based on this tasting, I will also say I believe the Quintessa has the most upside.

    - 2012 Caymus Special Selection: What can I say....Caymus Rocks! I know this is a polarizing wine and for those who have never had it, know it is heavily extracted with gobs of fruit and chocolate and oak, especially in its youth. At eight years of age, it has mellowed a little, but still distinctly Caymus SS. The nose is sweet and perfumed, and the palate is loaded with rich fruit, chocolate and integrated oak. It is also starting to develop some tertiary nuances with a little dust, cigar and leather, that are velvety smooth. This wine is always a pleasure and a treat for me to drink. It still has a long life, and of all the wines in the line-up, this was the smoothest wine in the group. Always a crowd pleaser and very consumer friendly. A solid 95 today, and my number 2 wine of the group.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2016 Carter Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon Fortuna Vineyard 94 Points

    USA, California, Napa Valley, Oakville

    A wine tasting at my nieces house to compare their favorite wines. The line-up was as follows:

    - 2011 Viña Cobos Malbec Cobos Marchiori Vineyard Block C2
    - 2012 Caymus Special Selection
    - 2016 Carter Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon Fortuna Vineyard
    - 2016 Quintessa

    This The wines were prepared as follows:

    2011 Cobos - PnP
    2012 Caymus SS - PnP
    2016 Carter - Half the bottle was gone from using a Corvin twice earlier (going back 2 weeks) and PnP today
    2016 Quintessa - Uncorked the bottle and slo-O'd for 6 hours - reinserted cork for transportation and poured when arrived.

    All wines poured at once and drank over the course of 2 hours.

    A great line-up! Not surprisingly, everyone had their favorites, and each of the wines in the line-up was someone's WOTN. I did not tally points, so I cannot say which wine was the group's number 1. For me, my WOTN was the 2011 Cobos, followed by the 2012 Caymus SS, then the Carter and 4th was the Quintessa. For me, only one point separated the WOTN from the Quintessa, and I also believe with more time, any of these wines could be number 1. Based on this tasting, I will also say I believe the Quintessa has the most upside.

    - 2016 Carter Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon Fortuna Vineyard: This wine keeps getting better! I think additional aging will be rewarded. The wine is fruit forward with virtually no heat. The nose is perfumed with violets and dark fruit dominating. The palate is rick with plum, cassis and some dark cherry, with some integrated chocolate and flashes of leather and forest floor. The finish is still a little short, but overall, this is an appealing wine that sings for me. It held its own in an excellent line-up and I look forward to trying some of Carter's other wines. 94+ points tonight and my number 3 wine of the group.

    Post a Comment / 3 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • 2016 Quintessa 94 Points

    USA, California, Napa Valley, Rutherford

    A wine tasting at my nieces house to compare their favorite wines. The line-up was as follows:

    - 2011 Viña Cobos Malbec Cobos Marchiori Vineyard Block C2
    - 2012 Caymus Special Selection
    - 2016 Carter Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon Fortuna Vineyard
    - 2016 Quintessa

    This The wines were prepared as follows:

    2011 Cobos - PnP
    2012 Caymus SS - PnP
    2016 Carter - Half the bottle was gone from using a Corvin twice earlier (going back 2 weeks) and PnP today
    2016 Quintessa - Uncorked the bottle and slo-O'd for 6 hours - reinserted cork for transportation and poured when arrived.

    All wines poured at once and drank over the course of 2 hours.

    A great line-up! Not surprisingly, everyone had their favorites, and each of the wines in the line-up was someone's WOTN. I did not tally points, so I cannot say which wine was the group's number 1. For me, my WOTN was the 2011 Cobos, followed by the 2012 Caymus SS, then the Carter and 4th was the Quintessa. For me, only one point separated the WOTN from the Quintessa, and I also believe with more time, any of these wines could be number 1. Based on this tasting, I will also say I believe the Quintessa has the most upside.

    - 2016 Quintessa: This was my 2nd favorite wine at a James Suckling tasting in Miami last year, so expectations were high! I was a little disappointed in today's showing, but it was/is still an excellent wine! Way too young though, and should have been decanted rather than slo-O'd (maybe even aerated too). This wine will not be peaking for quite sometime, IMO. Having said that, it was drinking pretty well today. Nose was floral, but somewhat restrained. Palate showed a nice balance of red and black fruit, some earthiness and some spice, coupled with oak and a hint of vanilla. A nicely blended wine that, while drinking well now, also shows a lot of potential. I feel this wine definately has the biggest upside of all the wines tasted today. A solid 94-94+, with a chance to add 2-3 points easily. Will likely not open another bottle for a couple years (would wait even longer if I didn't have a case).

    Post a Comment / 3 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

Closing

A great lineup with my adorable nieces! A great time was had by all!

×
×