Singapore
Tasted Sunday, August 30, 2020 by Collector1855 with 271 views
Wine & Co Consultancy, a local wine school that does WSET courses, called upon some of its alums to join them in tasting wines from the Chinese "leaderboard" to see how the quality has progressed. I had the odd bottle of China made red wine here and was always underwhelmed. So, a good opportunity to taste them blind in a structured format.
I'd summarize the situation as follows:
- On the top end the wines have moved a little bit in quality but are still far below from what I think any connoisseur is likely to buy. As a matter of fact, no one in the room really liked any of the bottles.
- Don't get me wrong, the wines are correctly made, resembling 10$ supermarket bottles, simple but correct (think Jellow Tail / Jacob's Creek). Tannins are polished but the wines are very, very oaky and feel sweet on the palate, I even thought there was some RS in them. We heard from a HK sales rep of Chinese wines that this oaky/sweet style is deliberate as the local taste is looking for this... Outch!
- To be fair, since growing wine in a new place is a game of study, trial and error, study some more, try some more, improvements will slowly but surely happen. Also one needs to consider that even in the best Vineyards there are no old vines yet, another ingredient necessary for high quality.
- Finally, to most buyer's dismay, the top names are already 200$, which is of course far too much for what's in the bottle. So if you are buying these wines, the rationale should therefore not be gastronomic, but either speculative (if you are into that) or to surprise your guests with a blind sample from the "Newest World".
2016 陸壹酒庄Domaine du1er Juin Pinot Noir 79 Points
China, Ningxia
A No-oak Pinot Noir from Ningxia. Oh boy, we are off to a rocky start here. Brownish color, is this Pinot? Green nose with asparagus, green apples and some red fruit. In the mouth it feels like 50% wine and 50% apple cyder with a touch of residual sugar. Tannins are soft. Don't know what to make of this. My scale starts at 80, so let me give 79 here…
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2015 Silver Heights Family Reserve 87 Points
China, Ningxia
60/40 Cab/Merlot. Garnet color with brown hue. Typical nose of CabSav from Chile with generous oak. On the palate not unpleasant but very fore-square commercial. Almost feels off-dry, a theme that we saw in many wines tonight. Apparently that is on purpose to suit the local taste who does not like the wines to be too austere. Also oak is associated with quality, hence the generous application of it. Decent wine but nothing to write home about. 87+
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2017 Grace Vineyard Marselan Tasya's Reserve 87 Points
China, Shanxi
This is from the Marselan grape (a cross of CabSav and Grenache). China is using this grape quite frequently. Dark purple. Nose of cherry bonbon, very much in the Languedoc style, Alc 14.5%. Fruity, sweetish, with vanilla, little oak here, has some depth. A wine to drink young.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2015 Tiansai Vineyards Marselan Skyline Of Gobi 88 Points
China, Xinjiang
Another Marsellan (CabSav/Grenache crossing) that China is successfully experimenting with. Garnet with amber hue. Feels like a GSM styled wine from South Australia or South of France. 14.8% alc. What works well here is there is a smoky oaky side that makes the with feel modern but also quite premium. If you are used to GSM this will work for you.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2015 Ao Yun 86 Points
China, Yunnan
Garnet color. A famous and expensive wine now, one of the Premium stars of China made by LVMH. I found this wine also a bit strange. On the one hand you have a rich sweetish mouth feel with alcohol, oak and soft tannins but then there is an asparagus greenness bell pepper side in the aromas. Both are not really married together (yet?). At 200$ a bottle it really isn't a QPR star to say the least...
Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
2017 Long Dai Qiu Shan Valley 86 Points
China, Shandong, Yantai
So here it is, the first vintage of the Lafite Rothschild project in China. A CabSav/Marsellan/CabFranc blend. The wine is very rich and modern, with lots of vanilla and oak, polished tannins but really ripe oaky like a 20$ Chile CabSav. The release price will be similar to Ao Yun at ca 200$, which makes commercial sence as local demand can easily mop this up. I don't see this making it into my cellar though.
Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
2015 陸壹酒庄Domaine du1er Juin Cabernet Sauvignon 84 Points
China, Ningxia
Brownish color. Lot of oak here in the nose with some dark fruit. On the palate with is alcoholic with dry tannins on the finish. Not really in balance. Avoid.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No