Escherndorf - Efringen-Kirchen - Arbois - Cramant/Bouzy/Verzenay
Tasted Wednesday, September 9, 2020 - Wednesday, September 16, 2020 by honest bob with 254 views
Despite strict COVID-19-related hygiene precautions this was an enjoyable journey. We were made very welcome everywhere we went.
Walk-in without appointment; despite COVID-19, the tasting room was busy. Friendly, very competent and well-informed salesperson. These Silvaners are exceptional, my ratings may be too conservative, particularly for the "1655" and Sehnsucht.
Walk-in without appointment; despite COVID-19, the idyllic courtyard of Ziereisen's Weingut was humming with customers. Despite that, a warm, open-hearted welcome. I become even more cautious than usual when I'm enjoying myself this much, so my ratings may be up to a couple of points too sober.
The actual winemaking facility in an idyllic village near Arbois doesn't receive visitors, so we walked in to their tasting room in town. The reception was warmer than on my previous two visits, and such wines as were available were excellent. How good must it feel be to be the Wild Child, the Avant Garde winemaker who has managed to shake up such a traditional place as Arbois so successfully that you can charge twice as much as the competition and still sell out many of the wines on your list almost as soon as it's printed? I don't know, but Stéphane Tissot certainly does...
Our third visit to Dieblot Vallois. Appointment made two weeks in advance. Not much has changed except they now have a fancy new office at the front of the (unaltered, spotless, functional) cellar. As ever, gorgeous wines from Cramant and the neighbouring villages.
Appointment made two weeks in advance. Friendly but, we suspected, not very experienced salesperson. We didn't understand why they declared the 2014, and the off the cuff remark from the salesperson that it was best drunk within a couple of years seemed to confirm our impression that this wine wasn't a success. Otherwise everything was as delicious as expected from Bara and Bouzy; we'd have loved to taste the prestige bottlings, but as that wasn't on offer, we bought them on blind trust (and reading other people's TNs). Cellar door price for the Special Club 2012 50€; Comtesse Marie de France 2008 60€.
Appointment made one week in advance. Monsieur and Madame Lallement sat with us for almost an hour and opened fresh bottles of three excellent wines. They are delighted with the quality of the 2018, 2019 and 2020 harvests, so I fully intend to return to purchase more of their outstanding (and outstandingly reasonably priced) wines in the future. In the meantime I was to secure the last six bottles of the 2012 vintage they had for sale; the Grand Cru Cuvée Réserve was my Coup de Coeur of this trip.
The real downer on this trip wasn't being fastidious about hygiene and mask-wearing, but the disappointing quality of food in some previously excellent restaurants. Almost all our meals evidently suffered from having been prepared under severe COVID-19 stress. Even Selosse's Les Avisés had a couple of things on the menu (e.g. tough, sinewy iberico slices) which weren't up to scratch. We had been looking forward particularly to returning to two restaurants in Arbois, but both were a disappointment. Les Caudalies offered very bland food accompanied by a truly mediocre wine flight put together by "France's best Sommelier" (caveat emptor, his wine list is indeed excellent and not overpriced, so choose yourself). Our too-long evening in Maison Jeunet**, where they took nearly 4 hours 30 minutes to serve us their smaller set menu, started off well with a glass of delicious local Crémant, but the food started going downhill from the fish course on.
This was the trip when I finally learned that the first and most important thing to say to any sommelier is: "Please don't bring me any so-called 'natural' wines. If you do, I will send them back." If they try to remonstrate, then it's appropriate to follow up with: "I don't care how good you think your discoveries are, or how ignorant you think I am, I happen to be the person who is paying for this." It is of course more difficult when you are in a Michelin** restaurant (Maison Jeunet in Arbois, see above) which offers NO red wines by the glass except two "natural" concoctions, a Poulsard, which was "having a bad day" and therefore could not be presented to customers, and a Pinot Noir from the same producer, which was undrinkable unless you like wine vinegar mixed with urine. I have named and shamed the restaurant here, but not the wine in question, because I sent it back and didn't pay for it. The alternative suggestion was a Savignin L'Etoile... to accompany rare pigeon served with a dark, umami-laden sauce. Not a great performance by the somm, who also first served our bottle of Macle CdJ at hot room temperature (I guessed around 26C), gave me a withering glance when I asked for it to be slightly cooled, and then punished us by plungung it into an out-of-reach-ice bucket, only returning once it was almost frozen. That evening was the first time I can remember that I was happy to leave absolutely no tip at all.
2019 Horst Sauer Escherndorfer Lump Silvaner trocken 89 Points
Germany, Franken
(9/9/2020)
From 75cl Bocksbeutel at Horst Sauer tasting room, opened previous day. Fresh, slender scent, hint of struck match; ripe green apple entry; beautifully clean mid-palate; long finish. A snip for 9€ at cellar door. Now-2024 88-89P
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2019 Horst Sauer Escherndorfer Lump Silvaner S trocken 91 Points
Germany, Franken
(9/9/2020)
From 75cl Bocksbeutel at Horst Sauer tasting room, opened previous day. Still a bit closed on the nose, just a hint of smoke, but the entry is tightly-woven, with a hint of salt and intensive crystalline sweetness; structured, layered midpalate just delicious; some ripe green apple action on the finish. Excellent value for 13,50€ at cellar door. Now-2028. 90-91P
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2019 Horst Sauer Escherndorf Am Lumpen 1655 Silvaner Großes Gewächs 92 Points
Germany, Franken
(9/9/2020)
From 75cl traditional Riesling-style bottle at Horst Sauer tasting room, opened previous day. Huge wine. SO2/struck match on the nose; the entry is currently at once fat, sharp, deliciously sour; bitter astringent green apple peel and exciting, jagged acidic/mineral structure on the mid-palate; dry astringent finish. This needs 5-10 years, but should turn out to be superb. Fairly priced for 27€ at cellar door. 91-92(?)P
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2019 Horst Sauer Silvaner Sehnsucht 91 Points
Germany, Franken
(9/9/2020)
From 75cl traditional Burgundy-style bottle at Horst Sauer tasting room, opened previous day. Raised in barriques, this very serious wine is quite unlike any other Silvaner I have tasted and would be a cunning “pirate” to slip into a blind tasting of lighter, 1. Cru Chablis-style Chardonnay. Fresh oak scent; sparklingly fresh, gently sweet entry; ripe acidity already well integrated on the midpalate, some fine red apple fruit; long finish. This is delicious already, but will surely develop and improve over the next decade. Interestingly, this is the only Silvaner Horst Sauer offers in magnum, double magnum and jeroboam! Fairly priced for 20€ at cellar door. 90-91P(?) (6 views)
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No