Sauer - Ziereisen - Jura - Champagne

Escherndorf - Efringen-Kirchen - Arbois - Cramant/Bouzy/Verzenay
Tasted Wednesday, September 9, 2020 - Wednesday, September 16, 2020 by honest bob with 254 views

Introduction

Despite strict COVID-19-related hygiene precautions this was an enjoyable journey. We were made very welcome everywhere we went.

Flight 1 - Horst Sauer, Eschendorf (4 Notes)

Walk-in without appointment; despite COVID-19, the tasting room was busy. Friendly, very competent and well-informed salesperson. These Silvaners are exceptional, my ratings may be too conservative, particularly for the "1655" and Sehnsucht.

  • 2019 Horst Sauer Escherndorfer Lump Silvaner trocken 89 Points

    Germany, Franken

    (9/9/2020)

    From 75cl Bocksbeutel at Horst Sauer tasting room, opened previous day. Fresh, slender scent, hint of struck match; ripe green apple entry; beautifully clean mid-palate; long finish. A snip for 9€ at cellar door. Now-2024 88-89P

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2019 Horst Sauer Escherndorfer Lump Silvaner S trocken 91 Points

    Germany, Franken

    (9/9/2020)

    From 75cl Bocksbeutel at Horst Sauer tasting room, opened previous day. Still a bit closed on the nose, just a hint of smoke, but the entry is tightly-woven, with a hint of salt and intensive crystalline sweetness; structured, layered midpalate just delicious; some ripe green apple action on the finish. Excellent value for 13,50€ at cellar door. Now-2028. 90-91P

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2019 Horst Sauer Escherndorf Am Lumpen 1655 Silvaner Großes Gewächs 92 Points

    Germany, Franken

    (9/9/2020)

    From 75cl traditional Riesling-style bottle at Horst Sauer tasting room, opened previous day. Huge wine. SO2/struck match on the nose; the entry is currently at once fat, sharp, deliciously sour; bitter astringent green apple peel and exciting, jagged acidic/mineral structure on the mid-palate; dry astringent finish. This needs 5-10 years, but should turn out to be superb. Fairly priced for 27€ at cellar door. 91-92(?)P

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2019 Horst Sauer Silvaner Sehnsucht 91 Points

    Germany, Franken

    (9/9/2020)

    From 75cl traditional Burgundy-style bottle at Horst Sauer tasting room, opened previous day. Raised in barriques, this very serious wine is quite unlike any other Silvaner I have tasted and would be a cunning “pirate” to slip into a blind tasting of lighter, 1. Cru Chablis-style Chardonnay. Fresh oak scent; sparklingly fresh, gently sweet entry; ripe acidity already well integrated on the midpalate, some fine red apple fruit; long finish. This is delicious already, but will surely develop and improve over the next decade. Interestingly, this is the only Silvaner Horst Sauer offers in magnum, double magnum and jeroboam! Fairly priced for 20€ at cellar door. 90-91P(?) (6 views)

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 2 - Weingut Ziereisen, Efringen-Kirchen (8 Notes)

Walk-in without appointment; despite COVID-19, the idyllic courtyard of Ziereisen's Weingut was humming with customers. Despite that, a warm, open-hearted welcome. I become even more cautious than usual when I'm enjoying myself this much, so my ratings may be up to a couple of points too sober.

  • 2018 Ziereisen Gutedel Heugumber 88 Points

    Germany, Baden

    (9/10/2020)

    From 75cl opened approx. 2 hours at Weingut Ziereisen. Grapefruit, attractively bitter; slightly dusty, hay-bale-like, autumnal character. Lovely wine at a bargain price, but already sold out (like every other Gutedel!) at cellar door. 88?

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2017 Ziereisen Tschuppen Blauer Spätburgunder 88 Points

    Germany, Baden

    (9/10/2020)

    From 75cl, opened approx. 2 hours at Weingut Ziereisen. Bright crimson/ruby colour. Morello cherry scent; light-bodied, mouthwatering bright red cherry-fruited entry; dusty-grippy tannic gain on the mid-palate; astringent finish. 13% alc. Stunning value at 12€ cellar door. 88-89P

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2017 Ziereisen Talrain 88 Points

    Germany, Baden

    (9/10/2020)

    From 75cl, opened approx. 2 hours at Weingut Ziereisen. Much darker red than the Tschuppen, with brown reflexes. Aromatically closed down tight. Medium-bodied entry, with again darker, but not black, cherry fruit; mouth-watering mid-palate acidity; finish shows firm tannins. 13% alc. Needs time, try perhaps from 2021/22? 87-88P(?)

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2016 Ziereisen Talrain 89 Points

    Germany, Baden

    (9/10/2020)

    From 75cl, opened approx. 2 hours at Weingut Ziereisen. Much more friendly and open than the 2017 Talrain tasted directly before.
    Bright purple colour. Attractive herbal scent, hints of menthol and cedar; entry with bright red fruit, not redcurrant, not cherry, can't put my finger on it, but it tastes good. Round, decent fine-grained tannins add structure on the otherwise linear mid-palate; quite long and vibrant finish. 12% alc. Delightful now and at least until 2023. Fine value for 17,80€ at cellar door. 89P

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2017 Ziereisen Schulen 90 Points

    Germany, Baden

    (9/10/2020)

    From 75cl, opened approx. 2 hours at Weingut Ziereisen. Dark red-purple reflexes. Broad pinot scent, cornucopia of red fruits; super-ripe redcurrant on entry; ripe mid-palate, velvety tannins, long and satisfying; pleasant bitter, aromatic-provencal-green-herbal finish. 13% alc. This is gorgeous, and fairly priced at 22€ cellar door. This 2017 seemed more balanced than I remember the 2016 Schulen being a couple of weeks ago. 89-90P

    Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • 2017 Ziereisen Rhini 90 Points

    Germany, Baden

    (9/10/2020)

    From 75cl, opened approx. 2 hours at Weingut Ziereisen. Dark purple-red colour. Some menthol-herbal action on the otherwise closed-down nose. Weighty, very astringent entry; fine but massive tannins on the mid-palate, fighting it out with substantial dark fruit. This feels bone dry and less friendly than the 2017 Schulen, but probably just needs 2-4 years to come into balance. 13% alc. 33€ at cellar door. 2023-2030? 90-91P(?)

    Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • 2017 Ziereisen Pinot Noir Jaspis 92 Points

    Germany, Baden

    (9/10/2020)

    From 75cl, opened approx. 2 hours at Weingut Ziereisen. Luminous purple colour. The scent is balsamic, exotic, with asian spice, like a luscious Vosne-Romanée; entry wide-open with delicious, rich, concentrated dark berry fruit. Deep, juicy cherry/loganberry(?) mid-palate fruit; long finish with dusty tannins. 13,5% alc. Worth every penny of the 45€ cellar door price. 92P(+?)

    Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • 2014 Ziereisen Pinot Noir Jaspis 88 Points

    Germany, Baden

    (9/10/2020)

    From 75cl, opened approx. 2 hours at Weingut Ziereisen. Dark muddy red colour. Vegetal aromas. Fresh, light, acidic, redcurrant entry; challenging acidic/gritty mid-palate with pure fruit but quite rough tannins. This was a surprise after the luscious 2017 Jaspis PN tasted directly before, a bit like following a 2009 1er Cru Morey or Gevery with its 2004 sister. Perhaps it'll come round in 4-5 further years, but I'm not holding my breath. 88P(?)

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 3 - Bénédicte et Stéphane Tissot, Arbois (4 Notes)

The actual winemaking facility in an idyllic village near Arbois doesn't receive visitors, so we walked in to their tasting room in town. The reception was warmer than on my previous two visits, and such wines as were available were excellent. How good must it feel be to be the Wild Child, the Avant Garde winemaker who has managed to shake up such a traditional place as Arbois so successfully that you can charge twice as much as the competition and still sell out many of the wines on your list almost as soon as it's printed? I don't know, but Stéphane Tissot certainly does...

  • 2018 Tissot (Bénédicte et Stéphane / André et Mireille) Chardonnay Arbois Patchwork 88 Points

    France, Jura, Arbois

    (9/14/2020)

    From an open 75cl bottle at B&S Tissot tasting room, Arbois. Gorgeous lemon scent, that sexy hint of struck match and... oops, something less attractive, not exactly "natural wine"-vinegar-burpy-yeasty-refermented-nasty, but too close for (my) comfort. Entry thinner than expected after seeing this has 14% alc; the mid-palate is lemony, slender, stream-lined and squeaky clean. Probably better after a couple of years sideways? 88-89P

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2016 Tissot (Bénédicte et Stéphane / André et Mireille) Savagnin Arbois 90 Points

    France, Jura, Arbois

    (9/14/2020)

    From an open 75cl bottle at B&S Tissot tasting room, Arbois. Basically a Vin Jaune "light", bottled after only 32 months sous voile. Light-bodied, super clean, lithe entry without any hint of cellar funk or Jura fustiness. Bright, penetrating lemon juice, long, long long... Beautiful wine, lip-smacking right now, but surely good for at least a decade in the cellar. 90-91P

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2013 Tissot (Bénédicte et Stéphane / André et Mireille) Arbois Vin Jaune Les Bruyères 90 Points

    France, Jura, Arbois

    (9/14/2020)

    From an open 62cl bottle at B&S Tissot tasting room, Arbois. Les Bruyères is normally the richest of Tissot's VJ range, but in 2013 it was the only one produced, and pretty skinny it is. Think Chateau Chalon rather than Arbois, and a thin one at that. However untypical it might be, it is superbly made, clean as a whistle, with bright lemon fruit and great length. 90P(?)

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2011 Tissot (Bénédicte et Stéphane / André et Mireille) Arbois Vin Jaune 99 mois d'elévage 92 Points

    France, Jura, Arbois

    (9/14/2020)

    From an open 62cl bottle at B&S Tissot tasting room, Arbois. After 8 years 3 months(!) sous voile this VJ is weighty, complex, tightly-wound, but retains the typical clean, fresh B&S Tissot style, i.e.no mustiness or false notes. It is as delicious, savoury, brightly acidic, persistently mouthwatering as expected, but perhaps less exuberent, more serious, even weighty. Time in bottle will tell; I'll aim to open my first one in roughly 2023-24. 91-93P(+?)

    CT members have recorded the following 2011 VJs, which S. Tissot chose to age for the more conventional 6 years 3 months: En Spois, La Mailloche, La Vasée, Les Bruyères, a generic "Vin Jaune", a Chateau Chalon and a VJ aged in whisky barrels. Not having had the chance to taste these seven(!) other bottlings from this vintage, I can alas only assess this eighth bottling(!!) in the context of my memories of previous vintages. Hopefully someone will eventually publish a comparative tasting.

    Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

Flight 4 - Champagne Diebolt Vallois, Cramant (4 Notes)

Our third visit to Dieblot Vallois. Appointment made two weeks in advance. Not much has changed except they now have a fancy new office at the front of the (unaltered, spotless, functional) cellar. As ever, gorgeous wines from Cramant and the neighbouring villages.

  • NV Diebolt-Vallois Champagne Blanc de Blancs Brut 88 Points

    France, Champagne

    (9/15/2020)

    From 75cl at Diebolt-Vallois cellar, bottle opened previous day. Blend of 2014/15/16 wines, 5g dosage. Brioche and yeast on the nose; slender green-apple-tinged entry with sharp pin-prick bubbles; super-clean mid-palate, not very long. Fine value for 22€ at cellar door. 88P

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • NV Diebolt-Vallois Champagne Cuvée Prestige Blanc de Blancs 90 Points

    France, Champagne

    (9/15/2020)

    From 75cl at Diebolt-Vallois cellar, bottle opened previous day. 85% 2017 base wine / 15% reserve wine from a foudre started in 2009 and topped up subsequently, 5g dosage; forgot to ask the disgorgement date, no details on label. A big step up from the Blanc de Blancs, this has much finer bubbles and seems to have less CO2 pressure, perhaps making it the more “gastronomic” wine. The entry is more golden/yellow-fruited, rounder, richer, deeper; the finish is long and persistent. Promising now, probably much better in 5-10 years. V. good value for 30€ at cellar door. 90-91P

    Post a Comment / 2 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • 2012 Diebolt-Vallois Champagne Blanc de Blancs Brut Millésimé 92 Points

    France, Champagne

    (9/15/2020)

    From 75cl at Diebolt-Vallois cellar, bottle opened previous day. Bottled 2013, 7 years sur lie, therefore disgorged in 2020, but no visible date on label, 4g dosage. An absolute baby, just giving hints of brioche, yellow fruit and an intense, concentrated palate, the minerality still tightly coiled. The bubbles are currently somewhere between the Blanc de Blancs and the Prestige cuvées, i.e. not too coarse, not too fine, so I could imagine enjoying this on its own or with food. It would be a shame, however, to drink it before 2024. Great wine; excellent value for 35€ at cellar door. 92P(?)

    Post a Comment / 3 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • 2010 Diebolt-Vallois Champagne Fleur de Passion Brut 92 Points

    France, Champagne

    (9/15/2020)

    From 75cl at Diebolt-Vallois cellar, bottle opened previous day. 100% Cramant, fermented in barriques, but unlike all the other DV cuvées without undergoing malolactic fermentation. Bottled spring 2011, "8 years" sur lie, so disgorged 2019, or perhaps early 2020 (no date on bottle), 3g dosage. A brilliant achievement for what everyone in Champagne admits was generally a mediocre year. This is already super-delicious, with complex ripe white fruit (even a hint of lychee), tiny, gently caressing bubbles. A class act, perhaps not for the really long term, but all the more enjoyable now-2025(+?) Pricey at 70€ cellar door*. 92P

    *If you can’t afford FdP, seek consolation with a bottle of DV’s 2012 vintage BdB for half the price. It should provide a similar amount of pleasure short-term, probably even more if you can wait until the late 2020s.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 5 - Champagne Paul Bara, Bouzy (4 Notes)

Appointment made two weeks in advance. Friendly but, we suspected, not very experienced salesperson. We didn't understand why they declared the 2014, and the off the cuff remark from the salesperson that it was best drunk within a couple of years seemed to confirm our impression that this wine wasn't a success. Otherwise everything was as delicious as expected from Bara and Bouzy; we'd have loved to taste the prestige bottlings, but as that wasn't on offer, we bought them on blind trust (and reading other people's TNs). Cellar door price for the Special Club 2012 50€; Comtesse Marie de France 2008 60€.

  • NV Paul Bara Champagne Grand Cru Extra Brut 91 Points

    France, Champagne, Champagne Grand Cru

    (9/15/2020)

    From 75cl at Paul Bara tasting room, bottle opened previous day. Old vines (50 years) 80/20% PN/Chard; 50/50% base wine from 2012/reserve; dosage 3g, 7 years sur lie, disgorged May 2020. Poured at fridge temperature. Generous first whiff of scent, then closed up until it warmed to about 14C. Soft red fruits (raspberry?) on entry, expansive mid-palate, long finish. Very fine bubbles. Excellent value for 29€ at cellar door. 91(+)P

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • NV Paul Bara Champagne Grand Cru Brut Réserve 90 Points

    France, Champagne, Champagne Grand Cru

    (9/15/2020)

    From 75cl at Paul Bara tasting room, bottle opened previous day. Younger vines than the Extra Brut: 80/20% PN/Chard; 50/50% base wine from 2013/reserve; dosage 7g, 4 years sur lie, disgorged Jul 2019. Astonishingly, this doesn’t taste sweeter than the Extra Brut, perhaps as a result of the different base wine (2013 instead of 2012), the younger-vine fruit, or the year since disgorgement. Full-bodied, delicious, perhaps a bit sullen, lacking “nerve” and “poise”? Fine value for 25€ cellar door. (89-)90P

    Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • NV Paul Bara Champagne Grand Cru Grand Rosé 90 Points

    France, Champagne, Champagne Grand Cru

    (9/15/2020)

    From 75cl at Paul Bara tasting room, bottle opened previous day. 80/20% PN/Chardonnay (12% of the blend is Bouzy Rouge); 50/50% base wine from 2014/reserve; dosage 7g, disgorged February 2020. Aromatically closed (this would surely have developed with time in a decent-sized glass and as it warmed up from fridge temperature). Generous red fruit; well-judged dosage just a little on the sweet side for my palate (would be great with spicy food); I'd prefer this to the Deutz NV Rosé tasted on 11.08.2020, for example. Fine value for 27€ at cellar door. 89-90P

    Post a Comment / 2 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • 2014 Paul Bara Champagne Grand Cru Brut Millésimé 85 Points

    France, Champagne, Champagne Grand Cru

    (9/15/2020)

    From 75cl at Paul Bara tasting room, bottle opened previous day. 90/10% PN/Chard; dosage 8g. Disgorgement not noted. Pervasive emollient-sugary quality from nose to tail; monolithic, inexpressive entry; sullen mid-palate without the suppleness or acid/fruit dance one might hope for; bitter, pith-like finish. We were advised that this should be drunk “within a couple of years”, whereas the Extra Brut/Brut/Rosé cuvées are good for a decade in the cellar. On that basis it seems hard to hope for an upside; a disappointment especially given the exemplary quality of the other wines tasted at Paul Bara today. 40€ at cellar door. 85-86P?

    Post a Comment / 2 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

Flight 6 - Champagne Jean Lallement, Verzenay (3 Notes)

Appointment made one week in advance. Monsieur and Madame Lallement sat with us for almost an hour and opened fresh bottles of three excellent wines. They are delighted with the quality of the 2018, 2019 and 2020 harvests, so I fully intend to return to purchase more of their outstanding (and outstandingly reasonably priced) wines in the future. In the meantime I was to secure the last six bottles of the 2012 vintage they had for sale; the Grand Cru Cuvée Réserve was my Coup de Coeur of this trip.

  • NV Jean Lallement Champagne Grand Cru Brut 89 Points

    France, Champagne, Champagne Grand Cru

    (9/16/2020)

    From 75cl P+P at Jean Lallement, Verzenay. This is the green-label bottling Lallement refers to on his cellar door price list as "Tradition", although that designation doesn' t appear on the label. 80/20% PN/Chardonnay; thereof 80/20% 2013 and 2014 wines, 6g dosage. Disgorged February 2020 (no disgorgement information on the label). Bright lemon scent; bone dry entry with fine, pin-prick bubbles, lacks the intense mid-palate fruit complexity of the Réserve and its resonant finish, so if you love superb Cava this might appeal strongly. Excellent value for 18€ at cellar door. 89-90P

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • NV Jean Lallement Champagne Grand Cru Cuvée Réserve 91 Points

    France, Champagne, Champagne Grand Cru

    (9/16/2020)

    From 75cl P+P at Jean Lallement, Verzenay. 80/20% PN/Chardonnay from old vines (over 35 years), 4g dosage. Disgorged February 2020 (no disgorgement information on the label). Gorgeous complex scent led by yellow/green plum, some hints of wild plum, even sloe; bright, dry entry (white pepper?); mid-palate developed from greengage fruit to something intense, deep (flashes of beef consommé as the wine warmed up); persistent, mouthwatering finish. Very fine wine indeed, with excellent potential; superb value for 20,50€ at cellar door. 91-92P

    Post a Comment / 2 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • NV Jean Lallement Champagne Grand Cru Réserve Rosée 90 Points

    France, Champagne, Champagne Grand Cru

    (9/16/2020)

    From 75cl P+P at Jean Lallement, Verzenay. 100% PN from old vines (over 35 years) 8% of which is red wine, 4g dosage. Disgorged February 2020 (no disgorgement information on the label). Very pale pink, excellent red-fruit scent (lighter than the Réserve but more direct than the Tradition cuvée); bone dry entry in perfectly poised balance with soft, generous fruit. Super-clean finish probably just needed more time in a bigger glass to be truly satisfying. Serious rosé with excellent potential, a world away from the dilute, sugary St. Valentine’s Day Massacres offered by some Grandes Marques. Superb value for 22,50€ at cellar door. 90-91P

    Read 1 Comment / Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

Flight 7 - Various restaurant meals (6 Notes)

The real downer on this trip wasn't being fastidious about hygiene and mask-wearing, but the disappointing quality of food in some previously excellent restaurants. Almost all our meals evidently suffered from having been prepared under severe COVID-19 stress. Even Selosse's Les Avisés had a couple of things on the menu (e.g. tough, sinewy iberico slices) which weren't up to scratch. We had been looking forward particularly to returning to two restaurants in Arbois, but both were a disappointment. Les Caudalies offered very bland food accompanied by a truly mediocre wine flight put together by "France's best Sommelier" (caveat emptor, his wine list is indeed excellent and not overpriced, so choose yourself). Our too-long evening in Maison Jeunet**, where they took nearly 4 hours 30 minutes to serve us their smaller set menu, started off well with a glass of delicious local Crémant, but the food started going downhill from the fish course on.

This was the trip when I finally learned that the first and most important thing to say to any sommelier is: "Please don't bring me any so-called 'natural' wines. If you do, I will send them back." If they try to remonstrate, then it's appropriate to follow up with: "I don't care how good you think your discoveries are, or how ignorant you think I am, I happen to be the person who is paying for this." It is of course more difficult when you are in a Michelin** restaurant (Maison Jeunet in Arbois, see above) which offers NO red wines by the glass except two "natural" concoctions, a Poulsard, which was "having a bad day" and therefore could not be presented to customers, and a Pinot Noir from the same producer, which was undrinkable unless you like wine vinegar mixed with urine. I have named and shamed the restaurant here, but not the wine in question, because I sent it back and didn't pay for it. The alternative suggestion was a Savignin L'Etoile... to accompany rare pigeon served with a dark, umami-laden sauce. Not a great performance by the somm, who also first served our bottle of Macle CdJ at hot room temperature (I guessed around 26C), gave me a withering glance when I asked for it to be slightly cooled, and then punished us by plungung it into an out-of-reach-ice bucket, only returning once it was almost frozen. That evening was the first time I can remember that I was happy to leave absolutely no tip at all.

  • 2015 Domaine Macle Côtes du Jura Tradition 91 Points

    France, Jura, Côtes du Jura

    (9/11/2020)

    From 75cl, good cork. What a beautiful typé CdJ this is, hard to believe it has 80% Chardonnay and only 20% Savagnin, as it's so intensely aromatic, zesty, brightly citric, deeply woody, layered and complex – all in all a great young idiosyncratic wine, (just) perhaps (vaguely) comprarable with a juvenile LdH Tondonia in perfect condition. 91P, indeed 91+(+?) if it develops as well as I think it should in the cellar.

    Served at summer room temperature at Maison Jeunet in Arbois (=26C, our request that it be cooled down to 18C was met with frosty disapproval and punished by immersion in an ice bucket until it was freezing cold. But despite the best efforts of the sommelier to make us feel like foreign idiots, and the stiff markup to 78 EUR, this was the sole outstanding beacon of excellence in several days of being served dreary Jura wines, most of which I didn't even bother registering, let alone writing TNs for, in struggling Jura restaurants. It tasted great too hot, too cold and (two hours later) at an ideal cool room temperature, with every single course of a decent but too-long Michelin** menu, and (almost) kept us awake until the final course 4 hours after we arrived. The sommelier got his own back, however, by serving an additional glass of vinegary, fizzy, refermenting "natural wine" red, allegedly a Pinot Noir, with the rare pigeon breast. First World problems, I know, but I admit to wishing that Covid-19 might simply eradicate the market for "natural wine" without killing us, or indeed any single one of the pretentious sommeliers who keep insisting I should pay my own good money for their latest undrinkable "natural wine" discoveries.

    Read 1 Comment / Post a Comment / 4 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • 2016 Domaine de Montbourgeau Savagnin L'Etoile 86 Points

    France, Jura, L'Etoile

    (9/11/2020)

    By the glass at Maison Jeunet** in Arbois. Thin, cleanly made, lemony Savagnin, which paled into stingy oblivion next to the superb Macle Côtes du Jura we were drinking already. The sommelier is not always your friend, particularly when his mission is to sell you additional glasses of wine like this for 18 EUR/15cl (or preferably, in his view, "natural wine", but let's not get into that subject right now). It was, gentle reader, not an appropriate accompaniment for rare pigeon served with stuffed turnip and umami-laden sauce. I could have told you this, you know it too, but there is no reasoning with a sommelier who is hell-bent on demonstrating his superiority. 86P

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2012 Paul Benoit & fils Arbois Vin Jaune 87 Points

    France, Jura, Arbois

    (9/13/2020)

    From 62cl, bottle opened day before in a restaurant. This exact wine recently won a coup de coeur from the local producers' association, but alas not from me this evening. It's super-clean, which is a good start for a VJ, but compared to more senior VJ from this the region (B+S Tissot, Macle & co) it's pretty thin, lacking concentration, texture, resonance and length. 87P

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2016 Daniel Dugois Savagnin Arbois Sous Voile 87 Points

    France, Jura, Arbois

    (9/11/2020)

    From 75cl, cork not seen. Nothing wrong with this serviceable typé (=sous voile) Arbois Savagnin. A bit dilute, perhaps, but clean. For those unfamiliar with the style, it's reminiscent of a traditional white Rioja (several rungs under MdM Capellania or LdH Tondonia/Gravonia) crossed with a fino sherry. We paid top dollar (=36 EUR) for this in a provincial Jura restaurant; the 15 EUR cellar door price is closer to the mark, but I'm afraid there are other, more exciting products out there at this price point. The 2012 was awarded 92P in Wine Spectator, but the most I can offer for this this bottle is 87P.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2018 Paul Benoit & fils Pinot Noir 86 Points

    France, Jura, Arbois

    (9/13/2020)

    From 75cl, composite cork. Initially brightly acidic and almost petillant, this calmed down after a couple of hours. Obviously very young and primary, but unexpectedly pure and super-ripe. Right now this is simply too sweet and fruit-juice-like to accompany food; given 5+ years in the cellar (the dodgy closure permitting) it might become more interesting. Blind I might have guessed an attenuated, but well-crafted Spanish Grenache, hope it develops some hint of pinosity with age. 86P(+?)

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • NV Benoît Lahaye Champagne Blanc de Noirs 90 Points

    France, Champagne

    (9/14/2020)

    From 75cl, disgorged 12/2019, pristine cork (as if it had been disgorged yesterday, in fact). Recommended by the somellière at Les Avisés. Avize, and initially served ice-bucket cold. Quite dark yellow for a NV; pretty closed, but a thick vinous cloud of scent, possibly yellow-fruited – your guess might be better than mine. Big-bodied entry; gentle, medium-sized bubbles, which disappeared a little too quickly. Blackcurrant leaf and bruised overripe red apple mid-palate, oak quite dominant. I think this might have completed malo en barrique, but it would be interesting to know for sure. Some accompanying spice/ginger. Finish bitter at first, but this improved towards the end of the bottle as it warmed up to room temperature. This Bouzy BdN strikes me as aiming at the big-boned style of Vilmart Grand Cellier NV; not sure I really like it. But we both agreed it simply wasn't ready to drink yet, and might have shown better in 2-4 years time. 89-90P

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

×
×