Tasted Sunday, November 8, 2020 by timothynbond with 189 views
Put together an ad hoc blind tasting to see how well the de Negoce wines I purchased fared. Picked up bottles that were available at my local small town liquor store, so maybe not the best comparison group, but still managed to get some stuff that was from reasonably close geography. I double-decanted each wine two hours in advance and put inside of bottle-sized burlap sacks, then had a friend tie and label them with letters to keep things anonymized. Unfortunately I realized while pouring that the Heitz comes in a green bottle, so I was not blinded to that one. Tasted each wine individually, evaluated them and voted on our favorites, and then did the reveal. I managed to guess each one correctly, but perhaps it was not that hard given how different the wines were. Among the five of us, everyone but me picked the OG No. 42 as their favorite, while if I excluded the Heitz which wasn't really blind for me, I preferred the OG No. 21. Drank the leftover with some grilled dry aged ribeye afterwards.
At this stage the de Negoce wines are certainly beating other Napa-designated cabs at this price point, and have some upside. So I am happy with the purchase. Going to bury them now until 2022, but will be fun to come back then and do another blind tasting with some 2018s at various price points and same AVAs.
2015 Beaulieu Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley 81 Points
USA, California, Napa Valley
Double decanted around two hours before. Tasted outdoors blind on a 75 degree day. Deep ruby with a cranberry nose. Cranberries and raspberries on the nose. Medium bodied with virtually no acidity or discernible tannins, with some strong pencil lead towards the front and coffee towards the back. Easy drinking but not particularly thought-provoking. Felt like a mass-produced supermarket wine, so I guessed this was the BV.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2018 de Négoce Cabernet Sauvignon OG N.42 88 Points
USA, California, Napa Valley, St. Helena
Double decanted two hours before serving. Tasted blind, outdoors, on a 75 degree day. Ruby colored with medium-intensity. A nose of tasted oak, marshmallows (like a campfire) and blood orange. Medium-plus tannins with quite a bit of grip, medium-low acidity. Began with blueberry fruit on the front but was a bit thin mid-palate before an interesting blood orange finish. Based on the tannins I placed this as one of the 2018, and through process of elimination figured it was the No. 42. The four other tasters picked this as the wine of the afternoon, but I placed it behind No. 21 and the Heitz.
Post a Comment / 2 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
2018 de Négoce Cabernet Sauvignon OG N.21 89 Points
USA, California, Napa Valley, Atlas Peak
Double decanted about two hours prior to serving. Tasted blind, outdoors, on a 75 degree day. Deep ruby-purple. Nose of vanilla and raspberries over a bit of tar (others found the tar more pronounced than me). Very strong grippy tannins with medium-low acidity and lots of sweet fruit on the palate, including notes of raspberries and cranberries. A little bit of heat on the palate. Based on the strength of the tannins I figured this must be a 2018, and placed it as the No. 21 from the sweetness of the fruit I recalled from the previous bottle. This one was much more in line with how I remember the last bottle finishing than the weird flavors and aromas I got when I first popped it. This was my favorite of the day if you exclude the Heitz which was identifiable from bottle color.
Post a Comment / 2 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
2015 Antica (Antinori) Cabernet Sauvignon 88 Points
USA, California, Napa Valley, Atlas Peak
Double-decanted about 2 hours before serving. Tasted blind, outdoors on a 75 degree day. Deep ruby color. A really in your face fruity nose of raspberries and cranberries with some reductive notes in the background. Lots of pencil lead on the palate with some very dark fruits (including plums) interwoven. Medium-plus tannins that were integrating well, but a bit thin mid-palate. Guessed this was the Antica because it felt a bit old world.
Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
2010 Heitz Cellar Cabernet Sauvignon 91 Points
USA, California, Napa Valley
Double-decanted two hours before serving. Tasted blind, outdoors, on a 75 degree day, but I was the one who had double decanted everything and I immediately recognized it as the only green bottle. Medium deep ruby color with aromas of smoked meats and dark fruit. Still a good amount of tannins and very well-balanced with flavors of blackberry, blueberry, blood orange, and hint of graphite on the front, with some sweet orange mid-palate and a strained tea finish. This was a weird bottle -- I purchased it from a local liquor store the day before and immediately stood it up only to find when I uncorked it that a layer of sediment had more or less formed in between the cork and the wine. It was also the last bottle we tasted and was noticeably warmer than optimal. Still showed well to me, but I recognized the bottle and knew that it was something I enjoyed in the past so there may have been psychological factors at play. My friends found to have some off-putting barnyard notes that I did not detect.
Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No