Tasted Sunday, March 14, 2021 by Omar Khayyam with 133 views
The Biecher wine was by far the more simpler wine, but also more open nose. Of the three more serious wines, the Zind-Humbrecht had some oak imprint as well as some residual sugar. But all three shared in that they had power and weight. These are food friendly wines that did better with food than on their own and that merits further cellaring, as they did best in the evening (we opened the bottles in the morning and left them uncorked on the kitchen counter all day, re-corking and chilling in the fridge just 45 minutes before dinner and then had them open for the entire evening.
I am very impressed by what you get for the price (in Sweden, the three better wines retail for 19-25 euros and the Biecher Riesling reserve for 8,8 euros). Some serious wine that you could easily put way a case of in the cellar - especially the Schoenenbourg Grand cru and the Herrenweg de Turckheim.
2019 Jean Biecher Riesling Reserve 81 Points
France, Alsace
Very open and delightful nose for a wine that retails well below 10 euro. Rosewater, lychee fruits and other lovely fruity and floral notes. My first feeling is, wow! is the difference between the grand cru rieslings at double or triple the price so little? Alas, it is not, as I try the wine, it is a lot thinner on mid palate, with a little bitter note and none of the lovely ripe fat fruit and texture of the other bottles. However, not bad for the price. We ended up using half the bottle for the fish soup.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2017 Zind-Humbrecht Riesling Herrenweg de Turckheim 89 Points
France, Alsace
The most perfumed wine upon opening of our line up of four random Alsatian rieslings. A little bit more luxuriously complex nose than the others, which I later chalk up on the account of some old oak barrel élevage and some residual sugar. There is a soaplike riesling aroma (no petroleum) - green apples, lime peel, peaches and lemon. Also some damp cellar and later on browned apple core.
At first rather spritzy but also tell tale big mid palate with a grassy and slightly bitter mineral finish. At first it does not really mesh, but 12 hours later the parts start to integrate in the glass and this is lovely to a fish soup. It balances between dry and off-dry. A food wine that needs some time in the cellar but is expressive now as well.
Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No
2017 Domaines Schlumberger Riesling Les Princes Abbés 88 Points
France, Alsace
Of the four Alsace rieslings tried, this had the most tell tale riesling nose
with some nice complexity and apple wedges mixed with hints of oily umbra or petroleum if you like, super dry, acids are slightly hard; it's a grassy and youthful showing of a steel tanked dry riesling not without body and power. As the evening goes on and the wines receive more air, the Dopff Schoenenborg and the Zind-Humbrecht Herrenweg de Turckheim gains in complexity and feel more rounded and integral, while this retains its grassy, sharp edges and slightly more simple feeling. It probably needs a couple of years more in the cellar.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
2017 Dopff au Moulin Riesling Schoenenbourg 92 Points
France, Alsace, Alsace Grand Cru
At first rather tight on the nose with fresh laundry and white flowers. Not giving much away. Big rather fat body for a dry white wine. Good acidity, slightly bitter finish, some alcohol.
But after many hours of airing the wine, it suddenly starts to open up to a beautiful pure riesling aroma of key lime pie, peaches, lemon. The powerful expression is supported by the big but balanced body which still has that gooseberry rather dry and bitter finish, but in a really nice way.
So impressed by this wine from a producer I had previously written off as a mass producer of not so exciting crèmant. Great QPR and excellent future for this wine, even long term.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No