Tasting Wines by Structure - HIGH ACID WHITES - Nick Jackson MW

WEBINAR
Tasted Sunday, March 28, 2021 - Sunday, April 18, 2021 by Heynetty with 214 views

Introduction

Three white wine grapes with a similar acid level but different acid type and shape.
Based on his book Beyond Flavor and not all the details are in the books so I'm giving this webinar a go.

Flight 1 - 3 High Acid White Wines (3 Notes)

  • 2018 Château d'Epiré Savennières 89 Points

    France, Loire Valley, Anjou-Saumur, Savennières

    (3/28/2021)

    A: Pale lemon
    N: Medium (+) nose of baked pear, yellow oxidised apple, acetyldehyde, lemon, honey, CHEESE, LANOLIN (really stinky merino socks), white blossom, wet rock, chamomile
    P: Dry, powerfully high acidity (type:bracing - it feels almost alive on your palate. shape: crescendo), medium alcohol (13%), medium (+) body, medium (+) intensity and long finish
    C: Cheese and lanolin too dominant AND the fruit is also outcompeted by the acidity, ideal length, good intensity and gaining in complexity here. Very good quality wine but better examples would have these elements better integrated with the pleasing flavors of fruit and florals.
    Suitable for ageing. The fruit and florals should balance out the acidity.
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Jackson says: savennieres is austere in youth and acidity feels like it dominates the fruit. The fruit and new flavors of toast and nut balances the acidity if left to develop age. Acid/Fruit balance is much better in young South African Chenin Blanc. The ripeness from the warmer climate helps.
    Ripe Chenin Blanc is soft at beginning so people think its a warm weather chardonnay but hold in mouth for 5 seconds and the acidity screams upwards.

    Aligote is high in acid but jagged shaped acidity. Others sometimes muddle these.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2017 Jean Reverdy & Fils Sancerre Silex 89 Points

    France, Loire Valley, Upper Loire, Sancerre

    (3/28/2021)

    A: Medium lemon
    N: Medium (+) nose of CHEESE, yoghurt but....
    P: Party on the palate. fresh green apple, fresh gooseberry, freah grapefruit, lime, grass, white blossom, wet rock, cheese, yoghurt.
    Dry, high acidity (type: electric , feel it on the edges on area in front of the gums/front teeth and cheeks are PRICKLY or ZESTY for ages after spitting. Shape: NJ says feeling it on tongues first and then moves to the perimeter around the edges of the mouth makes it SPHERICAL), medium alcohol (13%), medium (+) body, medium (+) intensity, medium (+) finish
    C: The acidity feels like there isn't enough fruit ripeness or intensity to deal with it but that is most Sancerre. Length seems good and as is intensity on the palate but lacks complexity. It does however present a typical picture of the grape from the Sancerre region. Its. a very good quality wine. Finer examples may have higher intensity. The wine is made to consume in its youth. Not likely to improve on ageing.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------
    Jackson adds that the fruit and body is very different and separate to the acidity in SB, Aligote and Muscadet. Note the lack of integration of the acidity. Exceptions include warm climates and high end Sancerres (single vineyards with lower yield), acidity feels more integrated. Bordeaux is complicated as its a blend. The acid structure is different. Semillon has a linear acid structure so remains at same level while the wine remains in the mouth. Also worth noting that CB is backloaded for acidity and but SB has more attack in the front.
    In Riesling or Chardonnay, its not like this.Acidity, for these grapes, is tucked into the fruit.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2020 Mylonas Assyrtiko

    Greece, Continental Greece, Attica

    (3/28/2021)

    A: Pale lemon
    N: Medium nose of preserved lemon, fresh lime, GRAPEFRUIT PITH, SALT, wet rock.
    P: Dry, super sour, high acidity (type:hard solid wall just smack you in the face...more so than CB or SB . Here the acid supports the rest of the wine. shape: I find lots under the tongue and then lots falling off the roof of the mouth. NJ calls this floor to ceiling type of acidity, medium alcohol (13.5%), pronounced intensity, medium body, medium finish
    C: This style is all about the saline and lemon and acidity. I think the acidity is leaving the fruit behind here. Good intensity and typicity but not complex or long.Good Quality wine.
    Suitable for ageing owing to high acidity. The fruit is deliberately made to play second fiddle to the terroir.
    ------------------------------------------------------------------
    Jackson adds the grape is high in phenolic bitterness. Common in this grape and albarino.It gives bite and freshness. It can be a check on fruit oxidation. U get it in Alsace again because they press the fruit firmly and so you get it at the moment of swallowing where one might normally get signs of oxidation. Note that Albarino has more fruit up front such as lime cordial and tropical fruit

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Closing

I am really interested to see if this works. Ask me in a month. Very subjective but may be useful.

×
×