Catalan Old World vs New World Wine Dinner

Catalan Tapas Bar (Cary NC)
Tasted Wednesday, August 11, 2021 by WineKnurd with 126 views

Introduction

5 Courses paired with 2 wines each, an old world ad new world wine. Definitely not your typical new world selections, and I very much enjoyed the thought that Jen put into the Albarino and Tempranillo new world selections.

Flight 1 - Albarino (2 Notes)

Shrimp & scallop ceviche with arugula, cilantro, and some diced Serrano to make it interesting, plus a few plantain tostones for scooping.

No clear winner for da' Knurd with this flight, the acidity of the Galacian Albarino is always a great contrast to the earthiness of a ceviche while the Santa Inez Albarino needed the earthiness of the ceviche to complement the lack of acidity and general earthiness of the wine. A- for both pairings. Oh and the Serrano addition plus the plantain tostones drove this over the top, I lobbied to make this a menu staple (though that was before we had the second course...)

  • 2020 Fento Wines Rías Baixas Bico Da Ran 90 Points

    Spain, Galicia, Rías Baixas

    Served with the first course, squaring off against the new world Crawford Family Albarino out of sunny CA (check the story for notes about the dish and pairing). Saline, lemon zest and some grassy notes with hints of pear. Textbook Albarino acidity. A bit more complex than I was expecting, picked up a few bottles sub-$20; I see no issue with an A- (90) evaluation.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2018 Crawford Family Wines Albariño 86 Points

    USA, California, Central Coast, Santa Barbara County

    Served with the first course, squaring off against the old world Bico da Ran Albarino out of Galacia (check the story for notes about the dish and pairing). Interesting wine, secondary MLF lowers the acidity below what I expect from Albarino and also some lees aging that makes it more apple fruit vs the usual citrus while retaining the traditional Albarino saline qualities. B (86) evaluation as I was expecting a better stand-alone version of Albarino, however this surprisingly scored much higher with the food. I appreciated the wine however the $30 price tag kept me form ordering any after the dinner.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 2 - Chardonnay (2 Notes)

Thyme risotto with smoked peppercorn Gruyere and topped with a fig demi-glace. Dish of the night, hit on so may levels- sweet, rich, creamy, cheesy, smoky, peppery, figgy; truly an experience for the palate. Mrs Knurd almost stole my portion as I was tasting the wines.

Mrs Knurd and I disagreed about which wine paired better, she preferred the Argentinian while I gave the edge to the Chablis for the old word wine + old world cheese used in the dish. Both were good, A- pairing for Argentina (didn't quite have the acidic oomph needed for the dish) and A+ on the Chablis (had the acidity needed to complement the richness but not so much as to turn things sour).

  • 2019 Marchiori & Barraud Chardonnay 88 Points

    Argentina, Mendoza

    Served with the second course, squaring off against the old world Marcel Servin Chablis (check the story for notes about the dish and pairing). More of a "tropical" style Chardonnay. 8 months in American oak gives it a smoky, mesquite nose along with vanilla and banana notes. Good acidity. Could easily have become disjointed but can tell that this was crafted by an experienced hand. Definitely unique, picked up 3 bottles at $20/pop to satisfy my knurd-ness. B+ (88) evaluation.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2018 Marcel Servin Chablis 88 Points

    France, Burgundy, Chablis

    Served with the second course, squaring off against the new world Marchiori & Barraud Chardonnay out of Argentina (check the story for notes about the dish and pairing). Definite lees aging on this one, apples and a hint of cream on the nose with lemon curd, limestone, and herbaceous hints on the finish. The limestone gets more "steely" with air but doesn't become sour or overly acidic. Pretty standard Chablis, picked up a bottle @ $20 to have on hand considering I have had worse for more. B+ (88) evaluation.

    Post a Comment / 2 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

Flight 3 - Pinot Noir (2 Notes)

Chicken roulade rolled with prosciutto, served over a bed of spinach, topped with a wild mushroom saute, sun dried tomatoes, and toasted peppercorn cream sauce.

Oregon takes the win in my book, as the oaky-spicy complexity brought an extra level to the dish, pairing nicely with the earthy mushrooms and salty prosciutto (A- evaluation). The French pairing suffered from being basic, as the dish was too layered and too complex for a one dimensional wine to really offer much more than just something to drink (B evaluation).

  • 2019 Violin Pinot Noir 90 Points

    USA, Oregon, Willamette Valley

    Served with the third course, squaring off against the old world Rene Leclerc Pinot of out of Burgundy (check the story for notes about the dish and pairing). Definitely more earthy and complex than its French counterpart, adding in notes of cedar spice, clove, and some citrus as it opens up, along with the "typical" cherry-raspberry combo I like in Oregon Pinot. More harmonious and complex than I was expecting out of the the Willamette especially for the price, picked up 3 bottles at the ridiculously discounted price of $20 each. A- (90) evaluation.

    Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

  • 2019 Domaine René Leclerc Bourgogne 85 Points

    France, Burgundy, Bourgogne

    Served with the third course, squaring off against the new world Violin Pinot of out of Oregon (check the story for notes about the dish and pairing). Suffers from the Burgundy markup, where the "value" doesn't start coming in until about that $40-$45 price point. Basic, one dimensional, and a tad too bold and assertive, maybe for the American palate? Nothing technically wrong with the wine, other than my expectations. B (85) evaluation.

    Post a Comment / 2 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

Flight 4 - Temperanillo (2 Notes)

Grilled lamb skewers with rosemary, smoked paprika, Aleppo peppers, and harissa roasted radishes with a cucumber raita for dipping.

A- on the pairing for both. Each had the tannic structure to hold with the grilled lamb and enough acidity to complement the peppers without the whole thing "turning green". Matched earthy to earthy (tobacco and radish) and spice to spice (oak and harissa), with the raita offering a nice cool and creamy change-up in texture and flavor. This dish and the Raptor Ridge were my 'Knurd pairing of the night.

  • 2015 Raptor Ridge Tempranillo Reserva 89 Points

    USA, Oregon, Southern Oregon, Rogue Valley

    Served with the fourth course, squaring off against the old world La Perla Rioja Reserva (check the story for notes about the dish and pairing). Spicy black fruits, blackberries mostly with earthy tobacco, black pepper, and leathery tannins. Screwcap after aging in oak for about 2 years, not sure there is any benefit to the further 2 year bottle conditioning because of the particular closure however it certainly is not hurting the wine. Voted best Tempranillo in North America by the Canadians and I have to agree with our northern neighbors on this one. Generally the domestic Tempranillo I have have the "pleasure" of trying ends up down the drain but my hats off to Raptor Ridge. Picked up 2 bottles at $40 each; you won't mistake this for $40 Rioja but definitely worth supporting Raptor Ridge's effort on this one. B+ (89) evaluation.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

  • 2014 Bodegas Solagüen Rioja La Perla 87 Points

    Spain, La Rioja, Rioja

    Served with the fourth course, squaring off against the new world Raptor Ridge Tempranillo out of Oregon (check the story for notes about the dish and pairing). Classic value Rioja- blackberry, fig, tobacco, spice, with some stewed notes. 18 months in American and French oak and 18 months in bottle. I have plenty of Rioja so I didn't pick any up at the dinner, but its a solid B+ (87) if you can get it for about $20/bottle.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 5 - Dessert (1 Note)

Bread pudding mixed with cinnamon raisin pretzels, orange peel candied pecans, and drizzled with dark rum sauce.

Wow this was outstanding! Great combination of flavors and textures, with the pudding itself being more brown sugar sweet and the candies pecans being a "brighter" citrus sweet plus the addition of the pretzels adding a bit of crunch to the creaminess as well as a nice salty contrast. The PX was just too much for a a nuanced dessert like this, I have used it many times before either in the dessert glaze or poured over a thick cake and/or ice cream, then served with a glass of the stuff; that's the only way to get this to "pair". Not even going to evaluate it. Note that the PX is the Bodegas 501 'Gades' Pedro Ximenex Viejo Sherry NV but it is not listed in CT.

The NOTG however was a different story, with its citrus notes complementing the orange peel glaze, giving it a nice pop. A- for that pairing.

  • 2018 Hill Family Estate N.O.T.G. Late Harvest 90 Points

    USA, California, Napa Valley

    Served with the fifth and final dessert course, squaring off against the old world PX based Gades from Jerez (check the story for notes about the dish and pairing).The Hill family does something interesting here, 97% late harvest Sauvignon Blanc affected with botrytis and 3% "normal" Viognier that is blended in after 6 months of aging in barrel. You won't mistake this for Sauternes, however would describe it as "Sauternes light" not in the sense that it is watered down but the lightness gained from a higher acid and less viscous wine (a fair assessment since it does not have the Semillon that gives Sauternes its body). Nose and palate full of oranges and tangerines with some red nectarine thrown in and plenty of florals and perfume from the Viognier. Not as much honey as it is marmalade and juice. I enjoyed it, and while the $50 for a 500 mL price tag was a bit steep, decided to splurge on a bottle to help put the Hill family kids through college. A- (90) evaluation.

    Post a Comment / 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No

×
×