Off to the Desert: An Intimate Evening at Caduceus Cellars' Ventura Room

My introduction to Caduceus Cellars came through the 2010 documentary "Blood into Wine," which chronicled Maynard James Keenan's ambitious venture into Arizona winemaking. As both a Tool fan and wine enthusiast, I had tried several Caduceus wines back then, though I never documented those early experiences with tasting notes. When I found myself in Phoenix for the weekend, the two-hour drive north to Cottonwood seemed like destiny calling—after all, my blog is called Heavy Pour Wine for a reason! I booked the exclusive Ventura Room experience primarily for the opportunity to taste back vintages and gain unprecedented access to the production facility. After a morning stop at Cathedral Rock in Sedona and some shopping in Old Town Cottonwood's downtown, I arrived at the hilltop estate for an intimate tasting hosted by Alan with Chef Rhyin preparing a three-course meal to accompany eight wines.

• 2021 Caduceus Cellars Nagual del Marzo 92 Points

  USA, Arizona, Yavapai County

  First visit to Caduceus Cellars in Cottonwood. This wine is named after the Marzo block, a really tiny two-acre vineyard where the grapes sit right on the creek, receiving substantial supplemental water from a high water table and significant calcareous sediment deposits. I arrived at the estate a few minutes before the tasting started so I was given a welcome pour of this wine by Jamie because I indicated I'm a fan of Super Tuscan wines. Sweet cherry nose with luscious fruit and bright red fruit character.
  
  Brad - heavypourwine.com

  Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

• 2023 Caduceus Cellars Hilltop PetNat Galileo 89 Points

  USA, Arizona, Yavapai County

  First visit to the Caduceus Cellars Ventura Room in Cottonwood with host Alan. This petnat represents the second bottle produced from the Galileo vineyard on the hilltop property. Maynard acquired this property in 2016, the same year the original Merkin restaurant opened about a block and a half away, with everything moving to the current hilltop location when it opened on October 6, 2023. The wine is made from the three varietals planted at this location in the exact same proportion as they exist in the vineyard: 40% Tempranillo, 40% Garnacha, and 20% Graciano, with in-bottle fermentation creating the bubbles. Orange and melon on the nose with a soda-like fizz character. Bitter finish. Not my favorite, though it was a decent pairing with the two bruschetta bites—one featuring herb ricotta with pickled blueberries, saguaro honey, Beavertail, smoked Maldon sea salt and marigold; the other with olive tapenade, sunny-side-up quail egg, green aioli and house-made Sriracha. The wine improved from my initial impression, moving from 88 to 89 points.
  
  Brad - heavypourwine.com

  Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

• 2012 Caduceus Cellars Primer Paso 91 Points

  USA, Arizona, Cochise County

  First visit to the Caduceus Cellars Ventura Room in Cottonwood with host Alan. Primer Paso means "first step" or "first pass" and was the first bottle Maynard ever released, debuting as a 2004 vintage. This wine is modeled after a northern Rhône blend with a Syrah focus—this vintage contains 60% Syrah and 33% Petite Sirah. Instead of the classic Viognier that would typically be added to such a blend, Maynard uses Malvasia Bianca, which has become a huge player in Arizona wine—essentially the Viognier of the state, traced back to Greece as its point of origin but grown extensively in Italy and Croatia. This vintage contains 7% Malvasia Bianca, though current vintages use 20%, adding even more floral white aromatics. The bottle had been open since yesterday. Old World funk on the nose with dark fruit and leather. Medium to low tannin. Good pairing with the salad course, which featured sunburst beets poached in orange juice with pink peppercorn and coriander then candied in saguaro honey, spiced nuts, Crow's Dairy feta, baby lettuce and arugula from the estate greenhouses, all dressed with a poached cherry vinaigrette made with Sancha wine. The salad in particular was amazing, and the accompanying pie was delicious as well.
  
  Brad - heavypourwine.com

  Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

• 2014 Caduceus Cellars Sangiovese Kitsuné 93 Points

  USA, Arizona, Cochise County

  First visit to the Caduceus Cellars Ventura Room in Cottonwood with host Alan. This wine comes from some of Caduceus's oldest vines, Sangiovese planted in the early 1980s in the Buhl vineyard down in southeastern Arizona. In Japanese folklore, a Kitsuné is a fox-like creature that serves as a protector, and this wine is named after Maynard's primary bodyguard, whose last name is Fox. Alan mentioned that Maynard sees good longevity in his wines, noting at least 30 years of aging potential, with bottles going back to 2004 still tasting beautifully when properly stored. The bottle had been open since yesterday. Tertiary notes on the nose with tobacco. Resolved tannin. Nice wine showing beautiful aged characteristics. This was my WOTN, and I purchased several bottles for my cellar.
  
  Brad - heavypourwine.com

  Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

• 2010 Caduceus Cellars Petite Sirah Velvet Slippers Club 87 Points

  USA, California

  First visit to the Caduceus Cellars Ventura Room in Cottonwood with host Alan. This wine club selection showcases one of the perks of the Ventura Room experience—access to really obscure archive bottles at prices well below typical markup. The wine has 14.1% alcohol, which Alan noted is higher than most current Caduceus releases, as Maynard has dropped alcohol levels over the years by picking at slightly lower Brix levels, resulting in most wines now finishing in the 13s. Maynard doesn't want bombastic, smack-you-in-the-face fruit; he wants wines that highlight the natural palate of the fruit without being masked by oak or alcohol, wines that pair beautifully with food with everything in balance. The bottle had been open since yesterday and mine was the last pour from the bottle. Tons of alcohol on the nose, almost smelling like a sherry. Liquorice and red fruit. Too much acid with red liquorice on the palate. Doesn't taste like any Petite Sirah I've had before. I really didn't enjoy this wine and it was my least favorite of the tasting.
  
  Brad - heavypourwine.com

  Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

• 2013 Caduceus Cellars Sancha 92 Points

  USA, Arizona

  First visit to the Caduceus Cellars Ventura Room in Cottonwood with host Alan. Sancha was originally sourced from the Buhl vineyard in southeastern Arizona when local vineyards weren't yet mature, but current vintages come from the Eliphante vineyard here in the Verde Valley. The wine is typically 100% Tempranillo, though some earlier vintages might contain a little bit of Garnacha. Tempranillo, along with Sangiovese and Garnacha, are varietals that thrive in Arizona's climate. Alan noted that over the years Maynard has been phasing out Cabernet to minimal production levels, moving away from well-known varietals to more obscure ones that excel in this climate, particularly Italian varietals and grapes found throughout Mediterranean regions. Now, we're back to Old World funk on the nose after the Petite Sirah. Whew! Still some tannin present with red fruit character.
  
  Brad - heavypourwine.com

  Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

• 2022 Caduceus Cellars Hilltop Reserva 92 Points

  USA, Arizona, Yavapai County

  First visit to the Caduceus Cellars Ventura Room in Cottonwood with host Alan. This represents the very first bottle produced from the hilltop Galileo vineyard. The wine shares the same blend as the Hilltop PetNat from earlier in the tasting: 40% Tempranillo, 40% Garnacha, and 20% Graciano. Alan described it as a lovely red for Arizona, noting it's light with a brightness to it that makes it really pleasing in warm weather. The bottle had been open since yesterday. Red young fruit on the nose with a very young profile overall. Lots of red fruit with low tannin. I really liked this wine and purchased several bottles for my cellar.
  
  Brad - heavypourwine.com

  Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

• NV Caduceus Cellars Helio Dolce 91 Points

  USA, Arizona, Yavapai County

  First visit to the Caduceus Cellars Ventura Room in Cottonwood with host Alan. This port-style wine is a co-ferment of Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Petite Sirah, and Malvasia Bianca, with 7% residual sugar and 18% alcohol. Alan recommended tasting it last as it would wipe out the palate for going back to other wines due to its high sugar and alcohol content. He described it as a perfect nightcap wine in small amounts, with notes of fig, roasted walnut, and caramelized toffee. Typical high-alcohol sherry nose with a nice smooth caramel palate. Good pairing with the dessert course, which featured a dark chocolate ganache infused with Anubis (reduced down from an entire bottle to 2 ounces of paste) folded into mascarpone, apricot glaze with Fresno chili pepper, mint-infused whipped cream, and poached wine cherry panna cotta set with agar-agar.
  
  Brad - heavypourwine.com

  Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

The Ventura Room experience delivered exactly what I'd hoped for—unprecedented access to Caduceus Cellars' archive wines and an intimate look at the winemaking operation that Maynard James Keenan has spent two decades building in the Arizona high desert. The highlights were tasting back through nearly fifteen years of the winery's history, from the 2010 Petite Sirah to the brand-new 2022 Hilltop Reserva, and watching Chef Rhyin's thoughtful approach to pairing locally-sourced ingredients with each wine. The 2014 Kitsuné Sangiovese stood out as my favorite of the tasting, showcasing beautiful tertiary development from those early-1980s vines. Alan's historical perspective—having met Maynard on his first trip through Jerome in 1995 and watching the entire operation evolve from an idea to this impressive hilltop facility—added valuable context to understanding Arizona's emerging wine industry and Caduceus's role in elevating the Verde Valley's reputation. While I enjoyed the wines, the food and Alan were the stars of this particular show.