Gibby's Vintage Club August Event: Blind Tasting - "A Snowball's Chance..."

Gibby's Wine Den, Geneva, IL
Tasted Thursday, August 20, 2009 by AllRed with 499 views

Introduction

Our local wine shop hosts a monthly tasting for its wine club members. The August event was a blind tasting of six wines, poured one at a time. Domino & I decided that since we usually do not fare well at these, our team name would be A Snowball's Chance.

Tasters were awarded points by correctly identifying the varietal (10), country (5), region/appellation (broadly defined) (10), vintage (5) and winery (25). We had roughly 10 minutes with each wine before the next was poured. The wines were unveiled at the very end, after all six had been tasted.

Flight 1 - Wine A. (1 Note)

Form the start we thought this was a Cali Chardonnay. Then we got to the last couple of sips and that Rhonish quality on the palate. That caused us to think maybe it wasn't a Chard, but we quickly dimissed that thought, and figured it was from somewhere other than California. Aussie? Oregon? We settled on a 2007 Oregon Chard. The whole group picked this as a Chardonnay. 5 points for vintage.

  • 2007 Goats do Roam Wine Company Goats do Roam White 89 Points

    South Africa

    Deep yellow color. Aromas of vanilla, butter, tropical fruit, coconut and oak. Flavors of tropical fruit, vanilla and oak. Medium to full-bodied, with a creamy, slightly viscous texture. Decent finish. The last sips had a slightly waxy, Rhonish quality.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 2 - Wine B. (1 Note)

There was no doubt this was a Sauvignon Blanc, but again, where was it from? We waffled between South Africa and California, and settled on a 2008 South African Sauv Blanc. 15 points for vintage and varietal.

  • 2008 Girard Winery Sauvignon Blanc 89 Points

    USA, California, Napa Valley

    Pale yellow color. Notes of citrus, jalapeno and grass. Good acidity, with flavors of grapefruit, citrus, grass, spice and a hint of jalapeno, and a nice medium finish.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 3 - Wine C. (1 Note)

At first whiff we thought Viognier, before we got to the wooly character of the fruit, and we leaned toward Chenin. Once it warmed and the floral qualities came out, we knew our first instinct was right. We settled on a 2006 California Viognier. 25 points for varietal, country and region.

  • 2007 Zaca Mesa Viognier 88 Points

    USA, California, Central Coast, Santa Ynez Valley

    Nice yellow color, opening with a billowy cotton aroma. Initially too cold, it wasn't until the last sips that the telltale floral qualities became evident. Woolly apple and white fruit flavors, with a hint of mineral. A bit too acidic.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 4 - Wine D. (1 Note)

The chocolate note initially had us thinking Merlot, but after that quickly disappeared we began leaning toward a low-priced Cali Cabernet. We guessed 2006 Mendocino Cabernet. When unveiling this one, it tunrned out that half of the group thought Cab, the other half thought Pinot. However one taster correctly identified this as Sangiovese. Well done. We however, get shut out.

  • 2005 Castello di Monsanto Chianti Classico 86 Points

    Italy, Tuscany, Chianti, Chianti Classico DOCG

    Garnet color with aromas of chocolate, herbs, earth and cherry, with a slightly green/stemmy edge. With air, the cherry note really dominates. Flavors of raspberry liqueur and white pepper with drying tannins on the finish. 86-87 pts.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 5 - Wine E. (1 Note)

The earthy, sous bois character initially had us in Bordeaux. The depth of the fruit, along with the blueberry and slightly sweet profile turned us away. We settled on a 2006 Malbec from Mendoza. Another shut out, and further proof that you should almost always go with your first instinct.

  • 2005 Château Plaisance (Bordeaux Supérieur) 90 Points

    France, Bordeaux, Bordeaux Supérieur

    Inky garnet color. Aromas of blackberry, savory herbs, black raspberry and sous bois. As it sat in the glass it developed a blueberry note and a sweet edge to the fruit. Lush dark fruit flavors on the palate, with slightly sweet tannins and a nice fruity finish.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Flight 6 - Wine F. (1 Note)

Right out of the gate we thought this was Syrah, the only question was from where? Certainly not old world...so we settled on 2005 Californian Syrah. Randy & Jan, the proprietors, gathered the sheets and began tabulating scores while we spent more time with this wine. As we spent more time with it, we knew we were wrong, as we felt pretty strongly this was a Cabernet. It was...but once again we get shut out.

  • 2004 Kaiken Cabernet Sauvignon Ultra 88 Points

    Argentina, Mendoza

    Inky, opaque garnet color. Opens with a nice meaty note, followed by savory herb aromas and black raspberry & dark fruit tones. Tannins are slightly sweet, bolstering flavors of raspberry liqueur, dark fruit and blueberry.

    Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No

Closing

After the scores had been tabulated, we came out on top, but not by much, and with only 45 out of 330 possible points...and not a single point scored on the reds. Ouch. Still, despite being so very humbling, blind tasting is a lot of fun.

×
×