ChrisinCowiche
Posts: 7845
Joined: 12/16/2009 From: Cowiche, WA Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Jenise quote:
ORIGINAL: ChrisinCowiche It’s almost impossible say “best”, because everyone has their own criteria. The highest rated WA wines, Cayuse and Quilceda Creek, don’t have tasting rooms there, or really anywhere unless you have an allocation at their annual tasting release events. Next tier would be a long list. DeLille, Mark Ryan, Gorman, Sparkman, Fidelitas, Force Majeure, Adams Bench, Januik, Efeste, aMaurice, Long Shadows. Not sure which would be open on a Wednesday. You and I don't agree about who's on which tier. Cayuse and Quilceda Creek are definitely the most admired and impossible to get. All the wines you mention are IMO another tier down from Reynvaan, RASA, Corliss, and Passing Time which I mentioned to Eduardo. I would add Liminal to that group, which IS made in Woodinville at Avennia, but here we go again all sold by allocation. While I admire the wines of DeLille, Force Majeure, aMaurice, Efeste and Long Shadows and would recommend them for for exceptional quality and balance, I don't believe these are at the same level of prestige and style that Eduardo prizes in certain boutique Napa producers (names I recall him mentioning, like Blankiet, are all at the $100-300 level). That's a different type of 'best'. Fidelitas, Januik, Sparkman and Gorman are all about bigness--oak, jammy sweet overt ripeness, high alcohol or all of the above. (They have their fans but I'm not one of them.) I think we agree more than we disagree. The challenge obviously is finding the "top tier" that has access Ed can enjoy during his visit to Woodinville. I have not tried Liminal, but have tried Avennia, buying Rhone but not Bordeaux, and am actually on the Liminal list (for now), and just received the invitation to their tasting next weekend in Woodinville. They and Passing Time and maybe one or two others might be worth visiting if private appointments in Woodinville could be arranged.
_____________________________
http://www.cellartracker.com/new/user.asp?iUserOverride=102173
|