Search Results - Save This Search

Wine Type Vintage Name Variety Locale Date Posted Score Helpful Comments Comment Date Community Score More...
Red

2016 Domaine Vincent Paris Crozes-Hermitage Selection

Syrah more

4/8/2023 - tward Likes this wine: 88 points

Very Good+ I rarely buy "mystery" offers these days, but I'm not mad about this at $20 USD delivered. Drank on PnP and only over about an hour and a half, so limited air exposure. Bright and ripe blueberry and blackberry, at first a bit candied in the nose, zesty and fun to drink. Clean and bright, but some savory hints as it opens. A nice flexible food wine.

13% abv

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    10/12/2023 7:41:00 AM - We all have several burn marks from over-hyped Mystery Wines. I am with you on both nixing those and on your spot-on TN (had it last night). Cheers!

Red

2015 Wind Gap Wines Syrah Sonoma Coast

more

5/7/2023 - thalver wrote: NR

This was far and away the best showing of nearly a case consumed, a couple bottles of which have gone down the drain. It was actually enjoyable . Somewhat. There is little fruit, and mostly herbal, forest floor tastes, and not the dominant funk some prior bottles have had. FWIW, I took the advice I had seen to stand these up for a while, and carefully decant off the fine sediment.

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    6/16/2023 5:07:00 AM - So you're telling me there's a chance....?

    We have just reluctantly finished the case of the 2014. I had a few of the 2015 (last posted TN in 5/20/2020). Your TN gives me some reserved hope that not all will be reduced to cooking wine. Cheers to optimism!

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    7/14/2023 5:56:00 PM - Yup. Netter than drinkable tonight.

Red

1993 La Bastide Blanche Bandol Longue Garde

Mourvèdre Blend, Mourvèdre more

8/4/2013 - Chomsky wrote: NR

Twenty years young. In a perfect place right now, secondary fruit and leather, campfire, etc. Very mineral and still somewhat tannic. What a treat.

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    5/29/2023 6:58:00 PM - We shared our one-before-last bottle of this a couple of nights ago, and at now 30 years old, your notes still hold true. Cheers.

Red

2018 Raul Pérez Bierzo Ultreia St. Jacques

Mencía more

4/26/2023 - jpsam Does not like this wine: NR

Nothing remarkable and nothing noteworthy. A Tuesday night wine. I don’t drink wine on Tuesday. You can do better!

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    5/2/2023 4:57:00 PM - Alas, I drank one tonight (Tuesday...), Prior to reading your TN. Otherwise, I would have relegated it to Monday, which (unless I manage to unload this at a pol party or similar) is when my last bottle will be consumed 😉. Just OK for me as well.

Red

2017 Jean-Michel Dupré Morgon Le Griottier

Gamay more

2/4/2022 - guribh wrote: 90 points

Solid Cru BoJo, as others have noted. At peak, and will hold here a few years.

One request: for the love of god, please drop the wax seal...! You'd be saving a few pennies per bottle and, more importantly, help your clients get to the product easier, with less opportunities to have wax in the wine or all over the counter, or a cut in the host's hand otherwise (of course, you may be skilled in some form of sword way of removing this red nuisance - so more power to you...).

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    2/12/2023 9:10:00 AM - @tophcooks - will try...my comment still stands, though.

White

1989 Domaine Jean-Louis Chave Hermitage Blanc

White Rhone Blend more

4/2/2022 - Edclr Likes this wine: 100 points

Absolutely stunning. No signs of age yet. Very youthful with very long finish. Couldn’t believe how distinctive this is. I paid $15 a bottle for this at a grocery store in Atlanta in 1993. Last bottle of 7.

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    5/18/2022 8:28:00 AM - Nice..! - I must have bought my case at the same store around that time (actually, I think it was at Peachtree Rd Liquors), but got ripped-off at $16.99....Drank most by now and thoroughly enjoyed the ride.

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    5/18/2022 2:00:00 PM - Well I'll be damned..Yes, I am. I should have looked at your profile pic (and vice-versa). Let's take this further off this forum: benhashal@gmail.com

    PS: I too have two of the 1989 Chave Rouge left. I actually believe we split this purchase or informed one another of the stash....

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    2/10/2023 3:45:00 AM - My recollection was a short aeration in the glass was all that it needed. Enjoy!

Red

2019 Château Poesia

St. Émilion Grand Cru Red Bordeaux Blend more

6/8/2020 - Jeff Leve wrote: 94 points

Crushed rocks, stones, smoked red fruits, herbs and flowers round out the perfume. On the palate the wine is medium-bodied, silky, fresh and vibrant, showing lift, energy, length and purity in the red pit fruit, cocoa and licorice filled finish. The wine was made from blending 70% Merlot with 30% Cabernet Franc, reaching 14.5% alcohol. 93-95 Pts

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    2/7/2023 8:43:00 PM - This wine gives 105% effort..!

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    2/8/2023 12:31:00 PM - All good. Always appreciate your insight, if not the cypherin'....

Red

2012 Xavier Vignon & Barbare Estate Vin de Turquie Cuvée XL

Turkey Red Rhone Blend more

12/13/2022 - Trevallon Likes this wine: 90 points

No experience with Turkish wine to compare to. I would have called it a Côtés du Rhône or Languedoc wine. Mourvèdre and Syrah characteristics dominated. Enjoyable rustic and still has time.

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    1/28/2023 5:16:00 PM - Spot on still.

Red

2016 Villa Creek Syrah Cherry Newton

Ballard Canyon more

3/28/2021 - tward wrote: 84 points

Good back yard BBQ wine. This was oversold in a long story email pitch. Solid wine, but not a lot of varietal character. Polished, a bit sweet in the domestic typical basic wine sense. Quality fruit, clean. 15% abv, which it holds together pretty well, but you can sense it's a bit boozy when drinking it. This should appeal to the domestic wine buyer as a top shelf supermarket effort. Good+

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    12/17/2022 6:14:00 PM - Yep. Just OK for me as well...

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    12/17/2022 6:55:00 PM - Oops, my bad. I jumped the gun too quickly and thus modified my response in order not to offend the (this time) innocent. I purchased via Wine Access. Also frequently guilty of glowing copy for a mere OK product...

Red

2015 Wind Gap Wines Syrah Sonoma Coast

more

5/20/2020 - guribh wrote: 88 points

Subject to re-review. Right now, this is puzzling wine: nose reveals some quality underlying fruit. The delivery to the palate has a bit too much of the green components that may come from whole cluster fermentation. I have a case of both this one (first time tasting) and the 2014, which seemed to show better on its first bottle sampling a short while ago. Leads to to believe that this one may show better (or is it wishful
thinking?).

I understand giving up on the label (well, it's gone...) and the genre. I am tempted, given so many other options, but I am not there yet. Hoping for better integration down the road.

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    9/12/2022 6:33:00 PM - Tried again tonight. Slight "fleshing", but still, no swan here.

Red

1999 Château d'Issan

Margaux Red Bordeaux Blend more

4/7/2022 - Winegangster Likes this wine: 91 points

Chateau d'Issan 1999 - My mom's best friend

Ok. Let anyone who has not watched porn throw the first stone at me... no pebble rain ? Sweet, we're between those in the know ! D'Issan 1999 has long been like Bree van der Kamp in Desperate Housewives's season I to me : un-tou-cha-ble. Too Margaux. Too arrogant. Too perfect. And yet, impossible not to imagine a world of kinkiness behind this strict appearance of the most classic Bordeaux blend : 65% of Cabernet felt like a skirt worn past the knee, a white button-up shirt, and a strict headband... but as always in Margaux, add 35% of ripe Merlot, and everything becomes possible. What if Mrs. van der Kamp was secretly wearing Honeybirdette's most daring lace ? It took me 22 years to dare staring at her, it took her 22 years to open her horizons... and here's the story.

D'Issan and I met around the 1999 en primeur campaign, and my first ever Bordeaux purchase was like the smile-blush-run sequence with my mom's best friend. She would never notice, I would have the moment tatooed in my fantasies eternally. Of course, I wish I had dared to make the first step, but hey... there are moment when you're just a teenager, and the case of D'Issan 1999 faded away in my basement and my desires up to that day when I decided to put some order im my cellar.

And here she was ! Marcia Cross in her prime who would have jumped from ABC to Pornhub : seductive, provocative, freed from codes and explict. Same strict outfit, but loose enough to reveal a shameless opulence and a sophisticated deep ruby lingerie. Eye contact. Politically incorrect. The wine swirls beautifully in the glass and reveals waves of smoky vanilla, ripe red fruits, warm pastry and a sensual hint of muskier aromas... it's prodigiously sensual. First kiss. No time for preliminaries. This wine imposes a sense of avid urgency to be drunk and Marcia and I have been waiting for too long : the embrace lives up to the promises but not beyond the long awaited scenario. It's full, it's round, it's mellow and D'Issan shows no restraint in this elegant debauchery, but no excessive efforts to call for a second round of cuddles either. Past a tsunami of torrefied coffee beans, pencil shavings, sweet plums marmelade, blackberries and fresh blackcurrant there remains an impression of soothing voluptuousness and bitter nostalgia. It's a classic aging Margaux, the best of MILF porn for sure... but post coïtum omne animal triste.

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    9/11/2022 5:42:00 AM - You Sir, wrote the most unique and lovely TN I've read on PornHub, ermmm - CellarTracker. Nice narrative. Had this wine last night (with another case to go). It took an hour of aeration in the glass (after decanting) to find its groove , but id certainly did. Cheers!

Red

2013 Andretta Brunello di Montalcino

Sangiovese more

10/29/2021 - hsacks Likes this wine: 92 points

Medium red color. Aromas of red cherries ,leather and French oak spices. Ripe, nicely structured fruit in the mouth with very good depth and length. Firm with goof lift on the palate. While delicious now, this wine could improve wit another year or two of bottle age.

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    6/1/2022 11:27:00 AM - Had the last of my batch last night. Your review is spot on!. Given the QPR, I will likely buy a few of their 2016s as well.

White

2018 Les Vins de Vienne Condrieu La Chambée

Viognier more

1/7/2022 - Eantnay wrote: 82 points

Second try with this wine and still a big disappointment for the price. Once again, the nose does not offer much of anything. I gave it 2 more points than last time because the mouthfeel was a bit richer. This time it was served with baked steelhead trout.

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    4/11/2022 5:41:00 PM - Spot on (we may differ a couple of points on rating, but who cares..). While not a bad wine, this is rather pedestrian for the price.

White

2019 Bedrock Wine Co. Sauvignon Blanc

Sonoma Valley more

11/15/2021 - Rieslingfan wrote: NR

If ever there was a Sauvignon Blanc that had some Riesling sensibilities…

Seriously though, I am a dedicated Sauvignon Blanc skeptic. I have tried so many, from Vatan to Dageneau to Bevan to Cloudy Bay, and I just cannot find a way to love it. The Massican Sauvignon Blanc came close. The Bedrock Steaks of William Holden or whatever came close. This wine comes closer. The fruit is all about citrus and peach (sounds like Riesling), the acidity is front and center (sounds like Riesling). There is a simultaneously chalky and creamy note on the finish, and a hit of herbs that don’t seem like Riesling, but then the mouthwatering acidity kicks in again. Hmm…I could like this. Maybe. I’ll leave a couple of glasses in the bottle to see tomorrow night. Keeping an open mind.

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    4/1/2022 5:24:00 PM - Well conveyed....

Red

1998 Château de la Gardine Châteauneuf-du-Pape

Red Rhone Blend more

2/24/2022 - J.Nimmo wrote: 95 points

I am so Happy about this and maybe the best CDP I've had. Thankful to have 4 of these. The first one was bad..... Thank God I opened #2..... It was so beautiful I almost fell off my Peloton.

Perfectly Enjoyed

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    2/25/2022 4:37:00 AM - Two bottles left downstairs, not far from my wife's Peloton. An excellent pairing suggestion! Cheers.

Red

2014 Wind Gap Wines Syrah Sonoma Coast

more

9/21/2021 - guribh wrote: 85 points

Somewhat of an annual TN: quite disappointed. Not fleshing any, rather "green" still. While I appreciate the integrity of this style, this showing did not resonate with me.

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    9/25/2021 5:07:00 AM - Not exactly, but certainly will try next goaround...I have 7 bottles left, and an open mind. Thanks for the tip.

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    12/29/2021 4:57:00 PM - @CPS: I did tonight. Regrettably, still unimpressed. 6 bottles left. Meh....

    Had a 2017 Fleurie Cru Bojo last night, and prefer it by a wide margin. Of course, YMMV....

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    2/1/2022 5:37:00 PM - @CPSchoeff - followed your suggestion tonight. Made it decent. Still, I find it more of an acquired taste or, if you prefer, an intellectual challenge, rather than an enjoyable experience. That weedy core ids not my thing..(and i am NOT a "hedonistic fruit bomb" kindda guy).

Red

2014 Viña Otano Rioja Gran Reserva

Tempranillo Blend, Tempranillo more

7/22/2021 - dlu Likes this wine: NR

Relatively dark, concentrated, and high-ish ABV. Pleasant, but not that memorable. To be revisited, but also noted as a bit of hype from our source in Seattle.

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    11/16/2021 4:28:00 AM - Thanks for the TN. You may want to add "yet another" to the Seattle source reference. I have found the overhype to be all-too-common and decided to simply avoid ANY "mystery wines" and almost everything else, especially when shipping to the East Coast tacks another $3.50/bottle to the cost.

Red

2018 Bedrock Wine Co. Old Vine Zinfandel

California more

8/30/2021 - JohnMcIlwain Likes this wine: NR

I’ll confess to not remembering the last time I drank a young Zinfandel (maybe Sky Zinfandel a few years ago?), but it’s been a minute. And despite having a few bottles of Bedrock Evangelho, I’ve been remiss in checking in on the Old Wine Zinfandel. But a wonderful bottle of 1987 Ravenswood enjoyed with a colleague and a chance sighting of the 2018 reminded me that I probably could use more dry-farmed California heritage wines at the table. Served at cellar temperature. The robe is a dark ruby, rather than inky purple and translucent to the meniscus. The nose is brambly and red-fruited, with notes of game, spice, and black raspberry seed. The palate is concentrated—but by no means over-extracted or roasted—with a fine thrust of plummy red fruit, wild hedge fruit, and despite it being “entry level,” there’s plenty of deep earth and soil tone to maintain interest. There’s fine acidity and certainly some tannins, which keep things ‘upright.’ And while there’s a bit of discernible wood here (nothing overt, dear reader), this carries itself with aplomb despite the ripeness of the vintage. Terrific with binchotan-grilled lamb loin chops from Dickson's and a sautée of corn and chanterelles; it certainly stood up to the grass-fed lamb, while not overwhelming the corn and wild mushroom. This is a lovely bottle and worth the tariff. And structurally, I can see this gaining complexity and interest with 7-12 years in the cellar. Re-buy? Sure, there’s a plenty of interest here, but I’d certainly advocate for serving at cellar temp and allowing the wine to open up. Also, it bears mentioning, this is a real bargain. Not “cheap,” but an excellent value. Well worth seeking out.

  • Comment posted by guribh:

    9/24/2021 5:30:00 PM - Thanks for a very thorough and well composed review. Cheers!

Loading wine details...
loading

×
×