Community Tasting Note

• dsimmons Likes this wine: 91 points

  December 24, 2012 - No definitive notes on this. Nice wine but less than my expectations.

  4,519 views

2 Comments

• Fantomas commented:

  5/30/15, 9:14 AM - Hi, if it's less than your expectations, why do you still give it a great rating ? These reviews live by subjectivity and a broad range of scores in-line with the individual impression. Please dont take offence but a range of 90 to 100 is not very meaningful.

• dsimmons commented:

  6/1/15, 7:47 PM - Fantomas. No offence taken. The rating of 91 indicated that IMHO the wine was a delicious bottle. The less than expectations comment means that I expected an even more exceptional wine based on the reviews of others and my previous experience with other vintages.
  
  Rating on CT actually are grouped int he range from 87 to 93 and is valuable once you learn how to interpret the info.

Add a Comment