Community Tasting Note

• LeChapeau wrote: flawed

  December 30, 2014 - Another bottle that turned out a little cloudy and below par. Still, good nose and enjoyable, but not the same wine as when tasted before.

  2,465 views

2 Comments

• Vintomas commented:

  1/4/15, 2:38 PM - You have marked two bottles flawed simply because they did not behave like those two bottles you scored 95-96 (which to me seems quite high for a Camus wine, even in a top vintage, since Mazoyères isn't one of their top two vineyards). Isn't this rather a sign of bottle variation? In that case, it would seem to be more correct to give the different bottles varying scores, rather than to stick to the original high scores.

• LeChapeau commented:

  1/4/15, 3:14 PM - You raise a good point. I guess I'm not entirely sure if the bottle is flawed or not. I drink a lot of Camus and have never seen a cloudy one before this so I assumed there was something wrong with it. The other bottles were stellar! The difference in quality level seems much more excessive than bottle variation to me.

Add a Comment