Community Tasting Note

• henrygjeffreys Likes this wine:

  April 24, 2016 - Dark malty nose
  Chewy acidity, intense, long and nutty
  Serious stuff, might need a bit of cheese

  1 person found this helpful 1,777 views

5 Comments

• Homer Holland commented:

  7/5/18, 8:42 PM - Thank you, but please add ratings to your TNs.

• henrygjeffreys commented:

  7/6/18, 7:52 AM - I've never really got to grips with the exactitude of the 100 point system. I tend to use 20 points or best of all 3 ticks but really only for my own use.

• Homer Holland commented:

  7/7/18, 4:59 PM - I find it very easy to use the CT! rating, see: https://www.cellartracker.com/popup/wine_rating_assist.asp
  Try that.

• vijayk416 commented:

  8/8/18, 3:52 AM - Chill out, Homer. The notes are worth more than the points.

• Homer Holland commented:

  8/8/18, 12:38 PM - Don't you worry Vijay, I chill out everyday with one or more nice bottles.
  I saw you are a very early CT!, so my respects to you.
  Also for your very nice cellar.
  However I do like scores, since "I like this wine" or "this is a beautiful wine" etc. are too subjective phrases. A score objectives that a little bit.
  And yes, I do know all the arguments against ratings, so a rating alone does not say it all or even much, especially if you do not know that rater, that wine, beer, whisky etc. lover well.
  Therefore a rating with a TN is the best for me.

Add a Comment