Community Tasting Note

• Esteve63 wrote: 88 points

  December 8, 2017 - this is very weak compared to the bottle we had earlier in the year. I bought a bottle off WTSO in April '17 and it was really good where I agree with the 92/93 ratings, but purchased same wine from Winebid last month and it is very average (very average cab...for the pedigree) a very notable and distinct difference. Suspicious....89 points. Could bottlings be that different? My advice is buyer beware. The fruit and depth is gone. strange. it almost feels counterfeit.

  1 person found this helpful 4,754 views

3 Comments

• Badmonkey commented:

  12/9/17, 5:51 AM - Nice note. I've had the same experience with the last couple bottles as well. It's like they threw their entry level cab in the Reserve bottle. I've never seen such a drop-off in the quality of fruit over a 6 month period. Makes me think something's not right as well.

• markcic commented:

  12/9/17, 6:16 AM - I had the same experience last week and I was really disappointed.

• bugdoced commented:

  12/11/17, 6:44 AM - sounds like your bottles were shut down

Add a Comment