Community Tasting Note

• wgoelen Does not like this wine: flawed

  January 21, 2018 - Oxidized. 5 bottles out of 6 for thr sink. And the sixth was only average ...

  1,858 views

3 Comments

• tarheel17 commented:

  1/27/18, 9:56 PM - I understand your disappointment. Still, shouldn't this be marked "flawed" rather than 50 points?

• wgoelen commented:

  2/3/18, 7:30 AM - You're right, I know, but on the other hand, doesn't it also cover up the massive amount of premoxed bottles from Jadot in that period? I have bought 42 bottles from Jadot 2005 - 2007 - 2008 and I can say that 75% of those were virtually undrinkable with varying degrees of oxidation.
  Anyway, statistically Cellartracker shouldn't take into account extreme ratings.

• tarheel17 commented:

  2/15/18, 9:11 AM - yeah, I gotcha. I hadn't read all your previous notes when I wrote that comment, I def see where you are coming from. Premox is so frustrating!

Add a Comment