Important Update From the Founder Read message >

A trip to Bordeaux's Right Bank (Very long)

Bordeaux, France

Tasted October 22, 2006 - October 30, 2006 by hcampana with 3,169 views

Introduction

A friend of mine, his dad and a friend of his dad embarked in our second trip to Bordeaux right after the harvest. After last year's trip to the Left Bank, we decided to hit the Right Bank in the hope we'd get to taste a lot of the in-barrel 2005s and make up our minds as to whether to buy futures or not. The group had interesting dynamics as the two senior people have a 40 year age advantge (disadvantge?) on me and slightly less on my friend.

We concentrated on the Rigt Bank appellations of Saint Emilion and Pomerol but made an exception and devoted one day to the Left Bank in order to show our new companion the "Grand Estates" of the Left Bank. I arranged for all the visits with plenty of time in advance and was sligtly disappointed that I couldn't book some of them (Cheval Blanc, L'Evangile, Beausejour Duffau & Le Tertre Roteboeuf) due to the harvest related "busyness" that this time of the year brings to all chateaux. As always, I wanted a range of different estates with different philosophie & sizes so we could get a more complete view of the appellations.

The overwhelming majority of estates treated us very, very well and were very generous in their allocation of time and wines. As with everything, some visits were more interesting than others. Some for the esthetics of the estate itself or the surroundings, others for the intimate knowledge we gained, and others for the sheer beauty of our hostesses. The visits hosted by the owners and/or winemakers tended to be more interesting for the relatively "advanced" wine knowledge in our group.

Flight 1 - DAY 1: Dinner at La Tupiña (1 note)

This was our first dinner at Bordeaux and we wanted to hit our favorite: La Tupina. This place is old and old style, but it offers great, simply prepared cuisine with fresh ingredients that take you back to the 18th Century. As it would remain the rest of the trip, I couldn't resist having Fois Gras every time I saw it in a menu. I also had a Duck Magret that was very well prepared.

Red
2003 Reignac France, Bordeaux, Bordeaux Supérieur
90 points
Since my friends had gotten there eralier and had eaten dinner before me, I ordered a bottle of 2003 Reignac to kick off the trip. This is a black purple wine that is completely modern in style. Very ripe and thick with very low acidity and substantial and slightly coarse tannins (although ripe). I like this style of wines, but I also like finesse and aromatic complexity. My friend is definitely more inclined to more complex, less bruising Bordeaux wines as he prioritizes food matching rather than juding a wine on its own. This would start an un-fair characterization of myself as the "Anti-Terroirist" in the group. ;-)

Flight 2 - DAY 2: Troplong Mondot (1 note)

We were greeted by Christine Brachet, who showed us the estate and led us to the tasting of the 2004 Troplong Mondot. Troplong Mondot is greatly situated at the top of the Cote de Saint Emilion in mostly limestone clay soils. Its neighbors are a who's who of Saint Emilion grand names: Pavie, Pavie Macquin, etc. It is one of the biggest estates in St. Emilion (33 hectares). It uses 75% new oak and uses micro bullage as needed. Press wine is only added to the second wine. "2005 is a cellar master's dream".

Red
2004 Château Troplong Mondot France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
89 points
Beautiful ruby color and an elegant nose of red berries with slight hints of coffee, chocolate and cedar. Noticeable acidity and sweet, elegant, non-pbtrusive tannins. This is on the very elegant side of the spectrum and is very approachable already. It lacked more intensity for me to rate it higher, nevertheless it is a very fine wine.

Flight 3 - DAY 2: Pavie (1 note)

Pavie was a highly anticipated visit. We were greeted by Delphine Rigall exactly at 11:30 AM, after we showed up 30 minutes earlier and were sent back like grounded children for showing "too early". Delphine showed us the estate and cellars, which are gorgeously decorated exhibitting great taste and a sense of fashion. Pavie is one of the best terroirs of Saint Emilion with a high sloping south facing vineyard at the top of the Cote de Pavie. It is also a big estate for Saint Emilion (37 hectares). The vineyards average 42 years of age, have varying soil substrates and are managed with great detail. The winery is designed with 100% gravity flow to avoid pumping. There is no fining nor filtering. Delphine talked with border-line religious fervor about Mr. Perse's efforts at the Chateau and about his shy nature.

Mr Perse is planting a big section of Cabernet Sauvignon right behind the Chateau. This will no doubt, create him more enemies (I can already anticipate the "He is destroying the Saint emilion typicity!!!").

Red
2005 Château Pavie France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
90 points
This is a monster. Clearly and without a doubt, this was the most concentrated wine we tasted all week. Very dark purple that was impenetrable. Viscous density that clinged to the wine glass like honey. Very primary aromatics of black fruits, spice and roasted coffeee in the initial nose. With swirling, some interesting nuances that I typically associate with Cabernet Franc emerged: tobacco leaf and mintiness. In the mouth it is massively tannic, full bodied and thick. The quality of the tannin was surprisingly rugged and slightly dry in comparison with every other wine we tatsted from the 2005 vintage (which is characterized by the roundness and velevetiness of the tannins. I know I will like this wine a lot in 15 years, but at this time, the tannin and drying finish are too much for me to rate it higher. My friend did not like it at all and wondered what food could possibly stand up to this "Neardenthal of a wine".

Flight 4 - DAY 2: Lunch at Grand Barrail (1 note)

This hotel/spa/restaurant is beautiful. It is mid way between Saint Emilion and Libourne. We had a great lunch in the almost empty , well appointed restaurant. I started with a chestnut soup with an immersed ravioli filled with fois gras and black truffle. Then I had a great slow baked wild boar with hazelnuts and finished with a tartine of dehydrated green apple with caramel. Recommneded.

Red
1998 Château Grand Mayne France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
93 points
This is a wine I loved. The incredible complex nose of dark chocolate, ground coffee and cedar is identical to the 1998 Clos de l'Oratoire I recently had (and loved!). Low acid, full to medium bodied, greatly accessible and a great match for food. Highly recommended.

Flight 5 - DAY 2: Pavie Macquin (6 notes)

We were greeted by the enthusiastic, attractive Sarah Wright. She is a transplanted Irish young woman that came to Bordeaux to see the world. Whilst in love with wines, her real allegiance continues to be beer. While in the vineyards, we met Nicolas Thienpont, who was polite, funny and welcoming. Pavie Macquin has 14 hectares of vines on top of a hill with a thick limestone ground. The vineyards are planted with 70% merlot, 25% Cabernet Franc and 5% Cabernet Sauvignon. They are ripping most of the Cabernet Sauvignon out because it is in a lot with clay soil and bad exposure, so it hardly ever ripens. Pavie Macquin is made by Stephan Derencourt. This is where Stephan got his start. They use whole berry fermentation and wild yeasts. They use 80% new oak barrels. An interesting thing was that the 2005 malolactic fermentation was not finished until June! They have no clue why it took so long.

This was the most energetic, fun visit we had no doubt because of Sarah's own enthusiasm.

Red
2002 Château Larcis Ducasse France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
86 points
Red fruits and some herbaceous notes in the nose of this relatively light, tannic wine made with 78% Merlot and 22% Cabernet Franc. This was shown as a start of an evolutionary process for this estate and to try and showcase the man-made effect of the new wine making team led by Nicolas Thienpont and Stephan Derenoncourt.
Red
2003 Château Bellevue St. Émilion Grand Cru France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
91 points
80% Merlot and 20% Cabernet Franc. In the nose, more of a black fruit profile. This is obviously dominated by its very ripe Merlot component, no Cab Franc characteristics were perceptible. Fat, juicy and jammy, it has very round but obvious tannins and a long and slightly hot finish.
Red
2004 Château Larcis Ducasse France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
92 points
A different kind of wine when compared to the 2003 Bellevue. The latter is a ripe, fruity and obvious wine. The 2004 Larcis Ducasse is more refined and complex. Very spicy nose of black fruits that is a lot more interesting than the 2003 Bellevue's. Full to medium bodied with nice ripe tannin in this rather understated, elegant wine.
Red
2004 Château Bellevue St. Émilion Grand Cru France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
88 points
Darker than the 2004 Larcis Ducasse. Deep nose of roasted coffee, black fruits and a hint of horse sweat. Medium to full bodied, smooth and less powerful than its 2003 sibling.
Red
2004 Château Pavie Macquin France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
87 points
Spicy, minerally nose. Elegant and fruity with some mint and a whiff of vanilla. Sharper acidity than all previous wines and lacking fruit in the mid palate to rate higher with me. A slight dissapointment.
Red
2005 Château Pavie Macquin France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
92 points
Darkest color of all wines tasted at this winery. This wine has an incredibly complex nose of red fruits, mint and tobacco leaf. Viscous and full to medium bodied, it has velvety tannins and a nice acidity. Pavie Macquin is more elegant and less "in your face" than Rolland wines such as Reignac or Pavie.

Flight 6 - DAY 2: Dinner and tasting at the hotel (3 notes)

We stayed at the hotel tonight, but first packed up some goodies at a Libourne supermarket: fois gras, hams, chorizo and jamon serrano as well as several cheeses.

Red
2000 Château Ducru-Beaucaillou Croix de Beaucaillou France, Bordeaux, Médoc, St. Julien
88 points
Had at the hotel with an assortment of goodies (Jamon serrano, fois gras, ham, chorizo, baguettes and cheeses) we bought at a Libourne supermarket. Relatively complex nose in this finesse style wine made with obviously ripe fruit. Very nice indeed.
Red
2003 Château Fombrauge France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
88 points
A cmpletely different wine than the la Croix de Beacaillou. This is defintiely in the modern camp. Very ripe fruit, very concentrated, thick with less aromatic complexity and more immediate palate gratification despite the obvious tannin. I like it, but reinforces my reputation as an "anti terroirist".
White - Sweet/Dessert
1996 Château Filhot France, Bordeaux, Sauternais, Sauternes
90 points
Very nice Sauternes that muts contain relatively high Sauvignon Blanc content given its citrusy character. Good acidity, good extract. Went great with the bloc de fois gras.

Flight 7 - DAY 3: Latour (4 notes)

This was our return to Latour after last year's visit. Latour is an impressive operation that is at the cutting edge of tchnology and good taste. To me, it is the most aesthetically pleasing chateau in Bordeaux. It is a thrill to visit it. The 2004 line up was dissapointingly different from last year, but the 1999 was re-assuringly pleasant. We saw Mr.Engerer run by the reception to host some shippers.

Red
2004 Pauillac de Latour France, Bordeaux, Médoc, Pauillac
80 points
This is one of the most puzzling evolutions in wines I have witnessed in a single year. Last year we tasted through the stable of the then 2004 barrel sample Latours and they seemed open, accesible, fruity and very approachable. One lyear later these wines are hard, closed, tannic and lacking fruit. Subdued nose of red fruits with no complexity. Un resolved and obvious tannin in this somewhat fruitless medium bodied wine. Very hard and un-elegant. I confirmed this wine has a subtstantial amount of press wine. Very dissapointing, especially in light of last year's performance.
Red
2004 Les Forts de Latour France, Bordeaux, Médoc, Pauillac
86 points
Much better than the 2004 Pauillac, but also less good than last year. In the nose: noticeable new oak, some cedar, wet loamy earth and faint cassis. Deeper than the Pauillac but very closed and tannic.
Red
2004 Château Latour Grand Vin France, Bordeaux, Médoc, Pauillac
88 points
This has been bottled for 3 months. Slightly frutier than its two siblings with a more revealing and elegant nose of subdued vanilla and slight cedar. In the mouth, close and un-forgiving, with too much tannin and lacking fruit in the mid palate.
Red
1999 Château Latour Grand Vin France, Bordeaux, Médoc, Pauillac
91 points
Much better than the 2004s. Like with all its siblings, in the ruby side of the color spectrum. Beautiful nose that is evolved and complex with ahint of barnyard that is not offensive. In the mouth, it disspaoints a little with a medium body and noticeable tannins. Not a blockbuster Latour and lacking a little fruit, this needs time to soften in the mouth and develop more aromatic complexity.

Flight 8 - DAY 3: Lunch at Lion d'Or (1 note)

Lion d'Or is La Tupina of the Medoc. Old style, no nonsense cooking of great south western dishes. We had an incredible turbot filet and a great dessert. We talked to the chef owner (Mr. Barbier) who is fluent in Spanish and is a real character (moody, proud and very French!).

Red
1999 Château du Tertre France, Bordeaux, Médoc, Margaux
87 points
Had this at the Lion d'Or in Arcins. A gentleman in the next table ordered the stinkiest (attractive!) dish I'd smelled in my life: Hare slow cooked in a reduction of its own blood. Thie picked my interest so much that I ordered a very similar dish in Paris the following week.

This is a simple, eleganttly textured, pleasant, very good wine to accompany food. It is not a blockbuster by any means.

Flight 9 - DAY 3: Branaire Ducru (2 notes)

This was a very interesting visit. We were greeted and hosted by the affable Jean Dominique Videau, who despite our insistence to try and find out why there has been a surge in quality since his taking over of the estate in 2002, he denied taking credit for it. Branaire is a quintessential Saint Julien: elegant, lightly extractedbut flavorful and light on its feet. They do not use pigeage for fear of over estraction and only use 50-60% new oak. They vinify in concrete vats.

Red
2003 Château Branaire-Ducru France, Bordeaux, Médoc, St. Julien
92 points
Branaire is a wine of elegance and finesse, not sheer power and opulence. Even in this hot, jammy vintage it stays true to its calling. Medium intensity color clearly in the purple side of the color spectrum. Made from a very low yield of 28 hectoliters per hectare. In the nose, plums and red fruits (no black currant here despite the high Cabernet sauvignon content). Medium to full bodied, not at all heavy. Very elegant and unobtrussive with surprising acidity for this vintage.
Red
2005 Château Branaire-Ducru France, Bordeaux, Médoc, St. Julien
91 points
Very beautiful purple color. Vanilla, licorice, flowers and plums fill the very beautiful nose. Medium to full bodied, brighter acidity and slightly coarser tannins than its younger sibling.

Flight 10 - DAY 3: Margaux (1 note)

We were hosted by the gorgeous, model-like Tina Bizzard who could easily win Miss Universe should she apply. Overall, Chateau Margaux was a disspaointment facilities-wise. It is old tech, somewhat un-tidy and a bit disorganized. They must have great terroir to make up for what seems to be a cost savings neglect. They choose to spend their money in public raelations instead of the winery. The wines are nevertheless incredibly good.

Red
2001 Château Margaux France, Bordeaux, Médoc, Margaux
92 points
Very intersting and complex nose of violets, balck currant and cedar. Medium bodied with its oak completely assimilated and a very elegant lightness. I really liked this wine for its approachabilty and aromatic complexity. The palate falls short of the nose on this wine. If I like this wine, can I be an anti-terroirist? ;-)

Flight 11 - DAY 3: Dinner at Cordeillan Bages (2 notes)

This is a great restaurant that consistently provides the 5 hour dinner experience with numerous amuse bouches and great modern cooking. It is surprising that they rely on such a young service staff with a lot of turnover. It may have to do with the relatively low volume of visitors in big parts of the year. Thanks to Gusbo for his immense generosity for bringig this wine all the way from Mexico and sharing it with us.

We started off with a Duval Leroy rosé champagne. My first plate wa s ahot seared fois gras lobe with peach in a vintage port reduction. This was the best fois gras I had all trip. It was flavorful, tender and the big rock grain salt that was lightly sprinkled over it exponentiated the flavor. It was agreat match with the Sauternes. I followed with a filet of Bar (A type of sea bass) in a cacao sauce. Wonderful. Then it was the turn of slow braised Mister Reyes' Lamb in 3 different presentations with a couscous side. Then we followed with cheeses (of which the Saint Nectaire proved to be the most outstandingly mature). Finally, I ended with a deconstructed Lemon tart. This was the most complete and long dinner experience we had and with the added magic of a bottle of Petrus, it was indeed a complete evening.

White - Sweet/Dessert
1996 Cru Barréjats France, Bordeaux, Sauternais, Sauternes
95 points
What a great dessert wine this is! Last year we were impressed with it and this year confirmed how fantastic it still is. Deep golden color and a viscous appearance. With an aromatic profile of pure Semillon (bee honey, creme brulee), the intensity in bouquet, taste and acidity is remarkable. Very full bodied, deeply botrytised, this has the concentartion of a Tokaji Eszencia or a Kracher high numbered Trockenbeerenauslese from a gret year, not that of an un known Barsac. I would love to put up this wine blind with all other Sauternais wines of 1996. I'd be surprised if it didn't finish #1 or #2 (even above d'Yquem!).
Red
1993 Pétrus France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Pomerol
94 points
This wine was stressful from the get go. My friend brought it from his distant cellar in NW Mexico so we could do a follow up to the 1994 Le Pin I brought last year. It made it intact in his checked luggage. Upon arrival to Cordeillan Bages, we gave it to the Sommelier for decanting. After a Champagne appetizer, the young Mexico-born sommelier whispered something into Gusbo's ear and his face disfigured in shock. He was told the wine was slightly corked! We ordered the Sommelier to serve a glass so we could taste it ourselves. There was no hint of TCA whatsoever. We dismissed the Sommelier's advice and asked for it to be served. The cork was destroyed upon opening despite the lack of saturation in it. After some time in the glass I finally got a very slight hint of chlorine that dissppeared as soon as I sirled the glass a little. Gusbo never got any hint of TCA.

The wine was truly memorable. A deep ruby color with some garnet in the rim, the wine was open, approachable and clearly in the midst of its premium drinking window. The nose was amazingly pleasurable and complex. Full of dark chocolate, black fruits and minerality. It was hard to stop smelling this wine. In the palate the texture was soft, tannins were completely melted and the flavor saturation was remarkable. Wines in this price range tend to dissapoint because expectations get too high. This was not the case with this beauty of a wine.

A bottle of Petrus is more than just another bottle of wine. It is an event in and of itself. Kind of like the SuperBowl. it doesn't matter what teams play or how good the game is, it is the Super Bowl and deserves to be treated as such. The romanticism and "specialness" of the bottle may have gotten it an extra point in my score.

Flight 12 - DAY 4: Clos Fourtet (1 note)

This estate is in the middle of Saint Emilion, a mere 30 yards from the church. We were hosted by Veronique Ballu, the estate manager's wife. This was a very interesting visit that is highly recommended because of the amazing under ground quarries dug out from underneath the estate. The views down there are amazing! And so is the 2005!

Red
2005 Clos Fourtet France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
92 points
76% Merlot, 12% Cab Franc and 12% Cabernet Sauvignon. Made with yield of 35 HL/Ha. Very dense purple color and a ripe nose of black fruits and lead pencil. Very round and full bodied in the mouth. With some very nice acidity and very finely grained tannins. This is a perfect marriage between clacissism and modern technlogy. A definitive winner.

Flight 13 - DAY 4: Canon La Gaffeliere (4 notes)

Comte Neipperg is one of my favorite producers. Clos de l'Oratoire and Canon La Gaffeliere are long time favorites of mine. They use whole berry fermentation and pigeage and vinify with natural yeasts. The enthusiastic and knoledgeable Magali Malet hosted us and offered a very generous tasting of all of Comte Neipperg's 2005 wines. The 2005 La Mondotte was by far my favorite 2005 of the trip.

Red
2005 Château d'Aiguilhe France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Castillon Côtes de Bordeaux
90 points
Incredible black purple color (I thought it was La Mondotte!). Jammy, ripe, caramelized fruits in the very exotic nose. Medium to full bodied, tannic and needing time to resolve the tannins.
Red
2005 Clos de l'Oratoire France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
91 points
More in the ruby spectrum. Attractive nose of red fruits. Medium bodied, finer and softer than the 2005 Aiguilhe. There is more finesse and elegance here, although it lacks the concentration of the 1998.
Red
2005 Château Canon-la-Gaffelière France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
92 points
55% Merlot, 35% Cabernet Franc and 10% Cabernet Sauvignon. Spicier and more mineral than the previous two wines. Full of fruit, elegant and balanced with remarkable concentration and very fine, silky tannins. A winner.
Red
2005 La Mondotte France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
96 points
80% Merlot and 20% Cabernet Franc from a 2 hectare plot. Black ruby with a gourgeous nose of very ripe black fruits, vanilla and spice. This wine is boldly elegant with a blockbuster flavor profile of fruit and complexity. This could have been a Pride Reserve Claret from an elegant year. I absolutely love this wine. Too bad the price tag may prevent me from buying some.
1 person found this helpful Comment

Flight 14 - DAY 4: Lunch at Hostellerie du Plaisance (1 note)

This is a great very traditional restaurant that is the opposite to the nouvelle style of Cordeillan Bages. My main plate was a slow cooked pork loin that was utterly delicious. A definite must when in Saint Emilion.

Red
1998 Château Monbousquet France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
94 points
Dining at Gerard Perse's restaurant in the heart of downtown Saint Emilion made it seem appropriate to drink a favorite of mine: the 1998 Monbosquet. What a great wine this is. Bull blood color and amazing aromatics of dark chocolte and black fruits that is not disimilar to the nose in last night's 1993 Petrus. Deeply flavored, full in body and an unctuous thick texture are simply amazing. What a great wine this is, and it's only getting better every year.

Flight 15 - DAY 4: Figeac (1 note)

We met the owner of Chateau Figeac during our visit (the only non individual visit we had). We were very dissapointed with the state of the Chateau, its facilities and the wines. Despite Mr. Mannoncourt's pretentious of having a wine superior to Cheval Blanc, what's in the glass destroys that notion. In other hands, this estate could really shine.

Red
1996 Château Figeac France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
80 points
After seeing the low tech, un clean and disorderly state of this chateau's facilities, I am not surprised this wine was disspointing. Thin ruby color with too much garnet for its age. The nose is devoid of fruit and is dominated by hot stones and a hint of brett. Medium to light bodied, acidic and short.

Flight 16 - DAY 4: Dinner at L'Envers du Decor (1 note)

This restaurant is touted as a wine bar but it is defintely NOT a wine bar but rather a typical restaurant. The wine list is unimpresive and the food is acceptable.

Red
2004 Château de Reignac Balthus France, Bordeaux, Bordeaux Supérieur
87 points
This is the Barossa in a Bordeaux bottle. Full bodied monster with a New World nose of melted butter and vanilla. Incredibly tannic and hard to drink with food, although crammed with fruit and extract. This choice does not enhance my reputation as an anti terroirist! This is one of the only 2 bottles of wine we did not finish all trip (the other was a non vintage, overly acidic and tannic Languedoc called Deux Annes -Two donkeys-).

Flight 17 - DAY 5: Vieux Chateau Certan (2 notes)

We were greeted by Mr. Thienpont's asistant, who showed us the estate and cellars. We briefly mey Mr. Thienpont but he was very busy. People don't realize these Pomerol estates are managed by the owner wne 2-3 employees. that is it! We were grateful to be hosted at these places with really low production volumes and little marketing/PR infraestructure. the estate is a mere 14 hectares (about the size of its neighbor Petrus).

Red
1999 Vieux Château Certan France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Pomerol
89 points
Beautiful ruby color with some garnet hues. Fruity nose of red fruits (framboise?) and spice. Medium bodied, elegant and long with juicy acidity. A wine of finesse.
Red
1996 Vieux Château Certan France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Pomerol
90 points
More evolved ruby than the 1999. more of a cabernet nose of black currant and spice. With swirling, the Merlot comes to the forefront with dark chocolate. More evolved nose and slightly more tannic than 1999, medium bodied and showing nice acidity.

Flight 18 - DAY 5: Lunch at Chez Servais (1 note)

This is a great little restaurant in the heart of Libourne. The food is very good (especially the fish dishes). We were served by Umma Thurman's slightly heavier twin ;-) I think I had a turbot (sole) dish.

Red
2001 La Fleur de Quinault France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion
88 points
Elegant, fruity, medium bodied and pleasant. Very good food wine.

Flight 19 - DAY 5: La Conseillante (1 note)

La Conseillante is one of the the quintessentially elegant wines of Pomerol. It has less than 12 hectares under vines and is a typical blend of 80% of Merlot and 20% of Cebernet Franc. It is polanted with a density of 6,000 vines per hectare and has yields between 35 and 45 hectoliters per hectare. We were hosted by their cellar master. this was the purest expression of fruit we tasted among the 2005s.

Red
2005 Château La Conseillante France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Pomerol
93 points
What a beautiful clear purple color. Jammy nose of pure red fruit extract crammed with raspberry, strawberry and red currant. Medium bodied, elegant and displying some of the finest, ripest tannin we encountered this trip, this is an essence of the vine type of wine.

Flight 20 - DAY 5: Le Bon Pasteur (2 notes)

This was another great visit. we were hosted by the extrovert Benoit Prevott, who is the Technical Director at Chateau le Bon pasteur and is also the enologist of all of Michel Rolland's estates in Argentina. He speaks fluent Spanish. Michel Rolland is a controversial figure (I still don't know why) whose wines are amasingly good. Le Bon Pasteur is only 7 hectares and sits at the borer between Pomerol and Lalande de Pomerol. They are currently experimenting with "integral vinification" (i.e. vinifying the entire wine directly in new 225 liter oak barrels for better integration and roundness).

White
2005 Château La Grande Clotte Blanc France, Bordeaux
88 points
A surprising white from Michel Rolland. Allegedly the only white wine produced in Pomerol. A surprising mix of 30% Sauvignon Blanc, 30% Sauvignon Gris, 25% Semillon and 15% Muscadelle. Vinified entirely in a 225 liter barrique made with 100% new oak. Very tropical nose of pineapple. In the mouth it shows a surprising acidity and citrusy flavor that does not correspond to the aromatic impression. Medium to full bodied and a very interesting slightly tart finish.
Red
2005 Château Le Bon Pasteur France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Pomerol
93 points
Made from a yield of 38 HL/ha, which is low when you take into account that the density of planted vines is a relatively low 6,500 vines per hectare (vs. 10,000 in many other estates). Black purple and densely colored. Nose of jammy, caramelized black fruits and some spices. After Pavie and La Mondotte, this is the most concentrated 2005 we tasted all trip. Thick and unctuous, this is a full bodied, flamboyantly flavored wine that is full of ripe fruit. Clearly in the modernist camp and opposite the delicate, finesse-styled 2005 la Conseillante. A winner.

Flight 21 - DAY 5: Dinner at 22 Rue Guadet (1 note)

This restaurant was an un-planned surprise. The food was good and the wine list much better than at L'Enver du Decors. It had several gems at very good prices (including the 2001 Pavie).

Red
1998 Château Pavie Macquin France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
89 points
First bottle opened was allegedly corked. Neither Gusbo, nor I could find any hint of TCA in the first bottle that was opened for us. On to the second bottle served to us. This is a nose wine. Complex aromas of dark chocolate and spice, with a nice texture and very concentrated flavors. The only let down was an overly acidic finish. This excess acidity makes the wine un-balanced and ruins an otherwise great aromatic experience. I'd give it 93 points on aromatics and 85 on the palate and finish.

Flight 22 - DAY 6: L'Eglise Clinet (5 notes)

We were hosted by the owner-enologist-salesman-PR man Dennis Durantou. I had never experienced a more rushed visit than this. Mr. Durantou was in a great hurry and rushed us through the visit and tasting in less than 18 minutes.

Red
2005 Château La Chenade France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Lalande de Pomerol
86 points
Spicy nose of red fruits. Medium bodied with slightly rough tannin and a drying finish.
Red
2005 Château les Cruzelles France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Lalande de Pomerol
85 points
Similarly fruity nose with some (but less) spice than the 2005 La Chenade. Medium to full bodied, slightly rustic and dry.
Red
2005 Château Amelisse France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion
88 points
A notch up in quality from the previous two. More serious nose of dark chocolate and some spice. Darkest color so far. A little closed.
Red
2005 La Petite Eglise France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Pomerol
89 points
Sweeter nose of ripe fruit and vanilla. Medium bodied with velvety tannin. Best in the Durantou line up so far.
Red
2005 Château L'Eglise-Clinet France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Pomerol
92 points
Loads of fruit in this dark, ripe, serious wine with some minerality. Medium to full bodied, with its tannins still un resolved (80% new oak was used). This wine has lots of concentration and a long, flavorful finish. Nevertheless, it fell a little short of my expectations given the praise it has received from most critics.

Flight 23 - DAY 6: Lunch at Chez Servais (1 note)

We returned to this restaurant to retaste the remarkable home made fois gras terrine. Mr. Durantou from L'Eglise Clinet was also there. We thought of paying his bill to thank him for receiving us but decided not to due to the very rushed nature of the visit.

Red
2003 Château Bellegrave (Pomerol) France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Pomerol
87 points
Better than I expected from a 2003 Pomerol without a great terroir. Pleasant and medium bodied. It did not dissapoint.

Flight 24 - DAY 6: Gazin (2 notes)

This was another entertaing visit. We were greeted by the owner Nicolas de Bailliencourt. Gazin sits in agreat terroir and is a 2 sided neighbor of Petrus. About 4 hectares of gazin vienyards were sold to Petrus 30 years ago, which makes him very proud. Gazin is low tech with concrete vats and pumping. The owner is incredibly extroverted, speaks perfect English and is a great conversationist. We were let in on some local owner gossip as well as candid opinions on several critics. It is amazing that Gazin doesn't produce better wines with its privileged terroir.

Red
2005 Château Gazin Pomerol France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Pomerol
90 points
Opaque, purple color. Fruit filled nose with some minerals. Medium bodied and with lower acidity than most other 2005s we tasted. Very fine tannin, with its 50% new oak completely assimilated, tis wine lacked a bit of palate coverage to rate higher.
Red
2004 Château Gazin Pomerol France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Pomerol
88 points
Bull blood color that is less saturated than the 2005's. In the nose, chocolate , vanilla and cedar. Medium bodied with low acidity. I liked this wine.

Flight 25 - DAY 6: Clinet (3 notes)

This was another very interesting visit. We were hosted by the new 26 year old winemaker, who outdid himself to please us. I am very greatful for his generosity and enthusiasm.

Red
2004 Château Clinet France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Pomerol
88 points
Less concentrated color than the 2005 samples we tasted. Chocolate and coffee in the nose. Lacking a bit of fruit but elegant and usave in the mouth. Tannins are in check and a fine acidity lingers in the palate. This wine will be lovely in 2-4 more years.
Red
2005 Château Clinet France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Pomerol
91 points
This is the only winery that allowed us to taste directly from cask.

2005 Merlot in Demtoisse lightly toasted barrique. Gorgeous, fruit crammed nose that reminds me of top napa merlots. Full bodied with noticeable tannin and nice acidity. Good mid palate coverage. A hint of roasted coffee emerges with time. Great wine. My favorite sample.

2005 Merlot in Demtoisse medium toasted barrique. Less fruity than previous sample, but very nicely textured. The higher tosting becomes evident with a roasted mocha aroma. Higher tannin than barrel sample #1 with slightly coarser texture.

2005 Merlot in Ermitage medium light toasting. Most beautiful nose of deep dark fruit and a hint of ground coffee. Full to medium bodied with more tannin than other two samples and a slightly hollower mid palate.

It is a lot harder to judge un blended, un finished wines as it is harder to encounter complexity that blending different lots give.
Red
2006 Château Clinet France, Bordeaux, Libournais, Pomerol
We were able to taste a Cabernet and Merlot sample directly from vat and before malolactic. These are obiously un-finished wines that show the roughness of pre malolactic state. Interesting, but mostly un pleasant. Not rated.

Flight 26 - DAY 7: Lunch at Violon d'Ingress (Paris) (1 note)

This is a modern looking restaurant near the Eiffel Tower with very good food and a lackluster wine list. We had a very good lunch. My hare in a reduction of its own blood was superbly stinky.

Red
1996 Château Haut-Marbuzet France, Bordeaux, Médoc, St. Estèphe
89 points
Beautiful bull blood color. Mature aromatics with cedar and hot stones. It didn't show Saint Estephe's typical spiciness but it was nevertheless very enjoyable.

Flight 27 - DAY 7: Dinner at Lavinia (Paris) (3 notes)

Lavinia is without question, the best wine shop in the world. It is huge, beautiful and high quality. The only complaint I have is the very poor service at the top floor restaurant. It is nearly impossible to get a waiter to come to the table as it could interrupt their socializing. we had an assortment of cold cust, cheeses and fois gras.

Red
2001 Château Lucia France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
90 points
This sealed my reputation as an anti terroirist with Gusbo. "This wine could have been made anywhere in the world". Black purple, concentrated and made from very ripe fruit. New worldish and not displaying the aromatic complexity of other Bordeaux wines. Tannin is present and grainy, but finish is long and fruity.
White - Sweet/Dessert
1997 Domaine Philippe Delesvaux Coteaux du Layon Sélection de Grains Nobles France, Loire Valley, Anjou-Saumur, Coteaux du Layon
95 points
What a great producer of dessert wines Delesvaux is. There is little vintage variation in the prodiction of these elixirs of pleasure. The wine is racy, with substantial botrytis, full bodied and sharp acidity to counterbalance the substantial concentration.
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
1996 Roberto Voerzio Barolo Brunate Italy, Piedmont, Langhe, Barolo
91 points
Very closed and reticent. It took forever for the nitrogen smell to blow off. The wine is tight and unforgiving. Very unlike the 1998 Scavino Carobric I had a few weeks ago. It has obvious condentration of fruit and an attractive textural sensation, but the nose just doesn't give up anything.

Flight 28 - DAY 8: Lunch at the Four Seasons George V (Paris) (2 notes)

This is the ultimate luxury restaurant. Service is impeccable, the fod is great and the wine list enormous. The only complaint is that we were slightly rushed to orderand te out of there. I had 3 plates of great food and a Partagas Series D number 4 Cuban robusto cigar to finsh in style.

Red
2001 Château Troplong Mondot France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
91 points
At George V during lunch. Beautiful wine that is on the elegant side. More mature nose of mocha infused black berries and a pretty medium bodied texture. This wine has very fine tannins but is very approachable. Less acidity than in the 2001 Clos Fourtet we had alongside it.
Red
2001 Clos Fourtet France, Bordeaux, Libournais, St. Émilion Grand Cru
91 points
At the Four Seasons George V for Lunch. This wine is more modern and lively than the 2001 Troplong Mondot we had alongside it, but lacks the aromatic complexity of the Troplong. Juicy, fruit-filled and young, it requires a few years to develop more interesting aromatics. The tannin was velvety and fine and the finish was juicy from its higher acidity. Went very well with our food.

Flight 29 - DAY 9: Dinner at Lavinia (Paris) (1 note)

I went back for more fois gras and dessert wines!

White - Sweet/Dessert
1996 Domaine Philippe Delesvaux Coteaux du Layon Sélection de Grains Nobles France, Loire Valley, Anjou-Saumur, Coteaux du Layon
93 points
Had it with a Fois Gras and a cheese platter at Lavinia. Great Chenin Blanc, although a notch behind the 1997's great concentration. Apricots and beehive in the nose and a full bodied, unctuous body with very shar acidity.

Flight 30 - DAY 10: Lunch at L'Epi Dupin (Paris) (0 notes)

Last year I had a so-so experience here and decided to come back. What a diofference ayear makes. I got there at a less crowded hour, so it was more comfortable and less noisy. The food was great and the chocolate fondant dessert was out of this world. I drank a half bottle of non-descript Croze Hermitage from Pallard.

Closing

This was a great trip. We had a great time, ate like kings, drank great wines and got rid of a lot of stress by forgetting the woirld we came from foir a few days. Some highlights:

BEST DINING EXPERIENCE: Cordeillan Bages (Pauillac)
BEST FOOD: Hostellerie du Plasaince (Saint Emilion) & Four Seasons George V
BEST WINE EXPERIENCE: 1993 Petrus
BEST WINES: 1st 2005 La Mondotte & 2nd 1998 Monbousquet
BEST SCENERY: The underground caves at Clos Fourtet and the Monolithic Chucrch in Saint Emilion.
BEST SIGHT: Looking at the beautiful Tina Bizzard from Chateau Margaux.
BEST WINERY VISITS: Pavie Macquin (thanks Sarah!), Le Bon Pasteur & Clinet.
MOST DISAPPOINTING WINES: The entire 2004 Chateau Latour lineup, 1996 Figeac, 1998 Pavie Macquin.
MOST PUZZLING QUESTION OF THE TRIP: Gusbo and I came back with a question unanswered: Why in the world are so many chateaux going back to wooden vats when they are more expensive than stainless steel???? For the life of me I cannot think of a good reason to do this, but yet they are putting their money where their mouth is, so this cannot be a false sense of tradition to save a buck. Can someone shed some light on this???
FALSEST ALLEGATION: That I am 100% anti terroririst (I am only 90% anti terrori!).

SOME THOUGHTS ON THE 2005 VINTAGE
Most of the wines we tasted have gorgeous fruit concentrations and juicy acidity. The overall finesse and roundness in the tannins was almost universal (excpet for the 2005 Pavie). With time they should become great wines, but they are not as impressive and flamboyant to tatse this young as have been other riper vintages. Because I have limited experience tasting barrrel samples, I was a little underwhlemed with many of the wines in light of the critic's very high initial barrel scores. I am nevertheless happy I bought some 2005s.

SOME THOUGHTS ON THE 2001s AND 2004s
These wines have been surprisingly approachable and good. They may be one of the last chances to buy some of the great producers at decent prices.

© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close