Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Cabernet Blend Comparison

My Home

Tasted December 26, 2014 by djlevin with 521 views

Introduction

Selected one each Bordeaux, Napa and Tuscan Cabernet Sauvignon blend to pair with dinner this evening. Invited friends over for a meal of braised beef shortribs, home-made mac & cheese with gruyere & cheddar sauce and succotash. All the wines paired extremely well with the meal served.

The Le Petit Haut Lafitte was the standout of the night. Exteremely well-balanced, with good structure and a very pretty, refined character that spoke of a well made wine. Kind of a mix between Old and New World with a fruit-forward palate.

The surprise of the night was the '93 Beringer. Wow, what a great aged Napa Cab. Just an excellent bottle-aged wine. This wine was made to age well and actually has a few years left in it, if anyone has this in their cellar... it isn't dead yet!

Flight 1 - Cabernet Sauvignon Blends (4 notes)

All great choices and enjoyed by all!

Red
1993 Beringer Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Private Reserve USA, California, Napa Valley
93 points
After one hour decant. The most surprising wine of the night. At 21 years old this bottle was singing! The nose showed plum, blackberry, black cherry, graphite and earth. The freshness of fruit on the palate was nothing short of amazing for a '93. The palate followed the nose with beautiful fruit. The structure was spectacular for an aged wine, with medium-high tannins, good acidity and well-integrated alcohol. Nice mid-palate of tobacco that added complexity, but the mouth-feel is what got me. The balance was good and the tannins had a great velvetty texture that filled the mouth. It needed more layering of flavors and a stronger finish to move in to the exceptional category though. This wine actually has a few more years under its belt! This is my first Napa cab sauv that has stood-up well to 20 years of bottle aging.
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
2009 Château Smith Haut Lafitte Le Petit France, Bordeaux, Graves, Pessac-Léognan
94 points
After one hour decant. The spectacular wine of the evening. This wine was exteremely well-balanced, with a refined, classically old world character... while still being fruit forward. The wine shows great QPR and is a substantial effort for a second label. Plum, blackberry, creme brulee, tobacco and earth on the nose. The palate follows the nose. The wine is very accessible for only fiive years in the bottle. I would suggest your prime drinking window to be 2016-2018. I don't believe this wine will age successfully beyond that. Everyone at the dinner agreed this was the best wine of the evening. With medium-high tannins and strong acidity the structure was spot-on. The alcohol was noticeable, but did not dominate. This contributed to a superb pairing with braised short ribs. This is the best value I have tasted from Bordeaux in a long time.
Red
2006 Cain Vineyard & Winery Cain Five USA, California, Napa Valley, Spring Mountain District
90 points
After 30 min. decant. Popped this half bottle looking to see how close this wine is to its drinking window. This needs another few more years. The nose is full of plum and rich red tomato. The palate is fruit forward with plum and blackberry moving to a hint of tomato. Nice spicey character leaning towards cinammon and clove. Medium high tannins with very high acidity. Slightly hot and not integrated enough yet to be well balanced. Starting to move towards a soft mouth-feel. I enjoyed this now, but believe it will be much better when I pop the next bottle in a couple of years.
Red
2007 Tenuta Monteti Caburnio Toscana IGT Italy, Tuscany, Toscana IGT
89 points
After 60 min. decant. Improved with more time in the glass. Fruit on the nose was of cherry and plum with vanilla and herbal mint. The nose was too hot to really enjoy. The palate followed the nose. Medium-high tannins and high acidity for good structure, but not well balanced. The alcohol was very noticeable. The other characteristics were a little out of kilter. I will save the next bottle for a couple of years, hoping it will come together.
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close