Important Update From the Founder Read message >

2005 Botrytis Forum - NEW YORK

downtown

Tasted February 20, 2007 by Mlermontov with 1,157 views

Introduction

first i must say a HUGE thanks to James Wright and Jodi Stern for inviting me and letting me in... it was trully an honor to be present at his tasting. Akos Forczek who put together this traveling forum (once a year - each time in a diff city) to promote the wines influenced by botrytis did an amazing job recruting some of the best in the game! Can one imagine meeting meeting Egon Mueller, Alexandre De Lur Saluces, Grehard Kracher and Istvan Szepsy in one room? well there they were... with wine! :) an amazing event indeed!

Flight 1 - Sauternes (2 notes)

Unlike many other sweet wines, Sauternes stops fermenting on its own, reaching the 13.5-14% alc level at which the yeasts die off. This creates a wine with more brawn to stand up to food and also a bit less sweet - with 2/3 of the sugars converting into alc. The yields are beyond low - 8 hectoliters per hectare.

White - Sweet/Dessert
1997 Château de Fargues France, Bordeaux, Sauternais, Sauternes
91 points
Took a while to trully open up and seemed a bit weak at the start. but all that changed with time in the glass. richer straw/light gold color, touch of disel on the nose, light apricot, melon, with time more citrus/lemon jello. slightly oily texture, good sweetness, lemon marmelade, medium finish. still more of a dessert than foie gras wine for now. (115 RS)
White - Sweet/Dessert
2001 Château de Fargues France, Bordeaux, Sauternais, Sauternes
93 points
light straw, lots of vanilla and coconut that persisted - needs time to integrate that oak. peach/pear and cinnamon flavors on the nose as well. oily, baked apples and apricots, lush and rich but with a clean and long finish. great acidity. needs time.

Flight 2 - Burgenland (2 notes)

Intrestingly this is a rather young "professional" winegrowing area - developing after WWII, with mr Kracher as one of the pioneers bringing the region into the market. Welshriesling and Chardonay thrive here, while Riesling and Semillon for example - both great sweet wine grapes, do not fare well in the climate. the absence of '03s on the market is easily explained - the hot and dry year did not produce the right conditions for the development of botrytis and most of the wine had to be sold off as bulk. only one TBA was made. compare to 10 in '04 and 15 in the amazing '95. '02 is also one of the top years in the last decade. The mystery of the "Zwischen den Seen" and "Nouvelle Vague" is revealed - the former means "between the lakes" and corresponds to the wines fermented in stainless steel, the later is "new wave" and is aged in new oak.

White - Sweet/Dessert
1999 Alois Kracher Welschriesling TBA #8 Zwischen den Seen Austria, Burgenland, Neusiedlersee
95 points
best nose of the night - going from apricots and caramel to cigar and tea and to marmelade. dak gold wine, lots of spicy (pepper?) notes, still rather sweet, but with high acidity (240 RS, 8.4 acid) ripe oranges and marmelade notes, like tea and cake together..amazing feeling. very long finish.
White - Sweet/Dessert
2004 Alois Kracher Welschriesling TBA #7 Zwischen den Seen Austria, Burgenland, Neusiedlersee
92 points
a baby and very difficult to judge. gold color, apricots, perfume, ripe fruit, spice. seemingly light (umm 240RS and 6.8 acid) oily - really coats the mouth. finish is VERY sweet now - will need time to come into its own. delicious!

Flight 3 - Saar (2 notes)

the chance to speak one-on-one to Herr Mueller was the biggest treat. the topic was obvious - 2003. I am seemingly in the minority when i proclaim these to be capable of long aging. Well - Herr Mueller compared them to the '59. He said when '59s were young people said they wont age, and thats how they tasted...and he said when he opens a bttl now he still feels that way - that its young and wont age...then again - its been 50 years :)
His TBAs are rare..this '05 was a HUGE crop... HUUUUUGE....200 bttls released...(.375) ... HUGE! the price as some of you know is somewhere in the statosphere.. but if you can - do it! best flight and best wine of the day...not at all biased - actually expected the hungarian wines to floor me..but not after the '05 and to be fair they were way too young.

White - Sweet/Dessert
1976 Egon Müller Scharzhofberger Riesling Trockenbeerenauslese Germany, Mosel Saar Ruwer
96 points
Not shoeing all it has today - and is in an awkward position - a bit too young for maturity and too old for fruity goodness... BUT its still was one of the top 3 today.
dark gold, started out silent but quickly developed, apples, custard, touch of petrol (but slight) apricots. Rich and young on the palate, sweet fruit and amazing zing of acidity. feels young - much younger than the '99 Kracher and '97 Fargues. a WOW... untill one smells the '05 ...
White - Sweet/Dessert
2005 Egon Müller Scharzhofberger Riesling Trockenbeerenauslese Germany, Mosel Saar Ruwer
98 points
ungodly ambrosia... ridiculous stuff. (price to match but...) eiswine-like zing (350 RS!!! 5.5 alc, 15 acid) flowers, sweaty riesling nose, apricots, nailpolish. on the mouth - pure power, burn-your-throat acid streak, light and pure - no sign of botrytis-caused heft, unending finish... this is a legend in the making.
1 person found this helpful Comment

Flight 4 - Tokaj (2 notes)

This is the new face of Tokaj it seems.. perhaps i am wrong but to me this is a different approach than what i had seen before and i am not complaining. these wines tasted more "modern" (its the wrong word i know) - gone is the oxidative, orange syrop/marmelade melange - this is clean, with razor-like acidity and amazing finish... but in its infant-hood - the oak is very prominant and truthfully surprisingly so. The 6 putt. is a wine i hope to buy and loose for 20+ years in the cellar. the Esszencia i know i wont be able to afford - but it is something otherworldly. how can something with 600RS have such balance? (3% alc)

White - Sweet/Dessert
2002 István Szepsy Tokaji Aszú 6 Puttonyos Hungary, Tokaji
93 points
too young. oak, caramel, dry pineapple nose. vanilla on the palate, oak needs time to integrate, TBA-like clarity, excelent balance and acidity. long finish. This is the new face of Tokaji ... and WOW :)
White - Sweet/Dessert
1999 István Szepsy Tokaji Essencia Hungary, Tokaji
96 points
ummm yeah.. well it just bottled so its less than imposible to judge. also we are talking 600 RS, 3% alc...and yet its clean clear and bright...how? dont ask me. like in the previous wine - the oak shows. spices and orages/lemons, sweet sucking candy, amazingly pure... WOW.

Closing

Thanks again - an unforgetable afternoon!

© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close