simple. drank a little too warm. red apple flavors.

green apple & yeast. candy-like finish.

green apple and underripe pear with a hint of yeast.

poached red apple and green apple, pear, yeast, medium acid level. very nice -- tasted twice consistently.

nose of sweaty red apple, probably funk from the bottle age... recovers on the palate, but doesn't deliver what i would expect.

green apple and ripe pear. not enough acid in this. fruit carries well through the finish.

vegetal -- broccoli/spinach. green apple. bubbles are a little too aggressive on the palate.

oak -- toast/wood/vanilla, red apple. nice mouthfeel -- bubbles gently caress the tongue.

stinky pear, toast, butter. medium acid, medium(-) finish.

simple green apple flavors. a little heat on the finish.

cat pee nose, green apple, pleasant palate, med (-) finish

sweaty socks on nose, green apple and underripe pear.

vegetal/artichoke or asparagus, ripe green apple, ripe pear. med acid, med(+) finish

green apple, yeast, medium(+) acid

grape nose. red mcintosh apple palate. rather simple.

doughy unbaked apple turnover. green apple and yeast and hint of red fruit (strawberry) medium finish. tasted twice. a new house champagne?

something off on nose, palate simple and watery, green apple/grapey. don't think this was a bad bottle, but really outclassed.

yeasty/bready nose, red apple

watery green apple with a hint of RS, smooth mouthfeel.

red apple & strawberry, simple but pleasant short finish

green apple & yeast.

wet dough/red apple. bubbles a bit forward on palate. med (+) finish

yeast/biscuit on nose w/ green apple. med (+) acid, well integrated. medium finish.

simple apple flavors w/ strawberry notes. yeast on palate.

yeasty nose , green apple flavors. wish i had a better note for this.

doughy flavors with green apple -- acidity almost makes it taste like crabapple.

red apple, pear, medium acid, medium finish

red apple, ripe pear. med(-) acid. needs more flavor on the finish.

pear/red apple

good mix of fruit and yeast, well balanced acid

simple flavor -- tastes diluted. medium finish is quite pleasant

green apple, crisp acidity. simple fruit-forward champagne

red apple, med(+) acid, medium finish

yeast, greena nd red apple, medium(+) finish. wonderful mouth feel, a pleasure to drink

red apple with minerality, medium acid, but could use a little more.

drank a little too warm. strawberry and red apple, medium(+) acid

complex -- yeast, strawberry, red apple, and much more is there. medium(+) finish.

too much acid. green apple.

green and red apple, biscuit, yeast. really enjoyable, one of the top champagnes tasted.

green and red apple, medium finish. very nice.

green apple, bread dough, minerality. medium acid, medium(+) finish. This is outstanding!

well balanced. green apple, medium(+) acid, medium finish

cat pee on nose, green apple, medium acid, medium(-) finish

green and red apple, strawberry. medium acid, medium finish.

yeast, clearly younger than the other dom, green apple and underripe pear, medium(+) finish.

yeast, burnt bread, caramel, red apple, caramelized pears. one of the more complex champagnes at the tasting due to the age. tasted twice.

"yeasty urine" is what I wrote... some green apple and strawberry. medium(+) finish

wow. very interesting nutmeg/sweet spice aromas. green apple. medium(+) finish. my favorite wine of the tasting, despite being up against better pedigrees, higher prices.

spice, red apple, biting acidity -- a little too sharp, even for my tastes. medium(+) finish

green and red apple, yeast, ripe pear, medium body, medium(+) finish. excellent mouthfeel.