2004 champagne horizontal
110 Taillevent London
Tasted January 30, 2020 by BenBlu with 684 views
Introduction
The champagne super group convened again, this time the task was to evaluate the 2004 vintage. Comprehensively. It turned out we had 42 champagnes from the vintage when all was said and done, a mammoth task over one dinner for 12 people. The wines were kind of single blind with the exception of the 6 we had for aperitif. Thereafter what was known was that it was going the Blanc de Blancs, then top white champagnes non BdB, then Roses and then the tail of others.
Flight 1 - Warm up non blind help yourself (6 notes)
White - Sparkling
N.V. Krug Champagne Brut Grande Cuvée Edition 160eme
France, Champagne
One of the stand out wines of the night. Lovely nose of roast hazelnuts, palate following through nicely, balance and richness. Will get even better with more age and in similar vein of great Krug NV #151. (clearly) Better than Krug 2004 vintage tasted later.
Flight 2 - Blanc de Blancs (9 notes)
White - Sparkling
2004 Taittinger Champagne Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs Brut
France, Champagne
On the nose this was something else and I immediately had this down for Comtes. My high hopes for this wine were confirmed and turned out to be one of the if not the WOTN. Toasty, nutty, salty. I love this and think this is going to be even greater with another 5-10 years in bottle. A screaming MUST BUY! Happy to have two cases but arguably one should be backing up the truck and stock up massively here. This is going to be in the vein of the great 1995.
White - Sparkling
2004 Krug Champagne Clos du Mesnil
France, Champagne
A privilege to encounter this wine again within a few months. This time blind I was able to spot it. This had stealth, crispy mineral zip, very dry and laser like precision. This will benefit from another 10 years. Frankly though, as good an impressive as this was my nod here goes to the more hedonistic Comte de Champagne. Bearing in mind that you can get 10 Comtes for one of the Krug Clos du Mesnil an easy choice for the non billionaires.
Flight 3 - White (not Blanc de Blancs top flight) (11 notes)
White - Sparkling
2004 Bollinger Champagne Vieilles Vignes Françaises
France, Champagne
Bottle 2062/4208. My third time with this champagne. Here blind the darker colour vs others was obvious and a bit of a give away. Getting better with temperature as this always does revealing lovely nougat tones. I loved this. Others were less convinced.
White - Sparkling
2004 Henri Giraud Champagne Grand Cru Argonne Brut
France, Champagne, Champagne Grand Cru
Oak oak oak. Yes it is obvious. Clearly identified by all blind. Very distinctive and I think I liked this. But there was a bit of consensus that it was a bit of a "cheap whore". Just too obvious. Probably lay down for 10 years and see if the oak integrates more.
White - Sparkling
2004 Krug Champagne Vintage Brut
France, Champagne
Racy, mineral and then some nice richness from the oak with good depth. Not as good as Krug NV 160eme. And a weaker vintage for Krug or maybe it needs more time. Still a good wine.
White - Sparkling
2004 Dom Pérignon Champagne
France, Champagne
Oh boy is this Dom 2004 coming along strongly as of late. I totally underrated this vintage of Dom 5 years ago. I already remarked a few months back when I tasted this that Dom 2004 is really starting to show right now. Here we got proof and in fact this was my WOTF and tied WOTN! An amazing bottle of Dom this - lovely reduction, wow, electrifying. The group all picked this up as Dom. I think this is the new 1995 and I love 1995. Go stock up on this while it's still "cheap"!
White - Sparkling
2004 Louis Roederer Champagne Cristal Brut
France, Champagne
Red cassis and apple centre, a lot packed in there as if you took 1.5 glasses and reduced it to 1 glass - guessed Cristal. Very good showing. If a bit overshadowed this time by the Dom Perignon in the glass just before.
Flight 4 - Rose flight (8 notes)
Rosé - Sparkling
2004 Pommery Champagne Cuvée Louise Brut Rosé
France, Champagne
I don't like Pommery. Reminded why. For a prestige cuvee unacceptable. Rose is almost colourless. Easy to spot. But that of course is not the issue. The palate is just so unexciting that if it was a generic NV it would just about pass. But prestige cuvee in a good vintage? Nahhh...
Rosé - Sparkling
2004 Ruinart Champagne Dom Ruinart Brut Rosé
France, Champagne
From magnum. Curve ball thrown by sommelier serving this to us twice (glass number 28 and number 30). Nobody got it. However I noted this both times quite pleasantly and ranked highly. Pure, concentrated, translucent in appearance, ethereal. Really good showing.
Flight 5 - Final flight blanc others (4 notes)
Here my concentration really went and I am not listing all the wines.
White - Sparkling
2004 Gosset Champagne Célebris
France, Champagne
Came out very late, I usually rate this cuvee and last year I would say the 2002 was my surprise champagne outperformer of the year. Here it didn't show so well. I actually like the standard vintage better from memory.
Closing
Another wonderful evening and great privilege to examine a vintage with this group. Many very generous contributions indeed and thanks to all for that and to Peter for organising. Also 110 Taillevent in London is the perfect venue for this kind of event under the expert guidance of sommelier Christopher and his great team.
The conclusions were that 2004 is a good but not a very good vintage. The Blanc de Blancs probably overall did best. Generally the quality was quite close together, quite homogeneous.
My top wines of the evening were Comte de Champagne, Dom Perignon (given the still "modest" price tag these 2 are MUST BUYS!!!!), Clos du Mesnil, Bollinger VVF (this one not unanimous but for me great) and Krug NV 160eme (2004 base vintage of course).
Given the amount of wines tasted in the context of great company and food the notes here are of course short and directional only.
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.